What did you pick for Lilly in season 1?
Okay, so almost everyone has now seen the "I thought you was dead" scene... Or have they?
Here's my theory:
This scene is determinte on what you picked for Lilly in season 1. The only logical choice is that it's her.
I abandoned her by the road, thus why Clemmy would come to that situation.
However, I never told Omid and Christa what happend to Kenny, thus they can't conclude he died thus wouldn't been able to tell Clementine that he was dead.
The only logical conclusion is the guy I gave water too
or Lilly.
What did you choose? Maybe it links to this and gives us a hint on who it is.
No Kenny fans jumping in going "OMG ITS DEFINTILEY KENNY WE'RE 100% RIGHT EVEN THOUGH WE WAS WRONG ABOUT EVERYTHING ELSE"
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Exactly my point. I didn't tell them Kenny died, thus they cant tell Clementine he died unless from pure supersitution. I was the only one to see it happen.
Think please.
What do you mean, "I never told Omid and Christa what happened to Kenny, thus they can't conclude he died", Clem wasn't even there to see it happen, but Omid and Christa are. SO they would be the ones telling Clem.
Incorrect. No matter what happened to Kenny, Omid and Christa are both there to witness exactly what happened. Hell, one path is Kenny saving Christa. I'm sure they would have told her when she inevitable would have asked "where is Kenny?" Over the last ~20 months you think Clem never asked?
I didn't leave Lily. So Clem has no reason to think she died. She just drove off. And the last scene with the "I thought you were dead"-line shows independently from that.
I dare say, since this scene is the cliffhanger moment, that that scene always looks the same. Though I would like it to be Lily, in the Lily-driving-off-scenario Clems stamement would feel a little wrong if it really was Lily.
edit: oh. I just realize. Lilly is actually spelled "Lilly" instead of "Lily" isn't it? Oh well...
Then that only leaves Christa or Omid.
Omid is only shot in the stomach and possibly COULD of survived that if Christa didn't have the strength to put him down.
The people in that episode look like a cult or something. Why would Kenny join a cult? Unless he's lost it and in which case, I can put him down
They're not there to witness Ben's death scenario, they woudn't need to ask otherwise.
Stop grasping at straws.
They were on the roof right above the alley. They see the walkers come in the alley and swarm from both sides, they hear the gunshot. They can reasonably assume Kenny died, regardless of what Lee actually says.
I left Lilly.
She got what she deserved. In times like those, having a sense of humanity is what is important. Granted, Larry was originally looking out for him and Lilly and vice versa, but they never apologised or attempted to make amends. When given to drop the salt brick on Larry, Larry would have done the exact same thing, but with no remorse. He straight up tried to kill Lee in the drugs store for no reason whatsoever. Those two deserved what they got.
With this family that gave Clem the bum rush, they got what they deserved too. The woman who had the affair deserved to be given a lesson by my Clem. Everybody else, I accepted their apologies, and completely understood their fears about Clem.
I just wish we got the proper chance to talk about Lee. What he did, and how he died.
If there's a single option to tell them that Kenny didn't make it then we can assume that they definitly told Clementine that Kenny is dead. Always remember, TWD is always moving in the same direction, no matter what choices you make.
Omid was shot in the chest. And even if he was shot in the stomach, gut wounds can VERY easily be fatal even with rapid access to medical care. Which he didn't have. I hate to say it, but he's dead.
That leaves Christa, Kenny, or Lilly as the most likely candidates for the "you" Clementine was referring to. And like Made, I didn't leave Lilly on the road either, so Clementine has no real reason to think Lilly was dead. Just no longer with the group.
i left lilly and i dont know why you think its her. Would an older clementine really be talking to her after what lilly did to carly/doug?
Its Molly,Kenny or Christa
While it's POSSIBLE that it's Lilly, I think it would be more likely to be Kenny. In Kenny's final scenes, both of them, from the perspective of Lee, Omid, and Christa, he is cornered and outnumbered. Just because Lee doesn't say "Kenny's dead" doesn't mean that Christa and Omid can't come to that conclusion on their own. When we saw Christa and Clem without Christa's baby after the time skip, what did you think happened? Most players probably thought that the baby was dead, while the characters said absolutely nothing about it. It's the same premise in Kenny's final scenes. Christa and Omid saw him go down to help Ben/save Christa, but he never came back up. They would easily put two and two together and think that he died, and thus tell Clem that.
I left her crazy ass on the side of the road. Think it's very possible that it is Lilly that Clem see's in episode 2 because she looks shocked and kinda unhappy to see them. Clem saw Lilly shoot Carley and was there when Lee made the choice to leave her behind. Of course Kenny would be cool but I just didn't get that "hey its Kenny" vibe from her.
Clementine doesn't really have any reason to believe Christa is dead unless Episode 2 is set a few months ahead again.
(Damn these timeskips)
Considering she was pretty determined Christa was still alive regardless of the options you picked.
It might be Molly, cause she is a kid, she's liable to make assumptions, hence the entire quote "I THOUGHT"
She could easily assume someone like Molly would be dead now, with their determination to always stay alone.
Because she has a chance to speak?
Plus she didn't seem very happy to see the person, if you saw someone you cared about, the first thing you'd say woudn't be "I thought YOU was dead" It seems rather harsh and hurtful to me, usually pointed at someone in a negative way.
If it's someone you cared about, someone like Clem would run upto them and hug them, specially if it's Kenny. But she seemed rather untrustworthy of the person.
If it IS Kenny, her reaction is probably for a good reason, maybe he's changed? Leader of the people that killed the people at the end of episode 1 for example.
Can't be Omid because that'd mean Christa and Clem left him wounded in that gas station without mercy killing him and Christa would not in a million years have let him turn. My Clem didn't shoot Lee, though, so I don't know if she could have done Omid like I had Lee doing to all the people need mercy killing in Season 1.
I can't remember what I did with Lilly, but I liked her, even if she killed someone...
So yeah, I may have did something good for her !
Molly is dead, if you don't help her she dies.
Molly is dead, if you don't help her she dies.
Or what about the woman from Hershal's farm? It got overrun, but we saw nothing of her?
So. If they're coming from both sides, how do YOU propose Kenny escaped from that situation?
Lee was convicted for murder. I'd be edgy around him too if we weren't playing as him. Probably scared too
You don't see her die any more than you see Kenny die.
My clementine wouldn't talk to Kenny after what he did to Larry. Despicable.
What woman? The sister? She is in the comics so won't appear.
Windows in the alley