Looking at marcost3's review made me think of something: What if it had been Christa who had been captured by Troy and was staring at Clementine instead of Jane?
Not really, seeing as they were wearing regular clothes instead of the vest and/or army clothing that his group seemed to prefer and they seemed pretty base.
Now that you mention it, it's entirely possible that Carver could've hired them to track down the Cabin Group, given that they were deadset on knowing if she had a group.
Its also worth noting that should Clementine be caught by Winston early on, he starts dragging her in the others general direction for a bit before Victor shows up. He say something(dont recall) and says he can just get rid of Clementine, to which Winston pulls out his gun with "gladly."
I'm mixed on what her take on the walkietalkie plan would be. On one hand, she would like having an intelligence advantage over Carver, who doesn't think the herd will be a problem; on the other, she would also be able to forsee the possibility of Taavia noticing the missing walkie talkies and Luke accidentally turning in to another signal.
Looking at marcost3's review made me think of something: What if it had been Christa who had been captured by Troy and was staring at Clementine instead of Jane?
Alrighty Jane fans, help me out here: What are her redeeming qualities and/or likable traits that make you like her despite her faults and wrongdoings?
Stepping into something of a visible mine field here since I'm smart/obsessive enough to have thought this out for myself but I want to know what other people have to say on the subject nowadays:
Can someone please tell me how exactly Sarah dying at all is supposed to prove Jane right?
The reasoning for its existence was pretty obvious, especially for a Sarah connoisseur such as yourself.
I swear, for a second, I thought you were implying that I'm eatin' Sarah. Dangit, Cilan and Burgundy!
Anyways, I really like that interpretation. I've been thinking about it, and that does work really well.
Well, that's the tragedy of the episode as a whole. It has these amazing moments with symbolism, characterization, and dialogue, but some of the choices they make are some of the worst storytelling I've seen in a while.
As to your thoughts, hmmm I like. My body is satisfied.
Yeah, keep it in the bathroom, pal.
I honestly found all of the trailer scene alterations to be satisfying. The "canon death" (I love that pun so much) was a different story.
Yeah, the canon death really does pretty much shit all over the firs one. Also, that pun was totally intended, he lied.
Yeah, I kind of figured you weren't referring to her first expression. The reasoning for its existence was pretty obvious, especially for a … moreSarah connoisseur such as yourself. You know your stuff on a lot of topics relating to this game, but when it comes to Sarah, you really know your stuff. Though I still figured, hey, why not be captain obvious here?
Anyways, I really like that interpretation. I've been thinking about it, and that does work really well. It makes the trailer slap a lot more poignant, and a lot less insulting. (I personally didn't find it to be too bad on that front, but a lot of others did. Clementine's expression after the slap was a little...well, you know) They made it so two of the people Sarah cared about hurt her with her well-being in mind. When her father struck her, she was completely incredulous and saddened, and not quite able to comprehend why he did so despite Clementine's prodding and explanations. When Cle… [view original content]
lets see. all of pete's scenes [ why did he have to die so early?]
i enjoyed jane as a character...never gonna do her ending tho i can't… more see any of my clem's justifying going with her after she endangered the baby.
the campfire scene in episode 5 still gets me as it is a clam before the storm moment.
both beginnings in episode 2 are good.
and the carver confrontation at the end of episode 2 was intense.
The worst to me were Kenny and Carver with those costume store mustaches and Jolene's toothbrush hair. And Sarita looked kind of like a dark-skinned Katjaa in my opinion. Everyone else was ok. Eddie had a cool design. I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
Apparently, the writers/develops intentionally hyped up people during the production of Season 2 later episodes by hinting at something using the term "Pizza or Ice Cream," with Kenny and Luke being the obvious assumption. Since Jane replaced Sarah and Luke in their respective capacities, I asked what party food she would be if Luke is considered Ice Cream.
Ok. I meant say there was a thread with a picture of all of the villains apparently plotting against Clementine and it's the picture that I wanted to see.
Yeah, Carver's design was always a sticking point for me since it told me everything I needed to know. And Kenny's Season 2 design in particular kinda bothers me for a number of reasons despite being fine enough on its own.
Jolene's toothbrush hair
Ew. Talking from experience?
