Evaluating Character Designs

1246713

Comments

  • All I'm saying is, if Jane looked that way in season 2 she wouldn't be in the situation she's in now.

    Kenny's isn't that bad, but Jane's is absolutely terrible

  • Eeh, ...spoilers?(I thought the game was supposed to come out tomorrow?)

    AAA_Jane posted: »

    All I'm saying is, if Jane looked that way in season 2 she wouldn't be in the situation she's in now.

  • For sure

    AAA_Jane posted: »

    All I'm saying is, if Jane looked that way in season 2 she wouldn't be in the situation she's in now.

  • edited December 2016

    What did they do to Kenny?! :O_O: He looks like Whodunit!

    Meanwhile, looks like Jane took a trip back through the uncanny valley because she looks barely more uncanny than she did before. Also, I love how her head looks like it doesn’t belong on her body.

    Edith is easily the best looking, which also makes her look worse than Jane due to the Uncanny Valley hitting her somethin fierce.

    And Baby AJ is clearly a bad render of his Season 2 model with new eyes implanted.

  • I think you got that backwards, pal.

    Kenny's isn't that bad, but Jane's is absolutely terrible

  • huh?

    DabigRG posted: »

    I think you got that backwards, pal.

  • Jane's isn't that bad, but Kenny's is absolutely terrible

    AAA_Jane posted: »

    huh?

  • Kenny, Danny, Marcus, Nate, Carlos, Troy, and Buricko are pretty much stereotypes when stop to look at em. Might as well toss Jane in there too. Though I guess Larry, Doug, Danny, Jolene, Eddie, Michelle, Luke, Carver and Reggie aren't that much better.

  • edited December 2016

    I am glad they gave Javier a beard. He looks like a stereotypical movie high school jock/bully without it.

  • Just because it's fun to make fun of them, I'm gonna have little more fun with the flashback models.

    Kenny is definitely the worst because the moment the camera panned in front of Clementine towards the left, with AJ visible in the background, and then you gradually see what looks like a melting action figure, I was like "Problem!” The funny thing is it looks like they started on his model early on in development They likely didn't get around to making sure they textured it so that he looks like he belongs in-game: as a result, his proportions are relatively the same but everything else is shit, namely his leaf rubbing beard and an eye-patch in place of the bandage-pad.."

    Jane looks even more like something out of Planet of the Apes than she did before, with feathers for hair like the Raptors from Jurassic Park III. Unlike Kenny, she looks like she somewhat belongs in this artstyle but her proportions are pretty bad since her head looks like it doesn’t belong on her body, which is bloated btw. And I love how 5% of that 69 lbs went to her face. Goddamn, when they said it'll go straight to your thighs, they fucking meant it! "That asshole family ran off with half our food," indeed.

    Edith is arguably the best looking of the three, as her proportions make her not look like too much of a humanoid abomination and her textures are fine since she actually fits into this universe. However, she looks simultaneously better and worse somehow though that’s probably just the artshift and the darker colors.

    And since I’ve already commented on AJ, I’ll instead note that “Young!” Clementine appears to be her 13 year-old head after either being attached to a smaller body or they simply dressed her up to make her look younger.

  • Okay, time to talk about things I don't really like:
    enter image description here
    Personally, I hated Becca's Season 2 attire in part because its so similar to Clementine's with very dirty/dark colors, thus I like the original design more for being brighter/cleaner. But when I did that Five Shades of Clementine picture several months ago, I decided that design made the most sense given the other characters are based on that timeline. She was really odd to draw because she is so sleek with a lot of bright colors and I had to try to make sure she shined visually amongst the other characters since she and Jane both have brown hair and comparatively paler skin.
    In fact, now that I'm looking at it, it is basically Jane's color scheme--except darker!
    enter image description here

    With unpleasantness out of the way, I will say that another part of the reason why I like her 400 Days design better is because, in the context of that picture and in the game, we didn't have that many characters who wore open jackets, so that pink blouse and especially that white tshirt popped pleasantly. With that said, that pink blouse is probably my favorite aesthetic wise because it's a neat touch for some detail variety and , like with Michelle, having this infamously mean-spirited character wearing pink is humorous.
    enter image description here

  • edited January 2017

    Dang it I actually planned on makin' this type of character design (my superior topic) thread... oh welp...

    Here's a question that I have been wondering about S2 clothing during winter, what would be more preferable to wear? Unseen out on the open that is.

