My "These Lips Are Sealed" Theory
Okay,you guys kinda helped me piece this together.Firstly,let's talk about the Brother Grimm's story,with the girl and the ribbon.A girl couldn't take off the ribbon from her neck,because,if she did,her head would fall off.The thing is,all prostitutes from the Pudding N' Pie are saying the same damn phrase:"These Lips Are Sealed",including the Mirror.I know it struck most people as odd,and it was the same for me.Some think it is a spell.I think so,too.So here's what i really think is up with this whole shenanigan:
When a girl agrees to be a stripper at Pudding N' Pie,Georgie wants to make sure that discretion really IS a guarantee.He puts a spell on them,which makes them unable to talk about their work.How?Georgie puts a ribbon around their neck.That spell is actually put on the ribbon,in a way that,when one of the prostitutes talks about their work,triggers their head to fall off.You know,the ribbon removes itself or is removed by someone else.That kinda thing.But my theory has its flaws.How come Lilly didn't have her ribbon on her?The killer must've known that body will be identified,so there's no reason for him to really remove it from this body.I guess i have to analyse that last picture with Ichabod and Lilly to make sure...Anyway,this is as far as i've gathered.Maybe you guys can tell me what you think?I dunno if another thread has been posted with this same theory,but I would actually appreciate seeing some here...
OwO<--creepy cat face
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Interesting theory! Definitely something to keep in mind. For everybody who doesn't know the story of the girl with the green ribbon, here it is: http://okayquitmadstop.blogspot.nl/2010/09/alvin-schwartz-green-ribbon.html One tiny thing, though: none of the versions of the story I've read mentions a purple ribbon. I've mostly seen green, yellow and red. Maybe I missed it, though. Or maybe TellTale changed the color to make the connection less obvious.
I know,but i thought it's just a different version of the ribbon,like,it's not the original.I thought it was mad ESPECIALLY for the Pudding N' Pie girls,and is marked with a spell,too.I dunno,but thanks for reading my theory!