Luke or Lilly? A Hypothetical Scenario.

124»

Comments

  • edited February 2014

    I apologized, I said that I should've treated you with far more respect, but now, I'm thinking if I really should treat you with more respect, judging by your reaction, I'd say the answer is no. I never asked you to change your thread, and I never said you were wrong(I'm sorry if you thought I did). I gave my own opinion, which happened to differ greatly to yours. I realized how harsh I'd been, then I apologized, but you reacted in an incredibly immature way.

    So, yeah, you ARE the jerk here. You're in the wrong. So am I, but at least I apologized.

    You're right, I'm the jerk. You called my thread ridiculous which means that I deserved mockery and ridicule. I worked really hard on this thr

  • You have just shown yourself for what you truly are, a complete and utter cretin. Originally, it was the same Lilly. They just made her non cannon after the comic "The Walking Dead: The Road to Woodbury" was released. The comics display what Lilly is capable of and shows that she could be under the command of a true monster, but I suppose it's a bit over your head.

    Not the same Lily, so you are infact wrong. Well done for being wrong, you retard!

  • edited February 2014

    OK, I'm really sorry to be that guy, but this doesn't sound like something Lilly would do either. I think she would be something like Carver's second-in-command and keeps Carver's grunts in line, but she likes to take charge herself and kinda fight Carver for position as leader.

    But, yes, I know this is a hypothetical situation. Just pointing that out.

    I don't consider joining the bandits as giving up. Like you said he doesn't give up. His number one priority is to survive at all costs. Remember, Lee could have been a bandit if it weren't for Clem coming into his life and being his moral compass.

  • [Shoot Luke] or [Shoot Lilly and her bandits]

    Shoot Lilly, no hesitation.

  • It's okay. Well, I think Lilly is capable of that brutality. They originally made Lilly to be aligned with the comics, but the "Road to Woodbury" comic ruined that. Nevertheless, that's what Telltale was going for. In the comics, Lori was running away while carrying her baby with Rick and Carl. Lilly gunned Lori down which also killed Lori's baby and that's only scratching the surface of the atrocities done by her hand.

    OK, I'm really sorry to be that guy, but this doesn't sound like something Lilly would do either. I think she would be something like Carver'

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

    Well apparently a lot of die hard Kenny fans would join up with Kenny after seeing him murder the group. :P

  • So... his attitude? He just shot let's see, an older man (Pete) a pregnant woman, a harmless Alvin, a teenager, a coward, and soon to be Luke. I seriously don't get why ANYONE would side with Kenny in this situation, because he isn't Kenny any more, he's a bandit murderer.

    deleted

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

    So... his attitude? He just shot let's see, an older man (Pete) a pregnant woman, a harmless Alvin, a teenager, a coward, and soon to be Luke.

  • You're right and I apologize. I suppose I'm just a sensitive guy. I should of took your criticism with a grain of salt. You're also right about you not asking me to change my thread. That was all me trying to appease everyone which is just not possible. I express my deep regret for taking my anger out on you. It was not only immature of me to do so, but also childish. I truly was unreasonable earlier and I felt the need to to prove something. I just need to straighten everything out between us and apologize. Zyphon, I'm sorry.

    Zyphon posted: »

    I apologized, I said that I should've treated you with far more respect, but now, I'm thinking if I really should treat you with more respect,

  • Kenny :p

    deleted

  • Well, I hope Telltale lets her take her own direction rather than making a game copy of Comic Lilly. Now that Telltale has free reign over her, there is so much more they can do with Lilly.

    It's okay. Well, I think Lilly is capable of that brutality. They originally made Lilly to be aligned with the comics, but the "Road to Woodbu

  • Ok ill give you that.

    DougGreene posted: »

    I know that he could have and probably will have changed, but his personality won't become totally inverted.

  • How can killing a teenage girl who has been secluded form the zombie apocalypse be valid...I mean I can see if everyone else in the cabin group are hypothetically antagonist to Kenny's group...but Sarah. That's when a sane person draws the line.

    deleted

  • I would shoot Lilly or Kenny in this scenario. There is no redemption in an act like this, especially when your trying to goad a child into killing another human voluntarily.

  • Well thank you, I'm glad we could work this out like reasonable people.

    You're right and I apologize. I suppose I'm just a sensitive guy. I should of took your criticism with a grain of salt. You're also right abou

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

    How can killing a teenage girl who has been secluded form the zombie apocalypse be valid...I mean I can see if everyone else in the cabin group are hypothetically antagonist to Kenny's group...but Sarah. That's when a sane person draws the line.

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

  • What are you talking about?

    deleted

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

    What are you talking about?

  • edited February 2014

    I'm not trying to change your opinion but to me the zombie apocalypse isn't about survival the fittest it about maintaining the last portions of humanity (etc. moral code). If I can do something to save a life I would, if I see a group doing wrong (murdering) I'm not gonna just join up with them to hypothetically "survive with the predators" I'm gonna take my chances. Either that or I would run like hell.

    deleted

  • edited October 2016

    deleted

    I'm not trying to change your opinion but to me the zombie apocalypse isn't about survival the fittest it about maintaining the last portions

Sign in to comment in this discussion.