The fate of the Saint John's in season 1
Why did you or didnt kill them? I didnt because I didnt want to show clem or scare her that Im a murder and did you tell everyone your past?
This discussion has been closed.
Why did you or didnt kill them? I didnt because I didnt want to show clem or scare her that Im a murder and did you tell everyone your past?
Comments
I didn't,and the same reason like you,also I want clem to know the difference between killing in self defense and killing for vengeance.yes,I told everyone in the motor inn,I wish I can tell duck too
I did because keeping evil people like that alive in a world like that, would just backfire, or some other poor fellow might end up on their dinner table.
I changed the title to avoid including Season 1 spoilers.
Also, I killed both brothers; not out of spite, but because they were a potential threat to anybody else who also could have run into them.
I told everyone about my past. I also killed both brothers because they deserved it.
Agreed. I didn't kill them for Clem but I almost wanted to. If they were to kill anyone else because we let them go, or even come after us becaus ethey knew where the Motor Inn was... With people like Ben on guard duty too. I like Ben but he didn't even notice Lee and Kenny come back from the supply raid in Ep3 it seems
My first playthrough
I killed Danny but not Andy. I was enraged at what they did, and I didn't want them to hurt anyone else. But after I killed Danny and Clementine saw, I was really upset; I didn't want her to see that. So, I beat up Andy but I didn't kill him. I knew he was going to die anyway because of the walkers approaching the farm, and I didn't want to seem even more like a murderer than I already was.
Yeah i didn't kill him because Clem was looking. I didn't know someone like that could influence my choices so heavily. because if she wasn't looking would have killed him
Whoo
Ep2 creeped me out too much. I couldn't believe what I was playing
Great minds think alike! Haha
Killed Danny, 'spared' Andy. Danny was essentially a 'warning,' and Andy was left to rot.
I killed them both, in the hope that they might not pull shit like that. I didnt care if Clem was watching, she wasnt the most important factor at the time.
Yeah, I think it was definitely the most creepy/disturbing episode. It definitely shocked me a little bit haha
My main feelings behind killing both of them was that I wasn't sure if they could still be a possible threat if left alive. I also didn't want them to do that crud to anyone else, and I felt they needed to pay for what they did + planned to do to my group. And, I told everyone in the group about my past.
Same here, that outcome is the best IMO. It makes the most sense & is also the most dramatic. :] Too bad S2 doesn't recognize the difference when killing just one brother![:\](https://community.telltalegames.com/resources/emoji/confused.png ":\")
I was all hyped up and ready to kill Danny. Then he said something that just made me freeze.
Most people didn't kill Jolene. If you don't kill her, Danny says he knows you aren't going to kill him and that you are a coward ( a dairy farmer is calling you a COWard... okay I'll stop now). You get a different dialogue from him if you shot her.
Here is what he said, "DO IT THEN! I know you can! I've seen you do it! Just like you killed that woman in the camp!" That statement made my blood run cold for a moment. Up until then, he seemed to be bargaining for his life, arguing that you need him alive if you want to eat him, which made me more inclined to kill him. The fact that he was telling me that I could kill him made me decide to spare him. Fuck that. I wasn't going to kill him myself, I'll let the walkers finish him off.
As for Andrew, I left him too. Mama's dead, Danny was bleeding out as we spoke. I read an interview from the VO who played Andrew say that the most merciful thing you could have done would be to kick Andy into the fence, so he would have left him. That's just what I did.
#NoRegrets.