Stepping into something of a visible mine field here since I'm smart/obsessive enough to have thought this out for myself but I want to know… more what other people have to say on the subject nowadays:
Can someone please tell me how exactly Sarah dying at all is supposed to prove Jane right?
As shown in the comic series, they do not reanimate. When they are devoured by walkers they only die and remain dead; like, you know, animals in real life.
Are animals affected by the virus and thus, are able to turn?
(Sorry I'm posting so many questions back to back, but I've had no internet/phone connection for a few days.)
Hey, so I was replaying season two again and I noticed something...
So I just wanted to ask a wild question. In episode one after the time skip when you're trying to find something to keep the fire lit with, one of the objects you can examine is a jacket... An old, torn-up jacket. Is this Christa's jacket? If not, then is it...
Jamie's?
Jane did say that Jamie had a leather jacket, and we don't know where she came from. So it's possible, right? But she probably died with it on, so maybe not...
Nah, it was a valid scene. Besides making Mike somewhat fearful of Kenny and his behavior, it also showed that Kenny was a lot more capable than in season 1 and that he even learned Lee's throat crush move :P
Weird thought: Do you think the scene of Kenny wrestling with Mike was pointless? Either way, do you think that scene would've meant more if Jane had replaced one or the other?
Nah, it was a valid scene. Besides making Mike somewhat fearful of Kenny and his behavior, it also showed that Kenny was a lot more capable than in season 1 and that he even learned Lee's throat crush move :P
I'm reading someone's tumblr and amongst their reasons for disliking Luke is the notion that he may have been added to Season 2 fairly late in its initial conception. Do you think there may be some truth to this?
What do you think Clementine's sexuality may be? I know, this is super random, but I feel curious, since poeple start to develop their sexua… morelity and stuff in their teens, and Clem is already 13, which means that writers probably already feel allowed to give her a boyfriend/girlfriend. Also if Kirkman puts more of his work in this season than in the previous ones (just like I heard somewhere around it's going to be), I think we could expect that (and knowing him, even child sex/rape cuz he's frikin crazy).
Edit: I'M SORRY I DIDN'T WANT HATE PLEASE FORGIVE ME PLZ DON'T BAN ME AGAIN BEING SO CLOSE TO ANF PLEASE I DIDN'T WANT ANY OF THIS TO HAPPEND PLEASE SPARE MY LIFE
Okay, I know this probably an obvious question: How does Kenny alone delivering a baby make more sense than Sarah doing it with or without him?
I'm sure that's been asked before but I honestly didn't think about it until a good while ago.
Hey, so I was replaying season two again and I noticed something...
So I just wanted to ask a wild question. In episode one after the tim… moree skip when you're trying to find something to keep the fire lit with, one of the objects you can examine is a jacket... An old, torn-up jacket. Is this Christa's jacket? If not, then is it...
Jamie's?
Jane did say that Jamie had a leather jacket, and we don't know where she came from. So it's possible, right? But she probably died with it on, so maybe not...
I don't know. Just thought I'd put it out there.
I'm replaying season 1. The statistics show Doug having been chose %50 of the time but most people on this forum claim they chose Carley. What do you think caused the discrepancy?
Changing statistics over time, most like. Apparently, Sarah was saved by a majority of people when the episode was initially released according to an interview, but someone made a post a few months ago noting that that had been significantly flipped when they played.
I'm replaying season 1. The statistics show Doug having been chose %50 of the time but most people on this forum claim they chose Carley. What do you think caused the discrepancy?
With the Kenny thing, to be fair, we're typically seeing him in season 2 from an upward angle because of Clementine's shorter height, giving… more him the appearance of being taller. We usually see Kenny at eye-level as Lee so we don't have that augmented perception of how tall he is.
In episode 5, Jane said Carver maybe had a job and a nice pretty wife. Now, I know she's just saying this to influence Clementine to turn against Kenny, but...was there ever any implication besides this that Carver once had a job and a wife?
I think I heard someone say that there's an unused line suggesting he did have a wife, but other than that no. Plus, Jane isn't the most reliable source of that information anyway.
In episode 5, Jane said Carver maybe had a job and a nice pretty wife. Now, I know she's just saying this to influence Clementine to turn against Kenny, but...was there ever any implication besides this that Carver once had a job and a wife?
Controversial Topic that might need its own thread but I have to ask: If Kenny (and Jane) wasn't so prominent or even existent in Season 2, who do you think could've filled the same purposes assuming the story beats would be basically the same?
Usually that means someone got banned and it automatically reverts to the first avatar you get when you join the forum. But that thread was … moremade way back in 2012, I joined at the beginning of 2014 back in January but before joining I lurked the forums for about 2 or 3 months. Back then I remember there being a limited set of avatar pictures you could choose from, unlike today where there's a different variety and you can select one that you like or make a gravatar and choose whatever you want to put as your pic.