  • Dang it I actually planned on makin' this type of character design (my superior topic) thread... oh welp...

    How humble of you, mate.:wink:

    Here's a question that I have been wondering about S2 clothing during winter, what would be more preferable to wear? Unseen out on the open that is.

    Not sure what you're asking here, but every character besides Luke and initially Rebecca had a jacket on anyway.

    TheMPerson posted: »

    Dang it I actually planned on makin' this type of character design (my superior topic) thread... oh welp... Here's a question that I have

  • edited January 2017

    Not sure what you're asking here, but every character besides Luke and initially Rebecca had a jacket on anyway.

    What I meant is what new winter articles they could've wore during the winter, I didn't really liked how characters had the same clothes like Luke he just unrolled his sleeves and that's it.

    I would've preferred in that concept art that Clem actually wore a jacket with her cap on.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Dang it I actually planned on makin' this type of character design (my superior topic) thread... oh welp... How humble of you, mate.

  • What I meant is what new winter articles they could've wore during the winter, I didn't really liked how characters had the same clothes like Luke he just unrolled his sleeves and that's it.

    Yeah, I could've unused some alternate costumes too.

    I would've preferred in that concept art that Clem actually wore a jacket with her cap on.

    Where is this?

    TheMPerson posted: »

    Not sure what you're asking here, but every character besides Luke and initially Rebecca had a jacket on anyway. What I meant is wha

  • edited January 2017
    DabigRG posted: »

    What I meant is what new winter articles they could've wore during the winter, I didn't really liked how characters had the same clothes lik

  • Oh yeah, Johnny was originally a North Carolina Bandit. Wonder who that person on the log was supposed to be.

    TheMPerson posted: »

    2nd or 3rd pics

  • edited January 2017

    Gonna post this here because why not.
    enter image description here
    enter image description here
    enter image description here

  • edited January 2017

    The jackets annoy me.

    Why did Lee only wear his badass jacket in episode 2? Hell, the title screen for Ep 4 SHOWS him wearing it again!

    And like Tavia said, that Jacket Bonnie gave Clem was pretty garish and ugly. It would have been nice to have the choice to wear it or not, like the hoodie in season 1

  • Really? It's not about fashion in this game, it's about survival, Clem didn't exactly like the jacket either but it's all she had to keep warm, Clementine has a great jacket in season 3 anyways if you're really worried.

    Louche posted: »

    The jackets annoy me. Why did Lee only wear his badass jacket in episode 2? Hell, the title screen for Ep 4 SHOWS him wearing it again!

  • edited January 2017

    It's not about fashion in this game, it's about survival

    all the more reason for Lee to keep on a thick leather jacket...?

    as for clem, again I was referencing season 1's choice of giving Clem the hoodie or not

    Spodes posted: »

    Really? It's not about fashion in this game, it's about survival, Clem didn't exactly like the jacket either but it's all she had to keep warm, Clementine has a great jacket in season 3 anyways if you're really worried.

  • Well the hoodie still turned about useful for Clem, and I do think Lee should've kept the jacket, but I didn't really care.

    Louche posted: »

    It's not about fashion in this game, it's about survival all the more reason for Lee to keep on a thick leather jacket...? as for clem, again I was referencing season 1's choice of giving Clem the hoodie or not

  • If he had the jacket on, he probably wouldn't have died

    Spodes posted: »

    Well the hoodie still turned about useful for Clem, and I do think Lee should've kept the jacket, but I didn't really care.

  • Nah, having a Jacket doesn't mean that really, plus it would've bit the thin part of the lower sleeve. Lee would've died either way, and honestly needed to, made season 1 a lot more emotional and set Clem's story up very well.

    Louche posted: »

    If he had the jacket on, he probably wouldn't have died

  • Lee didn't get a full chomp, the Jacket probably would have stopped it

    Spodes posted: »

    Nah, having a Jacket doesn't mean that really, plus it would've bit the thin part of the lower sleeve. Lee would've died either way, and honestly needed to, made season 1 a lot more emotional and set Clem's story up very well.

  • edited January 2017

    and Black Dick?

    you got me there

    DabigRG posted: »

    Hoodie-clad Clementine is my favourite design in the series. Yeah, she is definitely one of the best and one of the most iconic imo.

  • I still believe that it would've gone through giving him the small bite, unless Lee was wearing a bunch of pillows around himself, he'd still end up bit.

