›

(Spoilers and Hypotheticals) Take your pick: Kate or Carla

ArodinArodin
edited July 2009 in Tales of Monkey Island
The debate on who the mystery girl is at the end of "LOTSN" has more-or-less come down to it being either Carla or Kate taking on the mantle of pirate-hunter "Morgan Le Flay." Someone suggested making buttons to support who you think it is. So in a spat of boredom at work, I made these: :)

th_62275_carla_122_204lo.jpg

th_62274_kate_122_215lo.jpg

Comments

  • NimeniNimeni
    edited July 2009
    Kate, definitely. You should turn this into a pole.
  • Sir PantalonesSir Pantalones
    edited July 2009
    th_62274_kate_122_215lo.jpg

    Carla seemed relatively calm about it during EMI. Well, not calm enough to not drink her mind away, but calm enough to not want to kill Guybrush.
  • Mike HaleyMike Haley
    edited July 2009
    Where is the Independent Party nomination? For shits and giggles, I vote for the underdog, Wally B. Feed...

    I know that the odds are against him, though.

    EDIT: I may have broken the delicate censors.
  • goodsugarblinkgoodsugarblink
    edited July 2009
    I believe its Wally...the voice was kind of raspy, but young and Carla didn't seem to have beef at the end of Escape. It could be Kate, but Wally has a bigger role in the series..it also could be someone new.
  • RadogolRadogol
    edited July 2009
    goodsugarblink wrote: »
    I believe its Wally...the voice was kind of raspy, but young and Carla didn't seem to have beef at the end of Escape. It could be Kate, but Wally has a bigger role in the series..it also could be someone new.

    The official walkthorugh identifies the mystery person as a woman.

    http://www.telltalegames.com/monkeyisland/launchofthescreamingnarwhal/walkthrough
  • NimeniNimeni
    edited July 2009
    Man, it would be cool to see Wally again, though.

    Maybe its because Steve Purcell had a part in both of their creations, but for some reason Wally always made me think of The Geek, from the Sam and Max cartoons. Although I think Wally came first . . .
  • quigon87quigon87
    edited July 2009
    I believe it could be Kate because of the frame up...

    I could alsoe believe its Carla, didnt they leave her half drunk on that commercialized island? Cant remember, but shes always ticked at Threepwood...

    I believe the pirate hunter is a seperate character. The Line "Guybrush Threepwood! Ive waited a long time for this..." ... thats a line from someone whos been searching for awhile, not a just hired bounty hunter. Morgan La fey as an alias? Doesnt fit if you ask me. I say its the sword master and he convinces her to come with him, to which he eventually maroons her again..
  • quigon87quigon87
    edited July 2009
    Nimeni wrote: »
    Man, it would be cool to see Wally again, though.

    Much like Murray, Id be shocked if they didnt include him...
  • LucasJLucasJ
    edited July 2009
    th_62275_carla_122_204lo.jpg
  • CalBearRJCalBearRJ
    edited July 2009
    Nimeni wrote: »
    Kate, definitely. You should turn this into a pole.

    Or even a poll!
  • britt12334britt12334
    edited July 2009
    i think its kate because she was left in jail so should be pretty upset with him
  • britt12334britt12334
    edited July 2009
    quigon87 wrote: »
    Much like Murray, Id be shocked if they didnt include him...

    well he sorta was already in it guybrush thought the skull in the voodoo hut was him
  • PullmanPullman
    edited July 2009
    Carla
  • Ecto CoolerEcto Cooler
    edited July 2009
    Kate capsize's three hour tours!
  • NimeniNimeni
    edited July 2009
    CalBearRJ wrote: »
    Or even a poll!

    You know, I was staring at that trying to figure out why it didn't look right. Apparently I need to sleep more. Or at all.
  • Jerec84Jerec84
    edited July 2009
    I hope it's Kate. It's always cool when a background character comes back and becomes more important to the plot. Carla just doesn't fit it.
  • feverfewfeverfew
    edited July 2009
    img.php?loc=loc215&image=62274_kate_122_215lo.jpg

    Kate. I believe we've already seen a bit too much of Carla. Kate would be someone new :)
  • Important-Looking PirateImportant-Looking Pirate
    edited July 2009
    quigon87 wrote: »
    Much like Murray, Id be shocked if they didnt include him...

    i thought wally was behind the door in the voodoo lady's shack
  • AndyBundyAndyBundy
    edited July 2009
    It must be Kate. I don't think that Carla would mess up her life with a portion Guybrush again, after she may have had some other nightmares because of the nice boat trip in EMI. Also Otis would've been around, too. If there had been a female and a male person theatening Guybrush, it would've been Carla and Otis. And Kate would really fit into that since she was jailed because of Guybrush and for a person with such capsize it's a horrible experience to live with. Maybe she had to talk with Gov. Phatt, too.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.