"I thought you were dead" 4 Main Suspects Explained.
I believe that it's either Molly,Lily,Kenny or Christa.My number one suspect is Kenny and I will explain why.
Molly: There's no reason for Clem to think Molly was dead, she simply left.
Christa: Likewise Clem doesn't believe Christa is dead so i don't think she would say "i thought you were dead".
Lily: Again Lily didnt die she simply left so why would Clem think she was dead.
Kenny: Logically this is the only person who everyone thought died, obviously Christa and Omid would have told Clem what happened to Ben and Kenny so then Clem would obviously be surprised to see that he is still alive.
I believe that out of these 4 Kenny is the only plausible one that Clem would say this too, however the only other thing that could happen is Clem thinks one of the season 2 characters died then meets up with them there but i highly doubt this since the group didnt notice this person only Clem.
It has to be Kenny it just has to be!
Comments
Ermagerd why does everyone think Kenny is alive if he is I'm sorry for wasting your time but there is no evidence that Kenny is alive. He Is probably just as alive as Lee
Lee has been Confirmed dead so thats impossible,my point is Kenny is the only person that Clem would say that too so thats why i think its him. Doesnt make sense for her to say it too anyone else,plus Kenny had the only ambigious death of the first season for a reason....
People think Kenny is alive because they want to think Kenny is alive. Its not "obvious" Christa and Omid told Clem what happened. If it were they would show it in the game.
Come on dude telltale would assume their players are smart enough to put two and two together like they expect people to know the baby is dead without showing it dead. Of course Clementine would ask where is everyone else,she had been with them for months,it wasnt like episode 1 started 5 mins after the finale or anything
Lee 100% did, Kenny=??????
I meant that they both kicked the bucket....hard
Its been 2 years since season 1 so I assume he met up with a group,maybe went to a settlement who knows, anything could happen in 2 years
Why would kenny be in north Carolina?
no more unlikely then Rick finding his family, Daryl finding Merle and Rick finding Morgan again :P
it's still rather unlikely
Why Molly?
My main 5
Christa
Kenny
Lilly
Dying man at end of all that remains
Maybe even Adam but that's unlikely
Few people were mentioning Molly, who is Adam?
Well they showed Christa prego then Christa without a baby, hence we think the baby is dead. The game did not once mention Kenny anywhere after his imminent death. If the game started off with a "what happened to Kenny" or a very SUBTLE hint, for example maybe omid/christa reference Kenny THEN I would agree with you its Kenny.
Ain't the person with bandits? if so i'd say lily
I agree with your thinking... It's just.. Why does everyone think "KENNY IS GOD, HE'S ALIVE", and rule out all other possible people? Molly: personally likes working alone, so she's out of the Equation, Christa: was killed or captured OR possibly got away, but I doubt she would just go join a Bandit group since she was suspicious of Lee's group at first, and to top the cake; why would she join a group after what JUST happened? Lily: Honestly, she could pop up and be in the next episode, but I wouldn't hold my breathe, she was honestly a bitchy and whiny character that I didn't like, it would be a surprise if she showed up, but would you really want her here in the End? Kenny: The Glorious Stache God, That's what he's god of, and he could be Kenny The Badass Glorious Stache God if he lives on in Episode 2 of Season 2, he could possibly be alive on ONE of his "Death" scenes, since the one with Christa was alot more open ended then the other which looked to be that he had no escape anywhere Besides all the windows that were littered EVERYWHERE. Sooooo he has some chance of being alive, Now; can we settle that Lily and Kenny are the only possible people to be in this next episode that Clementine thought was dead?
Because from all the discussions i've read, the people aren't being logical about it and just skimming the surface, and at times coming up with their own theories that suck so bad it's almost not even mentionable.
Lily or Kenny would be main suspects but my big gripe about it being Lily is why would Clem say "I thought you were dead". No reason to think Lily was dead. So far not one person has been able to refute the fact that Kenny is the only one she assumed was dead.
The game was set months after episode 5 so it wouldn't make sense for Clem to only be asking about it months after, it was probably the first thing she asked when they met on the hill
Christa: "They say it's better up north." "They" as in other survivors. It seems like there are rumors going around amongst what few living remain that things are better up north (which we know to be false, but hey). If Kenny did survive, he's as likely to have heard these rumors as Christa and Clem. And if he hears things might be better somewhere else, why not head there?
He's Campman's son (the one that vanished while they were out hunting together).
Alright man. Maybe you're right. Just don't think Clem who just saw Lee die would ask about Kenny who she rely never connected with.
Ah but she still would be curious if nothing else and plus she did care about Ben so she definitely would have asked about him and you can't really explain what happens to Ben without mentioning Kenny.
Impossible to be him sure Clem has no idea what he looks like
People are probably quick to assume Kenny because Telltale said that Kenny's fate will be explored; that coupled with his ambiguous fate makes many believe he could still be alive. Not saying I believe this to be the case, but that is most likely what is driving a lot of fans to believe he is still alive. Telltale is definitely betting on a lot of people thinking so as well I would assume, so they could also be intentionally misleading people.
This is true also, maybe throw a curveball and that bandit that you could give water too is the guy alive. But if it's not a season 1 character it's really lame on telltales part in my opinion
Give it a rest believers, Kenny's dead.
Why would Lily, Molly, or anybody else be in North Carolina? My guess for Lily is that if she took the RV, she goes back the way they came, right? I guess she went back to the Motor Inn and died, IMO. I do imagine Lily being a part of a bandit group. Her angry attitude would fit right in. Kenny's as well.
Because as Rock said there is a rumor amongst survivors things are better up north hence many survivors heading in same direction, North.
"I guess that makes sense. Yeah. It makes sense, Wyatt."
You don't know that. He was obsessed with Clem and his dead family maybe he showed her a picture of adam
Finally someone who agrees with me THANK YOU!!!!
It's CHET!
Not to mention that Kenny claims that the radiator on the RV was busted (if Lilly took the RV, of course) and that she probably wouldn't go further than 30 miles.
He missed hot dish night...and he's about to get his revenge...
Agreed. While we don't know exactly what happened to him, I'd assume that he got taken by the St. Johns and cut up for meat. I'm gonna guess that he's dead.
At least with my playthrough its left ambigous whether Kenny died or not. He had two bullets left, one for him, and one for the kid... and I really could see Kenny shooting two zombies and then dragging the kid off, or shooting the kid and then fighting his way out of the zombies.
It's either Lilly, Christa, or it will be someone who seems to get screwed in the next episode but returns later.
Kenny is dead.
Yep Lilly, Kenny or Christa anyone else and I think using that scene is a little cheap really if its just some minor character
I'm with you on the Kenny theory. I also am looking at the narrative and seeing the drawing of Kenny in her pack seemed to me to be a bit of foreshadowing. Lee in my story line was at constant odds with Kenny, two steps forward, two steps back, but Clem always liked him. Another possibility is Christa. I think Clem has some reason to think she might be dead. Lily is another possibility and I could see her joining a bandit group. Also, Kenny gave her the impression that she wouldn't last long so she has some reason to believe she might be dead.