    Louche posted: »

    Lee didn't get a full chomp, the Jacket probably would have stopped it

  • First thing I noticed.

    BroKenny posted: »

    Sam's tits from TWDM were pretty hot. That's about all i can think of. xD

  • Lol, Becca is only in season 2 for about 10 seconds so why would that bother you?

    But when I did that Five Shades of Clementine picture several months ago,

    the what now?

    With that said, that pink blouse is probably my favorite aesthetic wise because it's a neat touch for some detail variety and , like with Michelle, having this infamously mean-spirited character wearing pink is humorous.

    Depends on your color settings, her shirt was pretty red in my game

    DabigRG posted: »

    Okay, time to talk about things I don't really like: Personally, I hated Becca's Season 2 attire in part because its so similar to Clemen

  • The beard was a massive improvement over that pornstar meets redneck mustache.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Off to a great start, I see: tits in wax museums. Here's a few off the top of my head: I'm not really a fan of Kenny and Carver. Kenn

  • Lol, Becca is only in season 2 for about 10 seconds so why would that bother you?

    Purely an aesthetical nitpick. I know I'm not a mod or a sfm user that can make things using existing models but l just don't like that design very much and would rather use the original if I did.

    the what now?

    This picture of the quintet I drew trying to see if I could draw them with my (admittedly somewhat accommodating) artstyle.
    enter image description here

    Depends on your color settings, her shirt was pretty red in my game

    Neat.

    Louche posted: »

    Lol, Becca is only in season 2 for about 10 seconds so why would that bother you? But when I did that Five Shades of Clementine pictur

  • And like Tavia said, that Jacket Bonnie gave Clem was pretty garish and ugly. It would have been nice to have the choice to wear it or not, like the hoodie in season 1

    Maybe its a thing about having certain tastes cause I actually didn't mind it, especially since cyan and purple seem to be a popular combo, for some reason.

    Louche posted: »

    The jackets annoy me. Why did Lee only wear his badass jacket in episode 2? Hell, the title screen for Ep 4 SHOWS him wearing it again!

  • True. I think my issue was that it made him look more like a stereotypical redneck dressed in somewhat dull, faded colors. Not to mention the eyebandage/patch making him look like a pirate and especially the weird undertones of him and Jane fighting.

    Jimayo posted: »

    The beard was a massive improvement over that pornstar meets redneck mustache.

  • That was a legitimate typo that I decided not to change due to laziness(initially) and because its funny(current).

    Louche posted: »

    and Black Dick? you got me there

  • Lol, tranny granny.

    Omid's cat posted: »

    In the land of the blind... Weird looking grandma! Who did this?! Worst designed character by TTG. Was she representing Mexico in swimmin

  • So as you probably know, I really don't like Carver--from his scruffy appearance, to his shitty color scheme, to his smug psychopathy, to his one-note characterization, to the fact that he looks like a rejected Walker Texas Ranger villain...in a lifetime movie, and even to the fact that he was so hyped up by both the first two episodes and the fanbase--, to the point that I considered him one of the three characters I legitimately hate/loathe.

    With all that being said, this takes the cake:

    enter image description here

    Wow...to think that Rebecca may have cheated on Alvin with THAT. :joy: From what I'm told, that is indeed supposed to be Carver's original model that was apparently left in the game's files. I seriously think they changed that purely because no one could take him seriously if he looked like that. I mean, holy shit, were we really supposed to be intimidated by someone that looks like Han Solo from the Star Wars Holiday Special with a literal horseshoe stache attached?

  • I liked Luke with the hat, but I prefer him without it.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Gonna post this here because why not.

  • Global DeejayGlobal Deejay Banned
    edited January 2017
    • You don't wanna test me girl, I'll pass every time.
    • You should "pass" a razor on that ridiculous mustache of yours. LOLOLOLOLOLOLO
    DabigRG posted: »

    So as you probably know, I really don't like Carver--from his scruffy appearance, to his shitty color scheme, to his smug psychopathy, to hi

  • Man why couldn't the Cabin crew just broke into a fashion mall and let us pick the winter outfits... (like small "breather" moments) I mean if they are able to animate different scars on Clementine, this shouldn't be a big deal.

  • But he has that sexy voice

    DabigRG posted: »

    So as you probably know, I really don't like Carver--from his scruffy appearance, to his shitty color scheme, to his smug psychopathy, to hi

Sign in to comment in this discussion.