What do you think was better, BioShock 1 or BioShock Infinite?
I prefer Infinite. It had better story. I liked the duo of Booker and Elizabeth. And TBH, I used to ship them until I figured out that they were actually father and daughter. 1 had better gameplay, but Infinite had better story. So, Infinite it is.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Bioshock 2.
1 > 3 > 2
I just couldn't get into 2.
Yeah, me neither. I got through the first thirty minutes of it, and decided to stop playing. Hated it so much.
The original. Infinite's gameplay was so dumbed down it isn't even close for me.
I guess I prefer Bioshock infinite because Booker had a character. They both had great twist though.
If I had to order all 3 games in the order I enjoyed them though, Id have to go Infinite, 2, 1.
The original for the story, 2 for the very fun gameplay and combat system.
I loved many things about Infinite (particularly the atmosphere) but it was a step down and a huge disappointment after the more open world and more politically complicated game we were promised in early development.
Bioshock 1, I just preferred the underwater Rapture setting.
Bioshock 1, easily for both the story and the gameplay. Bioshock Infinite is extremely overrated.
Bioshock 1, I found infinite's story confusing as hell and the ending was just nonsensical.
Bioshock 1 had better atmosphere and exploration based gameplay. Infinite had a better story and character development.
I preferred Bioshock 1 and i liked the underwater setting more and it seemed slightly more creepy and isolated along with a better verity of tonics.
All of the BioShock games are good games in their own right,
Personally, based on story alone, I would favour the first one. With that said, I feel as if Infinite comes in as a close second with the story (mainly because of the characters involved).
For gameplay, I definitely prefered BioShock 2, and I especially loved Minerva's Den; it is one of the few DLCs that I have bought and considered fully worth it. But between choosing the first and Infinite, I would go with Infinite.
Bioshock 1 was the best.