Lilly is irredeemable end of story !!!!! (Ep. 3 spoilers)

2»

Comments

  • Do you want a cookie for that?

    AronDracula posted: »

    I will never side with Lilly ever again in Season 1. I will always choose to help Kenny kill Larry and leave Lilly behind.

  • What do you mean? It translates from Spanish to English and vice versa.

    Poptarts posted: »

    It also has an english definition, so it'd be difficult for @TheOneTrueBlue to know to put it in google translate to be fair. It just looks like a random word left there that didn't make much sense at the time.

  • Im glad you said that because i did look it up and wouldn’t have known it was a Spanish word and as you said, Vale is an English word for something else

    Poptarts posted: »

    It also has an english definition, so it'd be difficult for @TheOneTrueBlue to know to put it in google translate to be fair. It just looks like a random word left there that didn't make much sense at the time.

  • I want my souls

    Do you want a cookie for that?

  • You mean a valley?

    Im glad you said that because i did look it up and wouldn’t have known it was a Spanish word and as you said, Vale is an English word for something else

  • No se puede.

    AronDracula posted: »

    I want my souls

  • Yep

    You mean a valley?

  • Okay, well, now you know what I meant. Do I still need to respond to your personal message? It is pretty clear why I do not like Kenny.

    Yep

  • Sorry but I'm not killing Lily unless I don't have a choice.

  • edited January 2019

    Stealin #50, witches!

  • Why?

    Sorry but I'm not killing Lily unless I don't have a choice.

  • I don't like killing unless I have to. if I had him kill Lilly he would probably go crazy and start killing more people. he did shoot her 8 times lol

  • Care to elaborate? What tf was ever so unique about Lilly? She was always an authoritarian piece of shit, and she remains one. I just think people want to be criticial to be critical. She is still good ol, power tripping, manipulative, evil, trash Lilly. She deserved to be water boarded in piss then and still does.

    Clemmy1 posted: »

    WHY ??? WHY TELLTAle...Skybound? Why ruin a character like this who had so much uniqueness about her to be turned into just another copy and

  • The fact you hate her so much proves they did a good job with her character.

    ZombieKenny posted: »

    Care to elaborate? What tf was ever so unique about Lilly? She was always an authoritarian piece of shit, and she remains one. I just thi

  • But they didn't.

    The fact you hate her so much proves they did a good job with her character.

  • edited January 2019

    I hated lily all the way back since season 1....now she's gone forever in my playthrough ?

  • They did a good job in making people hate her more is my point. I already explained why I didn’t like the writing for her character in S4

    iFoRias posted: »

    But they didn't.

  • edited January 2019

    Who the fuck else would AJ kill? Cause there is no one anymore to kill in finale. You would just convince Lee not to shoot her just for him to be killed instead? She was NOT defenseless.

    I don't like killing unless I have to. if I had him kill Lilly he would probably go crazy and start killing more people. he did shoot her 8 times lol

  • I wanted to spare her, but there’s NO coming back from this one-way path she was on. Lily was never going to become the good person she once was ever again.

  • Dex-StarrDex-Starr Banned
    edited January 2019

    Lily was a good person in S1:
    Change my mind

  • They may have done a good job but it's not a good job with her character. I don't even mind if we don't get to talk about the past, I just wanted more interesting things to happen. The way how everyone is talking about lily is just making the transition so simple 'she was alright before but now she's bad, isn't it so COOL how the apocalypse changes people?' the apocalypse can change people, but the change should be more than what we had, she doesn't seem like a fully realised character, so much so that you could easily describe her with a few words, as opposed to characters like AJ or Kenny.

    I think this is partly due to screentime. It's because of how the writers give every episode the same freaking plan. The shit always needs to go down in the last Act, because of that we barely got Lily. Unless, unless the writers intentionally gave us less Lily because they wanted to show that at this point Lily shouldn't matter anymore, it reflects her importance. Only that doesn't work because you might play a Clem who is determined to bring her back. Anyway, I enjoyed Abel's character a lot more.

    The fact you hate her so much proves they did a good job with her character.

  • Yeah i can agree there. I said all along that i didn’t think or want Lilly back because they would tarnish her character from how well i felt she was written in Season 1 and i was right. They have effectively ruined her but succeeded in making people hate her even more but not for the right reasons which is what i meant by “good job”.

    Ghetsis posted: »

    They may have done a good job but it's not a good job with her character. I don't even mind if we don't get to talk about the past, I just w

  • edited January 2019

    Ok.....

    Murdered an innocent person over a lost argument ✔️
    Stole an RV even after being forgiven, leaving children to die in the undead world ✔️

    Led to the death of both Lee, Amid and Ben, foiled the boat plan, altered the group forever with selfish decisions? ✔️

    Dex-Starr posted: »

    Lily was a good person in S1: Change my mind

  • How was it Lilly’s fault that Lee, Omid and Ben died?

    But other than that yep, fuck Lilly!

    ZombieKenny posted: »

    Ok..... Murdered an innocent person over a lost argument ✔️ Stole an RV even after being forgiven, leaving children to die in th

  • I'm assuming things with that, but had she not taken the RV, they would have gotten to their destination (the boats) much faster. Possibly before they all went away. I think if she hadn't killed Carly things might have also went smoother. And I think if she was Loyal to the group and stuck around, between her, Carly and having the RV. Clem might not have gotten kidnapped with that much supervision. All hypothetical though.

    How was it Lilly’s fault that Lee, Omid and Ben died? But other than that yep, fuck Lilly!

  • this lad is spitting TRUTH, this game is trying so hard to let me hate her and that's fucking annoying and i feel less enjoyed with her and the latest episode, and for that im keeping her alive despite the game's efforts at all cost, even if that means im ditching the little kid im carrying around

    iFoRias posted: »

    The episode was good but the third act (with lilly in it) almost completely ruined it,yeah she changed,she changed so much that i can't even

Sign in to comment in this discussion.