Which Is More Renowned: the Original S2 Story or the Original S3 Story?

2»

Comments

  • edited November 2018

    Yeah, admittedly I haven't check the Reddit comment's date.
    EDIT: That post was when ANF was wrapping up. @RavenSnowstorm and @BetterToSleep were going on about Capricorn Farms a good while before ANF actually premiered.

    Fangirl101 posted: »

    Um, they quoted the Reddit comment. You know that, right?

  • Season 3,definitely.

    I still can't understand why they cut the slaughterhouse,i just don't fucking get it.

    they even had a "next time" segment for S3 EP2 with the slaughterhouse in it.

    And about season 2..Honestly i don't really care,most people wanted a "darker" story but i thought season 2 was already pretty fucking dark.

  • Cause it stopped making sense for the characters to even go to it.
    Believe me, I tried.

    they even had a "next time" segment for S3 EP2 with the slaughterhouse in it.

    Uh...what?

    iFoRias posted: »

    Season 3,definitely. I still can't understand why they cut the slaughterhouse,i just don't fucking get it. they even had a "next time"

  • edited November 2018

    Cause it stopped making sense for the characters to even go to it.Believe me, I tried.

    Well Clem and Javier were supposed to go there to find their family or some shit.

    Uh...what?

    Yep,someone datamined ANF and found that years later,there's a lot of shit they cut that you can still find it's a mess.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Cause it stopped making sense for the characters to even go to it. Believe me, I tried. they even had a "next time" segment for S3 EP2 with the slaughterhouse in it. Uh...what?

  • edited November 2018

    Well Clem and Javier were supposed to go there to find their family or some shit.

    I know that, I was talking about once they [mostly] decided against the whole evil country slavers plotline.

    Yep,someone datamined ANF and found that years later,there's a lot of shit they cut that you can still find it's a mess.

    A little odd this specific detail never came up before, if so.

    iFoRias posted: »

    Cause it stopped making sense for the characters to even go to it.Believe me, I tried. Well Clem and Javier were supposed to go ther

  • edited November 2018

    wait doesnt this mean they could have easily made the s2 endings matter slightly with that? Since the objective was to rescue AJ and Mariana they could have just added different flashbacks which had the S2 survivor be kidnapped as well if you dint go alone. ((Also how many times was Mariana changed during development? Cause i heard she was hector s daughter at some point, then she s javi s sister and she ended up being David s daughter.))

    Original anf story: Before Michonne and S3 started development -The original story of the "miniseries" was "Javier"'s introduction(most

  • edited November 2018

    I imagine that, if it's true, the sister idea came first, then she became Gabe's cousin through the bulk of development as they started to properly figure out Javier's character and finally, they made her Gabe's sister out of convenience as the premiere's story was being finalized.

    UrbanRodrik posted: »

    wait doesnt this mean they could have easily made the s2 endings matter slightly with that? Since the objective was to rescue AJ and Mariana

  • I don't understand all this slaugherhouse talk. It's honestly nothing to want, there's nothing interesting about it and the supposed story surrounding it is poor. It's just terrible in general, calm your horses. What ya'll should really want is the E3 2016 ANF graphics. That looked so much better, I don't know why they had to mess it up.

    iFoRias posted: »

    Season 3,definitely. I still can't understand why they cut the slaughterhouse,i just don't fucking get it. they even had a "next time"

  • edited November 2018

    The original premise for "Season 3" was definitely sounding like a super Darker and Edgier reboot in a Last of Us country massacre way, what with the brandings and slavery and ...multiple fuckin Slaughterhouses filled with Walkers for some reason. Not to mention the war concept art, talks of a revenge story, and of course, that adrenaline makeover.

    I didn't care much for it.

    Ghetsis posted: »

    I don't understand all this slaugherhouse talk. It's honestly nothing to want, there's nothing interesting about it and the supposed story s

  • I'm telling you, even if the slaughterhouse made it to the final game, we'd only see it for like 10 minutes tops. I guarantee it.

    Everything about it just screams "cool looking throwaway location we'd visit for ~2 scenes" to me.

    Ghetsis posted: »

    I don't understand all this slaugherhouse talk. It's honestly nothing to want, there's nothing interesting about it and the supposed story s

  • edited November 2018

    Well, it was gonna be in Part 1, so...yeah.

    Everything about it just screams "cool looking throwaway location we'd visit for ~2 scenes" to me.

    Not to exacerbate anything, but that was pretty much in stone until I dug up the various screenshots, textures, and concept art for the latter thread.

    Deltino posted: »

    I'm telling you, even if the slaughterhouse made it to the final game, we'd only see it for like 10 minutes tops. I guarantee it. Everything about it just screams "cool looking throwaway location we'd visit for ~2 scenes" to me.

  • By campfire group you mean the 400 days group?

    and I think I heard the "bummer dad" thing before, but I forget where.
    Never heard about the maggot infested rabbit corpse.

    And the idea of Carver outliving his daughter could be interesting, but ultimately might be too much of a retread of Kenny in s1. (why do these two keep getting compared somehow)

    DabigRG posted: »

    The general outlines and initial concepts include * The general premise followed Clementine experiencing the apocalypse unshielded and

  • Of course.

    and I think I heard the "bummer dad" thing before, but I forget where.