My guess is that since it was way back in 2012 that there weren't a lot of avatars to choose from yet, so that's why most of those people were using the yellow and green Ben avatar and some of them probably haven't been on the forums in a long time so they didn't change it. Also I remember there being a dislike button that was removed because of dislike trolls. The like and dislike button was also something that wasn't added way ba… [view original content]
In episode 5, Jane said Carver maybe had a job and a nice pretty wife. Now, I know she's just saying this to influence Clementine to turn against Kenny, but...was there ever any implication besides this that Carver once had a job and a wife?
The majority of users who use that platform are entitled assholes, and they will become angered if you edit those articles.
Don't even mention Vernon's status.
Comments
It's not supposed to prove Jane right.
As shown in the comic series, they do not reanimate. When they are devoured by walkers they only die and remain dead; like, you know, animals in real life.
I can sympathize with her, but I am not too emotionally attached. This could be due to the fact that I haven't seen her for two years.
Why was season two episode five's original title Better To Sleep? Was the original plan very different to what it is now?
Sorry if this has already been asked before, I was just wondering.
Hey, so I was replaying season two again and I noticed something...
So I just wanted to ask a wild question. In episode one after the time skip when you're trying to find something to keep the fire lit with, one of the objects you can examine is a jacket... An old, torn-up jacket. Is this Christa's jacket? If not, then is it...
Jamie's?
Jane did say that Jamie had a leather jacket, and we don't know where she came from. So it's possible, right? But she probably died with it on, so maybe not...
I don't know. Just thought I'd put it out there.
Nah, it was a valid scene. Besides making Mike somewhat fearful of Kenny and his behavior, it also showed that Kenny was a lot more capable than in season 1 and that he even learned Lee's throat crush move :P
The "I'd eat the shit out of that racoon" one?
If so, then no. If you read it literally, you'd get it.
Well, I would hope not, but that's how a number of people take it or at least think was the reason for that.
Oh yeah, you're right! Okay then, I guess it wasn't pointless Kenny stuff then.
Okay, I know this probably an obvious question: How does Kenny alone delivering a baby make more sense than Sarah doing it with or without him?
I'm sure that's been asked before but I honestly didn't think about it until a good while ago.
I'm reading someone's tumblr and amongst their reasons for disliking Luke is the notion that he may have been added to Season 2 fairly late in its initial conception. Do you think there may be some truth to this?
eh i'm guessing maybe bi-curious? she doesn't have much experience with couples and all that other than Jane and Luke banging. xD
I'm not sure I understand the question?
Kenny has experience with these things, he used to be a father.
And that's pretty much the main issues of debate here, particularly from a writing standpoint.
Okay, apparently there's a scene where Kenny threatens to slap Clementine. Is this really a thing?!
In the truck in No Going Back when you're talking to Kenny, after he mentions Lee, if you say "maybe he shouldn't have", he threatens you.
Oh, that's right! It really has been a while since my first playthrough.
I thought is was a vest and a puffer style similar to the coat Clementine wears.
I'm replaying season 1. The statistics show Doug having been chose %50 of the time but most people on this forum claim they chose Carley. What do you think caused the discrepancy?
Changing statistics over time, most like. Apparently, Sarah was saved by a majority of people when the episode was initially released according to an interview, but someone made a post a few months ago noting that that had been significantly flipped when they played.
I believe it is meant to be taken sexually; yes.
Considering how Clementine and Bonnie react, I'm gonna say yeah. Which says...interesting things about Clementine.
True.
No this reply isn't late, why do you ask?
In episode 5, Jane said Carver maybe had a job and a nice pretty wife. Now, I know she's just saying this to influence Clementine to turn against Kenny, but...was there ever any implication besides this that Carver once had a job and a wife?
I think I heard someone say that there's an unused line suggesting he did have a wife, but other than that no. Plus, Jane isn't the most reliable source of that information anyway.
Repeat Questions because why not?
Controversial Topic that might need its own thread but I have to ask: If Kenny (and Jane) wasn't so prominent or even existent in Season 2, who do you think could've filled the same purposes assuming the story beats would be basically the same?
Can someone give me a decent description of Clementine's personality in Season 2? I can't seem to find a biography that does so.
The Walking Dead wiki says that Rebecca, Sarita, Sarah(wtf), and Nick(wtf) were working as food handlers. When was this brought up?
Cringes
Jokes aside, I don't think it was.
Do not dare to change it or you will be roasted alive.
People are—funny, there.
i remember what the site looked like before.. memories.
i joined in 2012, 4 years on here went by so fast.
cherish all this while you can.
Time: 1:03:15
Just a matter of time before he actually does slap Clementine...
I have no idea what you're getting at, here.
See, you say that and my first question would be "Which one is the crazy one?," for some reason.
The majority of users who use that platform are entitled assholes, and they will become angered if you edit those articles.
Don't even mention Vernon's status.
"I just shit in their cereal!"
At the very least, it comes off more as a "I don't believe this. How could you say that?" type of thing.
Wait, really?
I thought the joke was his poor choice of words, I would eat the shit out of that raccoon...
Well, apparently Carver was a carpenter. I think...
Isn't her personality determined by the player?
Now I have to go check it.