Don't be surprised if it's Herschel.
No one has mentioned Herschel yet but he seems to be the most liable "I thought you were dead" theory.
- Clementine looked up to Herschel as a father figure (When Herschey was chewing out Lee on the porch)
- She would have thought he died because his son died leaving her to believe that the farm was in complete danger.
Anyone else agree?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
No, Herschel died at the prison already.
Hershel is ded
Herschel is dead right now in the comic and the TV show I don't see him coming back anytime soon.
I think this was intended to be a joke lol
I love Hershy, but this would be really random if he arrived there ... in the Comics he travels from his farm (and at the time he thought it was a fortress, so there was no reason for him to flee, and afterwards he went to the prison where he met his end). So sadly, it's not him.
TV Show and the game are completely different worlds. Glen most likely did not find Rick when he went back to wherever in the game.
Sadly my friend it could actually be him. He hasn't left his farm in the game yet, or we do not know.
When he went back to Atlanta? Where he met Rick? And Herschel died at the prison in the comics too.
he dead
Anything is possible, and I don't know the timescale in the game compared to the comics, but I don't see why he'd be all the way over there when his life revolves around keeping the farm maintained. The only reason he left his farm was because of the outbreak. Even then he was convinced the world was fine, and afterwards he died at the prison. So unless they're actually allowing characters from the comics to have a change of story, I can't see this happening.
So you really believe the game and the tv show world are mixed together? So you believe that when Glen left us in like ep. 1 or beginning of episode 2 season 1, he actually went back and find Rick and them? Herschel died yes in the comics and in the tv show, but Not in the game. There is no character in the tv show named "Lee Everrett". Herschel would have met him.
PARALLEL UNIVERSE (sry caps)
No, the TV show is it's own thing. The game was originally intended to be canon to the comics, and it was until The Road to Woodbury came out(from what I'm told, haven't read it myself).
The timeline from the first season could match with the comic book. We don't know exactly how long after the outbreak that Rick wakes up from his comma and Glen leaves the game at what... like a week after the outbreak?
In my opinion the most likely person is Lilly. No matter your choice with Lilly in season 1 she gets away. She seemed like a woman who would do whatever it takes to survive. Lot of folks think it's Kenny because Telltale said we'll find out Kenny's fate, but I think we'll see a zombie Kenny at some point the same way we found out the fate of Clem's parents.
I hate when people think the Glenn and Hershel Game Character are the same as the TV/Comic. They look alike and have the same name, but they never do anything as they did in the comics/TV
Wouldn't that be because the games aren't covering the events in the comics? I mean Glenn and Herschel did exist before meeting Rick's group so the idea that they met with other survivors is plausible.
I don't understand what you don't get. The game is canon to the comics. Hershel is dead. So no, it couldn't be him. Figure it out.
See I'm stuck between Kenny and Lilly. And the only reason is because of Telltales claims of exploring Kenny's fate and also because I would like to are Lilly come back. But would Clem have any reason to believe that Lilly's dead? That's been my big question. She would have probably had heard of Kenny because of Christa and Omid but I would think that Clem would believe Lilly to be dead due to her just running off in the RV or being left behind. But either character will be awesome to see again!
Your retarded. 1 thing Clementine never seen Hershel died she barley knows him...
Oh my god, I don't mean to be mean but you are seriously the worst detective I've ever seen. Clementine saw him for a total of ten minutes before leaving.
Oh my christ, stop saying the game isn't canon to the comics because it is. Shawn appears in the comics as a zombie in Hershel's barn, Telltale specifically confirmed that these are comic characters making a cameo, this fucking site even confirms it on the official page.
Well what do u expect when the story is more bout the other survivors
Anyway I think it's tied to the comic primarily becuse of Shawn and the way he died
It helps connect the game to the comic
Another is the reference to Thomas in the police car
And the last one is that the prison lee was going to is the same one that Rick and the others find and eventually los
I agree either would be awesome. I would prefer Molly more than either of them though. I just don't think Kenny works for both his "endings". 1 he goes down to get the Walkie Talkie, this one I feel like he could have lived and is likely the route that makes people think he's alive. 2 is when he goes down to try and save Ben, where he just has 1 bullet and walkers coming from both sides of an alley. You hear the yelling, a gunshot, no more yelling and Lee gives a very sad face (if I remember correctly)... I just don't see Telltale being able to write out of that version without it seeming silly. But that's just me.
See but that's where I have the problem of it being Lilly or Molly. Would Clem have any reason to believe that they would be dead just because that parted with the group?
On another note, concerning Kenny's fate, could it be that Molly, who was still in Savannah at the time, be the one who saved Kenny from the herd he was supposedly lost to and that's why he could still be alive?
Interesting. You just gave me a reason to think Kenny could be alive. Have an up-vote.
Yay an upvote!!! That was an idea I pitched to a buddy of mine when heg said that any way they brought back Kenny would be silly. I don't know if this is what will be but after weighing all the options that one, to me and in my opinion only, was the most plausible.
Omg head hurts from laughing! Love your pics!
Your head shouldn't be hurting from the laugh but the fact that the picture he posted is a jpg type not a gif.
Edited. Sorry been a long day. Plus I've seen so many pics and gifs today.
Is Herschel Hershel's Twin?
I don't think it's Hershel. He's just too much of a minor character in the game.
Just because you're son dies it dosen't necessarily mean that you have to die too...
I really think that the only reason that they added both Hershel and Glenn was to make the correlation between the comic and game. Not to have them return for obvious reasons of them being with Rick's group.
Yeah, I agree.
I hope this is a joke.
I'm not too sure myself
True. But the comic and the game, however, are not.
(Also, Glenn went to Atlanta, and he found Rick in Atlanta... So...
No, it still is canon to the comics, just they changed one person from being in the comics to not being in the comics. Lilly is not Lilly Caul.
The characters from the game and the series are connected. Don't expect any further crossover characters like Hershel, Rick, Michonne, etc.
Oh, okay. Thanks.