    It comes from the Stream Telltale did in the buildup towards ANF's premiere.

    Never heard about the maggot infested rabbit corpse.

    It's at 10:50.

    And the idea of Carver outliving his daughter could be interesting, but ultimately might be too much of a retread of Kenny in s1.

    Yeah, that's likely why they changed it. If it was truly something they considered for very long at all.
    Still, makes the story we ended up with make much more cohesive sense, doesn't it?

    (why do these two keep getting compared somehow)

    Which two? :lol:

    Louche posted: »

    By campfire group you mean the 400 days group? and I think I heard the "bummer dad" thing before, but I forget where. Never heard about

  • Which two? :lol:

    kenny and carlos.
    it's like you said, you could just replace kenny with carlos in episode 3 and 4 and have to change very little.

    HELL, Carlos having that attitude towards Jane would make sense.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Of course. and I think I heard the "bummer dad" thing before, but I forget where. It comes from the Stream Telltale did in the

  • You mean Ties That Bind back when it was not split in two.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Well, it was gonna be in Part 1, so...yeah. Everything about it just screams "cool looking throwaway location we'd visit for ~2 scenes

  • Ah. Got a tad uncertain since any of the two can be.

    Pretty sure Carlos is supposed to be a less take on Lee on the baseline, but as I found, it's inherently easy for him to be associated with Kenny also/instead.

    HELL, Carlos having that attitude towards Jane would make sense.

    Oh yeah.

    Louche posted: »

    Which two? kenny and carlos. it's like you said, you could just replace kenny with carlos in episode 3 and 4 and have to change very little. HELL, Carlos having that attitude towards Jane would make sense.

  • ...Yes.

    Fangirl101 posted: »

    You mean Ties That Bind back when it was not split in two.

  • edited November 2018

    You ever notice how Kenny seems to have no ill feelings towards Jane in episode 3 or 4?
    It's just suddenly written in the last episode.
    He even seems impressed with her in episode 3.

    DabigRG posted: »

    Ah. Got a tad uncertain since any of the two can be. Pretty sure Carlos is supposed to be a less take on Lee on the baseline, but as I fo

  • I barely remember him thinking much of anything on her at all outside of that.
    Does he have a similar line when you come back from the first task if went with Mike and Bonnie first instead?

    Louche posted: »

    You ever notice how Kenny seems to have no ill feelings towards Jane in episode 3 or 4? It's just suddenly written in the last episode. He even seems impressed with her in episode 3.

  • I've actually never went with mike and bonnie first.
    But in Episode 3 Kenny points his thumb at Jane and asks "where'd she come from" in an impressed way with a smirk on his face. (this is when she starts talking and gives them ideas for the escape plan) If the writing were better, I'd say it was intentionally ironic considering he ends up hating her but I doubt that.

    DabigRG posted: »

    I barely remember him thinking much of anything on her at all outside of that. Does he have a similar line when you come back from the first task if went with Mike and Bonnie first instead?

  • I know.

    I've actually never went with mike and bonnie first.

    I honestly forgot that was even an option on my second playthrough however long ago. Partly since the game wants to constantly focus on Jane.

    Louche posted: »

    I've actually never went with mike and bonnie first. But in Episode 3 Kenny points his thumb at Jane and asks "where'd she come from" in an

  • S3's. I can't even imagine what could have been had it not been rewritten in July 2016. I really like the short E3 teaser they released around that time. What a wasted potential...

  • Yes logically I just think I should check up on Jane first. Don't they tell you to do that?

    DabigRG posted: »

    I know. I've actually never went with mike and bonnie first. I honestly forgot that was even an option on my second playthrough however long ago. Partly since the game wants to constantly focus on Jane.

  • It's been a while, but I seem to vaguely recall one of them mentioning that Mike & Bonnie are going to the museum and that Clementine could go with them, but it was in something of an offhand, easy to forget about way.
    Meanwhile, Jane gets Bonnie wondering whether she'll really help or if she'll just leave and Luke walking over to...just be doubtful of that I guess, which draws your attention towards following her.
    It doesn't help that Clementine can say who she'd go after first and then immediately leave for there after letting Luke/Kenny know.

    Louche posted: »

    Yes logically I just think I should check up on Jane first. Don't they tell you to do that?

  • You know, a really good editor with too much time should remake anf into the season 3 we should have had. I mean, its possible right? Now we just have to find someone who actually wants to do that.

  • edited November 2018

    Maybe if ANF used a common engine like Unity a dedicated group of people who know what they’re doing could make something. The problem is ANF uses the Telltale Tool so nobody would spend that much time learning how to use that mess of a program.

    You know, a really good editor with too much time should remake anf into the season 3 we should have had. I mean, its possible right? Now we just have to find someone who actually wants to do that.

  • I think a story board showing the cast, locations, and outcomes of the main major choices might be more feasible. All we need now are some artists with DeviantArt accounts and lots of free time to create those story boards.

    You know, a really good editor with too much time should remake anf into the season 3 we should have had. I mean, its possible right? Now we just have to find someone who actually wants to do that.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.