My thoughts on S2E1 ending
You have to keep an open mind as I know some of these are unlikely,
but improbable does not mean impossible.
In the end when Clementine says "I thought you were dead," I had a few thoughts on who it could be and who it could not be. After some time I put a lot of thought into this, and if you agree or disagree please discuss this like reasonable people. Or if you think it could be someone else, please discuss it as I would like to hear your input.
First the list of people who I don't think Clem is talking to in the ending.
(contains names I've seen in other threads and I'm just giving my thoughts on why I don't think it is them.)
Lilly - She was never killed in game nor mentioned to have died, so Clem would have no knowledge of death concerning her. Plus no real attachment to her.
Molly - Same as Lilly
Christa - If it was really Christa then Clem would've had a look of relief and would've said "You're alive!"(or something along that) with a smile on her face since she was in search of her. Instead, she had a discerning look with disbelief. No way it could be Christa.
Now onto the people I think it could be.
Kenny - Maybe he really did run off and Lee just assumed he was dead given the circumstances. Since we the audience didn't see an actual death scene, it gives the possibility that he survived the attack, but the rest of the group didn't see that.
Omid - We know he was shot in the chest early in the episode, but we had no real confirmation of his death. We didn't really see if Clem or Christa took the head shot so that Omid doesn't come back as a walker/lurker. For all we know he could have had a still heart from the shock; it has happened before in the real world. If they didn't take the shot then he could have still lived and was left behind. Just a theory I had.
Lee - Then there's the highly improbable off-chance if you didn't shoot Lee in the end of S1E5 and leave him behind that he survives and joins another group. This theory I doubt very much, but a theory nonetheless.
Comments
Could be Pete/Nick too. Although probably not since it was Clementine that was so suprised. I'm almost positive it's Kenny, because in season 1 Kenny was so central a figure, so it would make sense that the decisions you made as Lee that affected Kenny alot would come into play in season 2.
Omid- your kidding right? please tell me you are. for him to survive a string of luck would have to come his way A) Christa would have to Not shoot him in the head
They would have to leave the station and have the new group appear within 10-30 minutes C) They would have to have at least 2 doctors with medical supplies D) He would have to go Immedent surgery.
Highly inprobable especily in TWD world where you do Whatever it takes to survive
Its
A) The water bandit
B)Kenny
C) Lilly (Regarding your opinion its highly probable that she died and clem has reason to think that after 16+ months)
for me it is a definite no for Lee. Clementine would be super happy and run up to him (or maybe she was just shocked). but she sounded a little worried and frightened. and also...Lee looked pretty bad, but then again...he was a BADASS!
forclementine
i said it was just a theory, plus crazier things have happened
Or it could be somebody we haven't even met yet..
Another theory: It could be the girl that shot Omid!
Highly unlikely since that would be anticlimactic.
Very well could be. XD
In the case that it WOULD be Lee, wouldn't the look of relief on Clementine be even more apparent than if it was Christa?
How would Lee have survived?
You never know, especially with Telltale pulling the strings, they can pull plot twists out the ass. lol
Maybe someone Clementine met during the 16 month gap and saw him dead you are right. they will troll us just like they made us believe Nick was Kenny
Well, I forgot about some characters in the first season, but my guess is:
1)The group of old people in season 1(the ones that Lee thought that they had taken Clementine,before he figured out who the real "kidnapper" was)- if I remember right they didn't die
2) Could be Molly(the girl that Lee and Kenny met in the city,she was living on her own and if I remember right, she also later on didn't want to stay with the group anymore)
3)Also the others that we don't clearly know what happend with them : Kenny, Glenn,Lilly...
Might be anybody xD
I think that Lee and Omid can't be the survivors. If you decided to kill Lee he's just gone(yea it's hard to let go and we try to find diffrent reasons for him to return, but I think that won't happen) and Omid(that's just not possible, no1 would have wanted to save him in that sape + it would be nearly impossible to save him)
Damn I just finished this 1st episode and I'm so pumped up I could play the whole game over again :P Episode 2 come as fastest you can(but they will probably wait to sell the episode 1 to get some money and lure the buyers, and then realease episode 2, just business - but I'm thankfull that they made such an awsome game).
This is true
I would love Omid to come back. I've actually saw Prison Break once, and Lincoln was shot to the right part of his chest, near the same place as Omid. Then the shooter told his brother by phone that Lincoln had like 2-3 hours before he died. If the bullet hit just Omid's lung and not the heart, I think it's possible he survived.
Christa would have put a bullet in Omid's head without a doubt...not a chance it's him. kenny and Lilly seem the most likey,
But that's the thing, they don't show Christa or Clem taking the shot, so Telltale might be using that to their advantage. Also Clem had no knowledge of Lilly ever dying, so why would she say "I thought you were dead"?
Exactly the thing I thought
The water bandit guy, huh. I never thought of that before, interesting.
My opinion: