How did you treat Sarah?
When you were sneaking around the house and you found Sarah, how did you act towards her?
I acted friendly and went through with the whole pinky-promise thing but I can tell that that's gonna bite me in the ass later on.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Yeah, same here. I'm sure that whatever happens won't be too bad, though.
Promised to be her friend, too.
Was a bit soon for her to go declare her and Clem as best of friends. But I understood she might be lonely and seemed kindhearted enough (helped Clem alright), so I will at least try to be her friend. That's what I picture Clem doing.
I took the tough guy routine at first with the "or ELSE" option then the "your dad didn't care" response.
... Then I backed down and befriended her after dancing around the situation with the "we're not the same age" response because apparently I can't handle the awkwardness of saying "you're not my friend" even in a video game.
Didn't befriend her the four other times I played, but, yeah. Originally, befriended her for some reason.
Didn't befriend her, the whole pinky thing seemed like a bad idea, so I didn't become her friend.
Became her friend cause I didn't want to piss her off and hurt my chances of getting the supplies. I also apologized to Carlos , not really wanting to criticize the man for the way he raised his daughter.
I basically manipulated her into viewing me as a friend so she would stay silent about my escape.
This makes a lot of sense strategically. Those seem to be the 2 most reasonable choices. Wonder what kind of impact they will have on the following episodes.
I am trying to play Clem in a variety of different ways. I have a save file in which she's more reasonable and another one in which she is bolder (sometimes giving other characters straight up sass.)
Let's see how that goes.
I did NOT do the pinky-promise thing,because i am a soulless person.No,seriously now,doing that promise would mean i actually have to keep it.I barely met the bitch and she already wants me!I mean,really,Clemmy's been through hell and she was dying and Sarah was putting pressure on her to be her friend and shit.How immature can you get during the zambie apocalypse,after all?I don't like Sarah at all,actually.I just don't.After i get to know her a lil' bit,maybe i'll understand her.Or maybe i won't.
Ya, I watched 3 people on youtube play it and they all picked the "She needs to grow up sometime response" and it didn't make any sense to me. There is no reason to piss off the doctor of the group in case Clem needs help again.
I can just imagine Clementine asking for help and Carlos being "You need to grow up sometime".
I treated her like I treat all the special people I meet. I was nice... mostly.
Let just say I didn't treat her TOO nicely. I told her to not to tell anyone OR else and I didn't befriend her..
She wasent lonely, she was retarded.
I was nice to her and became her friend. Sarah seems like a decent person.
This.
I wouldn't say retarded, but she does probably have some kind of mental disability.
Also, did you say mental disability OR loneliness?
Why can't she have both?
I didn't be her friend, i don't know? There is something very creepy in he, maybe cause she is like super nonaware and naive, and her father is such a durtbag.
pinky promised
I Treated Her Well and I promised I was gonna be her friend, Now you don't need to tell me its gonna bite me in the ass later somehow because i know it will, There has to be something to that Choice of being friendly or not
[removed]
I was kind of avoided promising anything for as long as possible, doing the whole, "We aren't the same age" and "I just met you" thing, but I eventually did pinky promise.
Clemmy's so uncomfortable and taken aback by Sarah's pushyness and naiveté it's kind of funny.
You can just see by the look in her face that she's going all "dafuq?" in her head the moment Sarah says "we should be best friends!"
Still, I ended up doing the pinky promise thing because I thought she wouldn't help me otherwise.
But, I do have a very bad feeling about this.
I treated Sarah in the exact manner Clementine had soon treated herself in the shed, only not necessarily as 'harsh.' That said, a reasonably arm's length line needed to be stitched --were I in Clementine's hat-- in order to not lead this obviously unwell teen on, w/ an extra-layered purpose --the hat is off at this point-- for the potentiality of Sarah's resentment to come to a head, shaking things up a bit.
I was nice to her because I think she's just extremely sheltered and lonely, I don't think she has a mental disability, at least not one that's a big deal.
I do think the pinky promise means she will get into some kind of trouble and Clem won't be able to keep the promise, that'd be a pretty good tearjerker I think.
Like if she gets killed and Clem can't save her. Remember, Telltale is not afraid of killing ANYONE off. They killed Duck and he acts more like a retard than Sarah, plus he's younger, so Sarah certainly isn't safe from dying.
Edit : Maybe Clem will betray her somehow, leaving her alone because she has to or just decides to, getting her in trouble, something like that.
I was good to her 'cause I felt Sarah was a good person and Clem could use a friend, considering how lonely she was and that half the household was trying to kill her (the awkawdness of the whole situation didn't help). I figured that, even if they weren't really best friends, it was a good foundation for a friendship in the long term. In the end, it didn't feel very true to Clem as a character. Even if you control her, she does have a personality of her own and she doesn't seem like the kind of person who would befriend someone after a 10 seconds conversation. So I think it ended up being more of a manipulation, even if I didn't intend it to be that way.
I don't think my reaction was much different.
i was nice to her. i figured she might come in handy later since i can tell she's not going to be much good for much else other than bait thanks to her idiot father
I did the pinky promise, i was scared honestly at first sarah freaked me out, but then i realized she is just a girl who doesnt know about anything or anyone, buuuut i think that pinky promise is hidding something really important, i bet we will have to choose between saving sarah or someone else in the next episodes.
Personally I disn't see what the problem was with her immediately. She just seemed like a friendly young girl, and I think her father may be exaggerating her 'problem' because he's so overprotective, and in reality the real problem is his denial, as if letting his daughter witness something bad means that nothing will ever go back to the way it was.
Of course, if there is something wrong, I'm curious to know what it is. And in my responses I chose to have Clem match Sarah's personality but showed her the dog bite to see how she'd react. Nothing out of the ordinary as far as I could tell.
I mean, how would anyone here look to a hardened survivor if you had no idea of the severity of what was happening and everyone around you managed to keep you in the dark so that you couldn't even tell there was something wrong at all?
Yeah Sarah is not the problem, the problem is Carlos overprotecting her, he should teach her how to survive, how to shoot because the only thing he is teaching her is to hide but we know hiding is not enough to survive
She reads a book called "The Guurgles"
Of course I would be friends with her! And anyone who doesn't will be visited by Freddy Kruger!
Tried to be nice, said I was her friend, but didn't promise her anything. I don't promise.
Im sure later in the Story that Whole Pinky Promise thing is gonna come to bite you in the ass no matter what you choose, I feel like its one lf those Lose-Lose situations
Even people with disabilities can feel lonely.
Like many other things. The watch, for instance.
Yeah, Maybe if you didn't take the watch you are gonna need it for something and if you took Carlos is gonna be more hostile towards you and show distrust, It would put the player on a tough situation
I promised to be her friend, and I meant it, yet according to her father I took advantage of her? I was legit! it wasn't no manipulation!
Nice but refused to promise friendship. Knew it wasn't going anywhere good and don't want to be making friends at a place I was planning on leaving once stitched up anyway. I mean I knew she'd have to stay there, but I tried thinking like my Clementine.