And Sarita looked kind of like a dark-skinned Katjaa in my opinion.
...K? I know Sarita didn't serve that much of a purpose but I never got some of people's comments about her being Katjaa.
Eddie had a cool design
I guess.
I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
I don't like the way Bonnie's vest looks with her hair for some reason, but other than that I agree. In fact, Nick is ironically one of the better designs in Season 2.
The worst to me were Kenny and Carver with those costume store mustaches and Jolene's toothbrush hair. And Sarita looked kind of like a dark… more-skinned Katjaa in my opinion. Everyone else was ok. Eddie had a cool design. I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
Most? I've only seen 5 or 6 people say she was a favorite while most others like her well enough.
Either way, the response she got in comparison to her role makes sense. A common way to add to a character is by giving them a friend or villain that they can interact with. While this can sometimes lead to "Satellite Characters," it does produce some positive results. Paige essentially functioned as a non-related sign that Sam is indeed a good person, she just has a sharp edge to her that makes this difficult to see. And while they makes characters like Sam more likeable, they also get some fans of their own. After all, some people really liked Paige, I like Sarah, and I'm sure most people also like characters in the same vein as them, Katjaa, Omid, Alvin, or even Becca.
So, the affection is more of a contrasting but understandable result to a necessary evil, if you will. There is a thread about over and under rated characters if you want to sufficiently comment specifically on your own thoughts about her.
The worst to me were Kenny and Carver
Yeah, Carver's design was always a sticking point for me since it told me everything I needed … moreto know. And Kenny's Season 2 design in particular kinda bothers me for a number of reasons despite being fine enough on its own.
Jolene's toothbrush hair
Ew. Talking from experience?
And Sarita looked kind of like a dark-skinned Katjaa in my opinion.
...K? I know Sarita didn't serve that much of a purpose but I never got some of people's comments about her being Katjaa.
Eddie had a cool design
I guess.
I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
I don't like the way Bonnie's vest looks with her hair for some reason, but other than that I agree. In fact, Nick is ironically one of the better designs in Season 2.
I meant her hair style resembles a toothbrush, and I liked that Eddie had a piercing since I have some. What don't you like about the vest? Is it the colour?
The worst to me were Kenny and Carver
Yeah, Carver's design was always a sticking point for me since it told me everything I needed … moreto know. And Kenny's Season 2 design in particular kinda bothers me for a number of reasons despite being fine enough on its own.
Jolene's toothbrush hair
Ew. Talking from experience?
And Sarita looked kind of like a dark-skinned Katjaa in my opinion.
...K? I know Sarita didn't serve that much of a purpose but I never got some of people's comments about her being Katjaa.
Eddie had a cool design
I guess.
I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
I don't like the way Bonnie's vest looks with her hair for some reason, but other than that I agree. In fact, Nick is ironically one of the better designs in Season 2.
Comments
How do you think Lily would have handled Carver? Who would win in a battle of mental tactics and who is the overall better survivor
Do you think it's possible that the group that attacked Clem and Christa was with Carver's group?
Looking at marcost3's review made me think of something: What if it had been Christa who had been captured by Troy and was staring at Clementine instead of Jane?
Not really, seeing as they were wearing regular clothes instead of the vest and/or army clothing that his group seemed to prefer and they seemed pretty base.
Now that you mention it, it's entirely possible that Carver could've hired them to track down the Cabin Group, given that they were deadset on knowing if she had a group.
Its also worth noting that should Clementine be caught by Winston early on, he starts dragging her in the others general direction for a bit before Victor shows up. He say something(dont recall) and says he can just get rid of Clementine, to which Winston pulls out his gun with "gladly."
I'm mixed on what her take on the walkietalkie plan would be. On one hand, she would like having an intelligence advantage over Carver, who doesn't think the herd will be a problem; on the other, she would also be able to forsee the possibility of Taavia noticing the missing walkie talkies and Luke accidentally turning in to another signal.
wHaT
What if Christa had been the one bunking up with Mike and Reggie and thus, the one teaching Clementine those tricks?
Who was Pizza and Ice Cream? What does this make Jane?
Alrighty Jane fans, help me out here: What are her redeeming qualities and/or likable traits that make you like her despite her faults and wrongdoings?
