The Pinkie Swear
Curious, how many people accepted the pinkie swear to be friends with Sarah and of those, who intends to keep that? I personally accepted it but only cause Clem was desperate for help, If a major decision comes up because of it I can't say I'll hold true to it.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Desperate for hydrogen peroxide, I would've gone ''sieg heil'' and tattooed a swastika on my arm just to get some disinfectant at that point.
As it stands, yes I'll keep true to the promise as best I can. But I won't keep Sarah safely secure away from the world, I'll try to gradually introduce her to it so she doesn't ''cease to function'' as the physician said.
I accepted it because I needed her help, and I instantly regretted it. I won't go back and change it, but I'm 100% sure it's gonna come back and bite me in the ass.
I accepted because Tell Tale made me realize that even if they try to manipulate you, at the long shot, the more friends you have, the better
Also did anybody notice that if you swore to her that you wont tell her dad then her dad knows no matter if you didnt say it to him. Weird cause maybe Sarah WANTED to get caughy. I think Sarah wants Clem and manipulates her. Thing is i dont regret it cause when this comes to bite my ass, ill probably have that guy always there to help me
I did,I don't want clem to completely lose her childhood yet.also,I do want to introduce sarah gradually to the outside world,and maybe teach her some stuff if possible
I took the pinkie swear, while thinking the whole time "I will have no problem using you as bait". But also its Clem and when it right comes down to it ill probably live up to it... maybe
Pinky swear?! No way! I told her "no new friends, no new friends.."
I get that reasoning. But for me it was "what ever gets me what I need". A pinkie swear ill break in a heart beat is a good trade off for getting disinfectant for my arm.
I just did it to get the peroxide. This girl is stupid, but Clem is smart.
I don't say we were best friends and she still felt comfortable giving me the peroxide. Guess she realized Clem isn't someone to be messed with.
I let the timer run out, still got the peroxide.
"If I give it to you, will you go away?"
I did the pinkie swear just to get the peroxide at the moment because Clem really needed help even though I didn't want to, and I will probably end up following up on the promise at the end of the day though.
That scene was written "danger ahead" all over it. I too accepted it, knowing that I'll most likely to regret it later. But I'm really curious what would happen had I not accept it? Anyone refused it, I wonder, what was her reaction?
Absolutely not. I didn't even get the option to pinkie swear because I was not going to tell that freak that we're best friends.
"We're not the same age."
"Eventually..."
"..."
Master race.
I pinkie swore because I felt bad for her.
I dont know if I'm friedns with her not (I didn't get that stat for whatever reason) however I promised to be friends but didnt pinkie swear... it just got oo weird. From the way she acted I think were friends
I didn't do the pinky swear, I can't put my finger on it but I just don't trust her at all. I went with "We're not the same age." "Eventually..." and "No". I thought that if Sarah wouldn't get Clem the peroxide then Clem would find a way to get it herself, but it turned out Sarah got it for me anyway.
I accepted it because I wanted help but I fully intended to keep to it. Why not have let Clementine have a girl friend around her own age?
I knew as soon as I made that promise Telltale is gonna be a bunch of jerks and put me in a situation where I'm going to have to break it.
Haha yeah I can see them doing this as well, another reason I am glad I didn't do it, I am not tied down.
i dont know what but i think something bad gonna happen witch will test the "friendship" of the two
Not necessarily stupid, just naive. I also suspect she might be autistic in some way, considering how she speaks to Clem despite her age.
I did the pinky swear to get the peroxide, but the whole time I was a bit creeped out by Sarah's "crazy stare". Her mannerisms kind of reminded me of Nate. So yeah, I don't trust her one bit.
I might consider doing that in my second playthough
*Doctor
I did the pinky swear but only 'cause I needed help.
I think my Lee raised Clem to be an honest person, so I'll try to be true to it as long as I can. But when it comes down to it, I'll save my own skin!
I'm playing Clem a little more hardened so I told her we just met and weren't friends at first because it's hard to trust people but I felt bad when she kept pushing. I ended up saying we were friends and did the swear but warned her it might go wrong. That'll ease my conscience a little when I have to use her down the line, lol.
I'm fairly sure physician and doctor are synonyms.
I made it my goal to be as polite and friendly to everyone as I could the first time I played, so I gave her the benefit of the doubt and did the pinky swear. Although, I am slightly suspicious as to why she was so desperate for the pinkie swear and why my word alone wasn't good enough for her.
That's what I'm trying to do, Trying to make Clem hardened. I don't want to make her a jerk, but I'm not making her all innocent either.
I did it. felt sorry for her. cant wait for carlos to die though XD
I assume that when Sarah's dad said, "Cease to function", my feelings are like these: Either she'll become the new Lilly bitch or Katjaa who will go suicidal like she did when she can't shoot her son, Duck.
One of the few situations where I think silence is the best option. If you do not answer her after the were friends thing, you don't have to pink swear, she just keeps on talking and eventually gives you the peroxide anyways.
I seriously doubt she's autistic. I think she's just been cooped up too long without any kids to talk to. If the last time she spoke to children was before the apocalypse, then it makes sense that her development would be a little arrested.
I was friendly with Sarah since she came off as a decent person and I do think she knows at least a bit of what's going on, just not to extend that people will go to survive. I did the best friend and pinkie swear and I am planning on continuing talking to her since I got the feeling her father's opinion of me is not going to change. I'll probably see if I can help her adjust if I get the options to do so.
For some reason, I like to imaging that she's going to be helped by Clementine, if players choose that option, into learning how to handle things and not break down like her father thought. She might be naive and sheltered but that dosen't mean she'll break like a twig.
I accepted it, and I din't tell Carlos that she helped me,but he still berated me for getting her to help me. - so I hope she does't think Clem got her into trouble after the pinkie swear.
She seems decent. Not creepy like some say, just sheltered. Hopefully that's the truth. I swore
I never pinky swore. I told Sarah we couldn't be friends, I thought it would be better. The girl is obviously naive on how the world works now, so us not being friends may help her down the road. that's just what I think