It's not Christa or Lilly...
Okay first off, Christa. When you first meet her in "Long Road Ahead", you can bond with BrOmid. Lee asks BrOmid how they made it. He responds with, "Christa never lets us join groups." In "All that Remains", after BrOmid's death (R.I.P. BrOmid) Clementine can ask Christa during the fire if they could find a group. Christa then says she doesn't trust groups. Why would she lie to Clementine and go against what has kept her alive? Also, Clementine strongly believes she is still alive. We can now rule out Christa. Next, Lilly. Not only has she not been confirmed for Season 2, but Clementine doesn't have any reason whatsoever to believe she is dead. Clementine knows Lilly can handle herself because of her military experience, regardless of being abandoned on the side of the road.
Comments
Lee said:
The group assumed she would have died. Clem doesn't have to witness her get attacked to assume she is dead. Besides, 2 years without running into her would lead me to assume she is dead.
And just because a character "Isn't confirmed for season two" doesn't mean they can't appear. Ever heard of a surprise?
And I'm pretty sure Christa would make exceptions to the "lone wolf" thing if her life was on the line.
Some people let her get in, and Telltale won't change who the ITYWD person will be based on your decisions. Therefore, it's not Lilly
It's probably Kenny, or at least, that is what I believe.
Kenny or Victor they are the only two who make sense
Molly is also a possibility. I don't think that it's her, but it is a possibility.
Not really she also doesn't like groups & Clementine has no reason to believe shes dead
Kenny said:
30* And even then Clementine still doesn't think shes dead
That's true I suppose, although there is the possibility for Molly to be lost to a herd.
I replayed his "death" scene and here is what I think. 1.) If you agree to leave Kenny alone with Ben, he doesn't lock the gate and you give bullets. Also, after he kills Ben, you can hear 3 distinct pushing sounds and then a gunshot. I think he pushed the walkers out of the way and one maybe tried to grab him so he shot. Or maybe he even shot at Campman. 2.) If he "dies" trying to save Christa he can shoot more than once. If you don't pull Christa up after Kenny boosts her up you can sit there and he shoots multiple times and goes offscreen. (Also, when you try to contact Campman on the radio before Kenny drops it into the building, Campman doesn't respond.) 3.) When you pull her up he says "Get the fuck off me." He could be talking about a walker but if he was he would have tried to push it off of him. I don't recall hearing any pushing sounds or grunting when he says it. Instead, he sounds shocked. Like maybe someone he has never met before is grabbing him. 4.) When you save Clementine, there's a suspicious door. However, you cannot open it. I think maybe Campman saved and/or knocked Kenny out and took him back planning to kill him. Maybe he already told Clementine he killed him, if he she even asked or noticed. 5.) If Kenny was saved by Campman, I think Kenny woke up and found the two walkie-talkies. He probably then figured out Clementine's parents were dead (if he didn't already know). He then would proceed to find BrOmid/Christa/Lee. Having gone through a shit ton of walkers, he would probably be covered in blood, or even Ben's brain matter, he walks out of Savannah. However he goes the opposite way Clementine and the rest. Having gone the opposite way, he probably gets up north to the mountains first, finds a group, and then meets Clementine either in Episode 7 or Episode 8 (S2E2 or S2E3). I've also noticed a few things. 1st, in Episode 4, when Kenny gets grabbed, if you don't save him, Christa does. 2nd, in Episode 4, if you don't help him push the desk, Omid will help. Lastly, in Episode 4, when you have to pull the chord to open the attic. If you don't, once again, Christa does it. It's like Telltale doesn't want Kenny to die...... Coincidence? I think not
Actually I dont know why people keep saying Lilly is presumed dead, People are basically saying a single line by Lee is enough to think Someone as tough As Lilly died just because she is by herself yet those same people have no doubt Kenny escaped from 50 walker approaching him in a closed Building or Alley, I simply dont get it
My theory is way to long to post here, so instead, I'll just link to it: http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/57605/the-walking-dead-season-2-predictionskenny-christa-lilly-etc-/p1
Im not saying shes dead, just Clementine doesn't think so
How would you know?
I make good points right?
-_- do I have to explain it yet again....Lilly lovers I swear......
Im not referring to you, I mean the people who think Clementine thinks Lilly died, Thats nonsense
I think she will be revealed in Episode 3 and killed by Kenny or a walker
Clementine believes that bad things happen to bad people, which is why Clem is reassured (if you kill the St. John brothers) when you tell her that you killed them because they were bad men. She was eight years old, so she assumed that Lilly died because she did something terrible to Doug/Carly to reassure herself.
And I'm not a Lilly lover; I loved both Kenny and Lilly, and they were both good friends to me, but you can't rule Lilly out as a possibility based on a hunch that Clem didn't think she was dead.
That's fucking stupid Ben -_-
"I'm just saying..."
That's fucking stupid
He does lock the gate... which is why Lee couldn't get in...
Not if you leave him with Ben
You can choose "Okay" or "Hell No"
What makes you think the gate wasn't locked either way? I'm pretty sure the lock was broken, which is why Lee couldn't get back in once it closed.
Replay it and when given the option choose "Yes"
I have: He closes the gate in both scenarios:
He shuts it but doesn't lock it
What if its not Kenny, Lily or Christa. Who do we have left?
Victor
But we can't determine if it was truly locked or not...
SUCH MYSTERY!
I suppose so.
There is no way to claim it isnt someone. Until episode 2 it could be any surviving character
She'd assume it after two years. Same with Molly