Oh yeah, I forgot about Randall for some reason.
Can someone please tell me how exactly Sarah dying at all is supposed to prove Jane right?
I swear, for a second, I thought you were implying that I'm eatin' Sarah. Dangit, Cilan and Burgundy!
Well, that's the tragedy of the episode as a whole. It has these amazing moments with symbolism, characterization, and dialogue, but some of the choices they make are some of the worst storytelling I've seen in a while.
Yeah, keep it in the bathroom, pal.
Yeah, the canon death really does pretty much shit all over the firs one. Also, that pun was totally intended, he lied.
No, this reply isn't late, why do you ask?
Somewhere in this communities, there is a thread with all of the villains apparently plotting against Clementine. Does anyone have a copy of it?
Somewhere in this communities, there is a thread with all of the villains apparently plotting against Clementine. Does anyone have a copy of it?
What do you think the original connection between Luke and Carver was?
Because he was too cool to live.
Pizza and icecream was originally believed to be Kenny and Luke. Jane was unknown at the time.
Okay, I sorta got the gist of that when I decided to look it up when I got the chance. What would we call Jane to go with that theme?
Which characters do you think have the best and/or worst design(s)?
Wait, what?
Never heard of it, sorry.
Father and son...
...
I'm just kidding.
Cookies!
Best: Molly Jane
Worst: The family that appears at the end of S2 E5 if you went with Jane. The Hispanic Molly, red head Carlos and black Duck.
Why do most people on these forums have some kind of affection towards Paige from Michonne? I never understood it.
The worst to me were Kenny and Carver with those costume store mustaches and Jolene's toothbrush hair. And Sarita looked kind of like a dark-skinned Katjaa in my opinion. Everyone else was ok. Eddie had a cool design. I liked Nick, season 2 Bonnie and season 2 Clem also.
Apparently, that's what Luke preferred over Pizza.
Apparently, the writers/develops intentionally hyped up people during the production of Season 2 later episodes by hinting at something using the term "Pizza or Ice Cream," with Kenny and Luke being the obvious assumption. Since Jane replaced Sarah and Luke in their respective capacities, I asked what party food she would be if Luke is considered Ice Cream.
Ok. I meant say there was a thread with a picture of all of the villains apparently plotting against Clementine and it's the picture that I wanted to see.
That was an actual theory I saw a while back and looking at it now, it's entirely possible that may have been the case at one point.
Mmm...Meh. Jane in particular both works and yet also bothers me for various reasons.
Well, those were the easy answers.
Yeah, Carver's design was always a sticking point for me since it told me everything I needed to know. And Kenny's Season 2 design in particular kinda bothers me for a number of reasons despite being fine enough on its own.
Ew. Talking from experience?
...K?
I know Sarita didn't serve that much of a purpose but I never got some of people's comments about her being Katjaa.
I guess.
I don't like the way Bonnie's vest looks with her hair for some reason, but other than that I agree. In fact, Nick is ironically one of the better designs in Season 2.
Most? I've only seen 5 or 6 people say she was a favorite while most others like her well enough.
Either way, the response she got in comparison to her role makes sense. A common way to add to a character is by giving them a friend or villain that they can interact with. While this can sometimes lead to "Satellite Characters," it does produce some positive results. Paige essentially functioned as a non-related sign that Sam is indeed a good person, she just has a sharp edge to her that makes this difficult to see. And while they makes characters like Sam more likeable, they also get some fans of their own. After all, some people really liked Paige, I like Sarah, and I'm sure most people also like characters in the same vein as them, Katjaa, Omid, Alvin, or even Becca.
So, the affection is more of a contrasting but understandable result to a necessary evil, if you will. There is a thread about over and under rated characters if you want to sufficiently comment specifically on your own thoughts about her.
For the sake of answering my own question, I'll briefly throw out a few:
Which remind's me of another question...
How does a thread about either Character Designs or Fashion Statements sound?
I actually like Kenny's design in season two better then in season one.
Fashion statements... In a zombie apocalypse?
Eh, could work.
Oh really?
I'm gonna assume you mean the thread, but I meant who has the best look to them.
I meant her hair style resembles a toothbrush, and I liked that Eddie had a piercing since I have some. What don't you like about the vest? Is it the colour?