It'll be interesting to see how Telltale will handle the traitor's storyline in S2 if you spared him in, it might end up being a way for them to "fix" some of the shoddy writing behind that arc in episode 5.
So I thought for sure that because the sentinel shows up if you have the traitor dead, that would mean my man Duncan would still be alive, but then I saw that you dont see the "death" scene unless the traitor is alive ;-;
So I thought for sure that because the sentinel shows up if you have the traitor dead, that would mean my man Duncan would still be alive, but then I saw that you dont see the "death" scene unless the traitor is alive ;-;
Pray4Duncan
Asher, Talia and Traitor Royland in my canon playthrough.
The three most hot tempered Forresters together. Hopefully it makes for an interesting second season.
I think both your Sentinel and the traitor survive !!!
First the Sentinel, the last time we saw him, he fell to the ground, surround by 3 Whitehills soldiers. That's all, no more !!!
And the traitor, If you choose Gwyn, she'll side by side with you at the end, leaving the fate of your traitor unknown. If you're not choose her, the traitor will take Gwyn's place instead.
I think both your Sentinel and the traitor survive !!!
First the Sentinel, the last time we saw him, he fell to the ground, surround by 3 W… morehitehills soldiers. That's all, no more !!!
And the traitor, If you choose Gwyn, she'll side by side with you at the end, leaving the fate of your traitor unknown. If you're not choose her, the traitor will take Gwyn's place instead.
I do not know the Codex change when the game end - thanks for let me know !!!
Hm, why some other character like Ysera - VIsera, Eleana, Ludd, Gwyn, Gryff ... do not appear in Codex ???
If you kill the traitor then your sentinel shows up, if you spare the traitor your sentinel dies and the traitor shows up. If you have Asher and decide to call off the plan Gwyn shows up.
Asher, Talia and Traitor Royland in my canon playthrough.
The three most hot tempered Forresters together. Hopefully it makes for an interesting second season.
The sad thing is that even though I feel like Asher's storyline is better than rodriks, Asher has so many more interesting determinant stuff, Gwynn appearing at the end, having a battle play out different for everybody, Rodrik has no determinant scenes, why couldn't Eleana appear at the end of episode 6 if you let her stay
The sad thing is that even though I feel like Asher's storyline is better than rodriks, Asher has so many more interesting determinant stuff… more, Gwynn appearing at the end, having a battle play out different for everybody, Rodrik has no determinant scenes, why couldn't Eleana appear at the end of episode 6 if you let her stay
Why didn't they allow her to, it is a shame because telltale really liked Asher's storyline much more,'I just wished the stories were equal to each other. Now We may never see Elena
I forgot to mention that she can leave if you tell her to go. What didn't make sense is that the option "You don't belong here" sounds very negative to tell her that and I said "This is war" which affected nothing. You disappoint me, Telltale.
Why didn't they allow her to, it is a shame because telltale really liked Asher's storyline much more,'I just wished the stories were equal to each other. Now We may never see Elena
I forgot to mention that she can leave if you tell her to go. What didn't make sense is that the option "You don't belong here" sounds very negative to tell her that and I said "This is war" which affected nothing. You disappoint me, Telltale.
I do not know the Codex change when the game end - thanks for let me know !!!
Hm, why some other character like Ysera - VIsera, Eleana, Ludd, Gwyn, Gryff ... do not appear in Codex ???
Gwyn, I wanted peace and we had like 20 soldiers vs 500 Whitehill men. We ain't winning that, even if we somehow managed to kill both Ludd and Gryff I had a feeling Harys would rally them.
I don't think Whitehills wanted peace, they'd have made the Forresters slaves. Gwyn was using Asher, she never cared that his brother was killed and I don't know if Asher and Talia should trust her.
Gwyn, I wanted peace and we had like 20 soldiers vs 500 Whitehill men. We ain't winning that, even if we somehow managed to kill both Ludd and Gryff I had a feeling Harys would rally them.
I don't think Whitehills wanted peace, they'd have made the Forresters slaves. Gwyn was using Asher, she never cared that his brother was killed and I don't know if Asher and Talia should trust her.
she saves you 2 times
the first : from a soldier who saw you killing gryff
and instead of being pissed off at you like if you double cross her
she butchers that soldier and saves you
the second: like royland or duncan she saves you in the ending and as a bonus the codex says the traitor or your sentinel is still with you
I don't think Whitehills wanted peace, they'd have made the Forresters slaves. Gwyn was using Asher, she never cared that his brother was killed and I don't know if Asher and Talia should trust her.
Comments
It'll be interesting to see how Telltale will handle the traitor's storyline in S2 if you spared him in, it might end up being a way for them to "fix" some of the shoddy writing behind that arc in episode 5.
Is it possible to have both Gwyn and either Duncan or Ser Royland?
I dunno
I had traitor Duncan and Talia. Anyone have any idea what determines who you get?
So I thought for sure that because the sentinel shows up if you have the traitor dead, that would mean my man Duncan would still be alive, but then I saw that you dont see the "death" scene unless the traitor is alive ;-;
Pray4Duncan
Yes, actually Royland and Duncan (one of them) always survive.
If the traitor's alive, the codex says that the sentinel died. I'm not sure what it says if Rodrik killed the traitor.
Do they show up with Gwyn and Talia in the end?
In my playthrough, Talia was with the traitor, Royland while my sentinel, Duncan was still at Ironrath.
Is it wrong to consider changing my decision of killing the traitor just to keep the sentinel alive?
Asher, Talia and Traitor Royland in my canon playthrough.
The three most hot tempered Forresters together. Hopefully it makes for an interesting second season.
Same, although Royland is sentinel in my playthrough
The brother with Talia and Duncan (the traitor)
No, but in the codex says that they are alive.
Talia was with Gwyn in my playthrough. I guess that's an unpopular outcome?
I'm just relieved that the codex states that Royland's 'whereabouts are unknown', because I love my Sentinel and if he were dead I would be very sad.
I think both your Sentinel and the traitor survive !!!
First the Sentinel, the last time we saw him, he fell to the ground, surround by 3 Whitehills soldiers. That's all, no more !!!
And the traitor, If you choose Gwyn, she'll side by side with you at the end, leaving the fate of your traitor unknown. If you're not choose her, the traitor will take Gwyn's place instead.
In the Codex it said that the Sentinel was killed.
I do not know the Codex change when the game end - thanks for let me know !!!
Hm, why some other character like Ysera - VIsera, Eleana, Ludd, Gwyn, Gryff ... do not appear in Codex ???
If you kill the traitor then your sentinel shows up, if you spare the traitor your sentinel dies and the traitor shows up. If you have Asher and decide to call off the plan Gwyn shows up.
Same here.
Perhaps they're wherever Talia and Gwyn planned to take Rodrik/Asher?
Ended with Talia and Gwyn
My choices exactly
My sentinel (Royland)
Maybe too late, but traitor Duncan saved Asher. (in my playthrough)
The sad thing is that even though I feel like Asher's storyline is better than rodriks, Asher has so many more interesting determinant stuff, Gwynn appearing at the end, having a battle play out different for everybody, Rodrik has no determinant scenes, why couldn't Eleana appear at the end of episode 6 if you let her stay
She was taken by Whitehills
Why didn't they allow her to, it is a shame because telltale really liked Asher's storyline much more,'I just wished the stories were equal to each other. Now We may never see Elena
I forgot to mention that she can leave if you tell her to go. What didn't make sense is that the option "You don't belong here" sounds very negative to tell her that and I said "This is war" which affected nothing. You disappoint me, Telltale.
What also is weird is that we never know what happened to her in Asher's play through. She could have been captured or she could have left
She definetly left because she did see Rodrik dead. She didn't have anything else to do, she probably doesn't care much for Asher.
She probably did leave, but the white hills swarmed iron rate so anything could have happened to her
I think it's only the original cast of the game (Forrester household) that they made pages for. Maybe in season 2 we'll have more pages!
Gwyn, I wanted peace and we had like 20 soldiers vs 500 Whitehill men. We ain't winning that, even if we somehow managed to kill both Ludd and Gryff I had a feeling Harys would rally them.
Exact same haha
I don't think Whitehills wanted peace, they'd have made the Forresters slaves. Gwyn was using Asher, she never cared that his brother was killed and I don't know if Asher and Talia should trust her.
´´gwyn was using asher´´ did you even see the ending with gwyn at all?
she saves you 2 times
the first : from a soldier who saw you killing gryff
and instead of being pissed off at you like if you double cross her
she butchers that soldier and saves you
the second: like royland or duncan she saves you in the ending and as a bonus the codex says the traitor or your sentinel is still with you
i ended with gwyn with asher
My main character always varies
I either have to dirk or Asher
But my companions are always the same I am with talks and sentinel Royland
Yep. How do you think he'll redeem himself?