The St. Johns Farm Dinner Scene - Season 4
Does this not carry over correctly? I'm certain I stopped Clem from eating any of Mark's leg but she still says she did during the card game.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Does this not carry over correctly? I'm certain I stopped Clem from eating any of Mark's leg but she still says she did during the card game.
Comments
She says i'm joking afterward, so she could be telling the truth but then try to cover it up by labeling it a joke, or she could be joking entirely
Seems like she was very serious, then when the kids were visibly repulsed she tried to say she was joking. Louis even calls her on it.
"I'm kidding."
"Are you though?" with a facial expression of "no you ain't joking, cannibal"
I’ve already head cannoned it as a joke so idc much. Kinda pissed though cos I restarted the entire series just to try and fix it only to find out she says it either way.
Yeah, I really want a chance to clarify that, hopefully it gets brought back up. I don't need the game to remember that I stopped her from eating Mark, but I need the game to give me the chance to say it outright.
Now thats what I call determination
In the middle of from the gallows rn
Pretty sure Season 1 did not log in a lot of choices, such as Lee's last words and wether or not Clementine actually ate Mark's leg. It's a bit strange that Telltale would make this one of the options during the card game, seeing how Clem seems to be serious/downplaying something that really happened when it could in fact not have happened.
Lol really? You did all 3 seasons again just to get to that point? I knew it would have been in there no matter what. It’s the way Telltale are these days.
What if Clem had killed someone and eaten a man’s leg during her time alone with AJ offscreen? I doubt it but how do we know thats not what she meant? Haha
! AJ talks about the ranch being good until the blood. Clem found the ranch, killed everyone and ate their legs and that's why there was blood everywhere lol.
Ahhh good point! That must be it then haha!
On a serious note, i do hope they explain what actually happened at the ranch at some point
I think the line was intended to be interpreted as either a true joke or awkward save, both.
I wonder if anyone actually had Clem eat the leg meat? I wanted to, but Clem was this sweet little girl. And I could do it.
I did let her in my Asshole Lee playthrough of season 1.
Shit... Maybe I got my saves mixed up and I ended up using the Asshole Lee/Clem save for ANF when I replayed last week to get a save ready for TFS.
I’m not the brightest when it comes to telltale
LOL that's sad. I considered my lee to be an asshole as well. But I couldn't let poor Clem eat that meat. Okay maybe my lee was an asshole to everyone else besides clem.
I expect they will talk about it a bit, but it's not really hard to figure out what happened at the ranch, nor does it matter how exactly it went down. All that matters is that the ranch is gone.
I’m interested in the ranch and I really want to know what happened — AJ brought it up so it would suck to never learn what happened there. Especially when he called it “the blood”
It was either overrun by walkers or attacked by an opposing faction to the New Frontier, maybe both. That's "the blood" AJ talked about. I don't really see the relevance of the event to this game tbh, right now it seems unnecessary to delve deeper into it than a few off-hand comments.
But we don’t know if the blood was an enemy faction murdering everyone or Clem killing the people there. That’s why I’m so interested; I just want to know how Clem and AJ we’re reunited.
Nearly 8 hours after posting and several notifications about replies, I just now realized I screwed up the title and for some reason none of you called attention to it. I'm disappointed in you all. I've fixed it, but I had called them St. Martins, not St. Johns.