I think this is Lilly.
At the end of the episode when we are told what will happen next Clementine comes forward and says "I thought you were dead," who do you think it is. I think this is Lilly. While it may be Kenny or someone from the new characters (eg Nick). Okay, what do you think?
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Like was argued in another thread, Clem should have no reason to believe she was "dead" especially because in my scenario I let Lilly stay inside the caravan and she stole it and drove off making her survival all the more likely.
And if Lee left it on the road?
You can't rule out any of the characters from S1. It could well be Lilly but I don't think so. If it was her then Clem maybe said "I though you were dead" because she couldn't believe she was still alive, but I don't know.
Then it means that my choice is completely ignored.
I think it'll be Christa.
if you dont help Christa, i'm pretty sure they kill her, or at least they definitely hurt her. just depends if they stop after she tells Clem to run or not.
personally i think it will be the guy Clem could give water to, because it is a "major" choice they show at the end.
Yeah, that's one of possibilities, too.
Could be Lilly, Christa, Molly, Kenny, the old people stealing the boat, one of the St. John brothers (Andrew I believe).
My initial thoughts were Molly or Kenny.
It didn't have much gas left in it at that point- Kenny said so.
And, Clem hadn't seen Lily in around 2 years.. Clem probably knew that the odds of one random person surviving the apocalypse over so much time are not very high.
I'm starting to think it's Vernon. When the other cancer survivors in 400 DAYS referred to him directly they said they "lost" Vernon, which doesn't immediately mean death. When you also take into account how many players here posted about wanting to wreak revenge on Vernon for stealing the boat, I wouldn't be surprised if Telltale tries to shove our ache for vengeance back into our faces. Having an adult PC kill Vernon would be one thing, but doing it as a young girl adds a whole new level of nastiness.
Good theory, but why would Clem think Vernon was dead? He stole the group's boat, surely Omid and Christa would have told her that.
no reason ? thats a stretch. Every single person in Clems life has died in the past 2 years. She leaves by herself in a van with no gas and bandits around the area. It fits perfectly that as a entire 2 years passes Clem thought Lily died. Where in fact the van ran out of gas, and she eventually joined a group of bandits.
Although possible I don't think they would end the trailer and clearly make it a "huge deal" with the dramatic effects for such a minor character we don't even know the name of
Everyone thought leaving Lily behind was an effective death sentence, even Lily mentioned it as such. So there would be a reason for Clementine to think she was dead. And the RV was going anywhere far according to Kenny. It is reasonable to think Lily didn't make it.
As pointed out elsewhere, if ANYONE vanishes for a long period of time during a zombie apocalypse where the living and the dead are equally monstrous, it would be fairly easy to assume to assume the worst-case scenario.
For what it's worth, he does have a name, though I think it's only in the credits. It's Victor. I don't think Clementine is talking about him, though, for the reason you said.
It´s either Kenny or the Bandit who we gave Water.
It's so absolutely Kenny. Telltale has said that his fate will be explored, meaning he's either alive or we see him as a walker, and seeing him as a walker is absolutely pointless.
I've seen other people mention that it might be the bandit, but that makes absolutely no sense to me. With the tone of voice Clementine uses, it's clearly someone she knew well in the past, or at least someone she knows the name of (the bandit's name is Victor, incidentally, but I don't think she knows that unless she watched the credits).
I also think it's Lilly. Of course she has a reason to think that Lilly died, they either left her alone by the side of the road to be chased by zombies or she stole an RV that was almost out of gas.
My money is on Kenny or Lilly, because they are some of the biggest characters of Season 1 that just "disappeared" if you will. We don't see either one being killed, but since she's saying that she thought whoever it is was dead, that makes it more likely to be Kenny IMO. Lilly's circumstances were far less dangerous than Kenny's, meaning that Clem would have less of a reason to think she was dead than that Kenny was. I'm HOPING it's Kenny, but I wouldn't be surprised if Lilly shows up.
If it were to be Christa, shouldn't Clem look a little more happier? By her face expression on that preview, she seems to feel slightly concerned from who she thought was dead. My money is on Lilly. My top 2nd choice is Kenny.
A huge plot twist would be Ben because if you let him live, his fate was undecided like Kenny. Perhaps they both escaped and Kenny had to amputate Ben's leg.
Well, amputating Ben's leg wouldn't do much because he was impaled through his torso. Of course, you could always try to amputate the torso, but this isn't the American Civil War, so nobody is likely to get too amputation-happy here, especially given how important the human torso is. Also, the fact that Kenny shot him in the face might have something to do with his not coming back, but we'll just have to wait and see.
Maybe it's molly i mean when she left lee is the only one who knew about it maybe chriasta and omid told her she's probable dead
Oh crap! You're right! It was definitely the torso. My mistake if I said the leg, I completely forgot where the zombie bit him. Thanks for correcting.
Ben is definitely dead then. No way Ben is still alive after being bit on the torso. But it's The Walking Dead, you never know. Besides, his wiki stated his death was determinant. O.o
I think it's the guy who clementine found near the river, one of the bandits who tried to rob Christa. I think most of the episodes of season 2 will be about finding Christa and he will most likely know where she went.
I think it meant that Ben's death was determinant in the way that he can die in two different ways, either falling from the belltower and being eaten, or being impaled on the balcony and shot by Kenny.
Clem didn't sound too thrilled about it. Thinking it's Lilly.
I think it will be to soon for Christa too come back. It could be her but it would be far more interesting if they brought a person from season 1 back.
If you're going to speculate on who it is, OP; at least have some thought out theories. I'm not trying to be mean, but we already have like 10 other threads saying the same thing. If there are any mods-- can we move all these threads into one theory thread?
Welp. I've seen a lot of discussion about who it is that Clem sees at the end of the episode and haven't seen anyone say this yet:
It's going to be..... Carly.
Clem would obviously think that she died. Think about it people, Carly's head is grazed by a bulled and she's left for dead. Another group comes along and picks her up and takes care of her.
This is kind of a joke post but it's just as possible as some of the other crazy stuff that's being posted lol.
You see Carly dead in 400 days as Russel-- if you decide to hide from Nate. (only if you saved Carly in season 1)
Well thanks for ruining this for me haha. I keed I keed.
Oh, sorry. For some reason I didn't even think about spoilers.
Kenny or Lilly!
I highly doubt Lilly. If you left her on the side of the road and played 400 Days, you saw she was dead. If you didn't, she still has the motorhome, but it's far fetched unless she somehow found gas for it.
I want to say it's either Kenny, Molly, Christa, or someone from the comics/show that has already died, but isn't dead in the game yet. Maybe someone in one of the traveling grounds that they meet during season three? Or could it be someone that Clem knew before this all happened? Maybe a relative that lives further north?
She dies anyway. There was a gunshot after clem distracted them witch was probably shot by ralph and aimed at christas head,
That was Carly, not Lilly.
Molly can die in one of the options I've been told.
Molly and kenny. Molly is the only way kenny could make it out of that situation and seeing them both there would show us how kenny got out of there
she just gets seperated from the group and looses her weapon. SHE IS THE NINJA OF SAVANNAH SHE WILL BE FINE
idk very hard to say. Im a little crushed deciding whether its kenny or lilly