Wow cookie cut one line out of my entire post... I even stated "Sure the character will be different than the TV one..." so giving a lectur… moree about how she is going to be different is fruitless. I'm just stating why a lot of people including myself are just not interested in the idea. Heck it's worse in the context of if you seen the TV show as some people find it very hard to relate to a different version of a character they already thought they know.
Over all, I'd much prefer seeing a continuation of the existing series and story. Michonne just feels like a side track, a speed bump..
it's a popular character from the TV show and we know that is exactly why it's being made
Well, save for the fact that this is based… more on the comic version of Michonne
And no, they are not the same character. They share the name, they share some basic traits with each other, but the direction of both characters, and by extension the growth and development they go through are definitely different. Seriously, if someone who only watches the TV show starts playing Michonne, they might understand some basic things about her character that the show and the comics did the same, but for the most part, they're going to be lost.
Speaking of that, it's going to be fun when this finally comes out, and the forum gets filled with people asking questions such as "wtf this didn't happen in the show" "This isn't Michonne at all" "Why isn't Danai voicing her"
Maybe people are just not excited about the Michonne episodes. Personally I find the idea crazy, sure it's a popular character from the TV… more show and we know that is exactly why it's being made. To me that is the very problem, sure the character will be different than the TV one but darnit I'm already sick of Michonne, heck I don't even watch the TV show anymore I'm sick of the entire cast.
Probably, just would prefer a side story that branches away from Clem and the crew with a "new" character... or perhaps an expansion or DLC to Season 2 vs Michonne. An entire Carver DLC story arc would be epic for example, all the Cabin group could be part of it all the way up until they leave. xD
Thank you. Not once did the OP bring up Kenny. This discussion is about everyone's opinion of Jane. Sadly, you can't talk about one of the characters without the other being brought up.
Personally I liked Jane's character, we learned about her and we saw her strengths and flaws, she's one of the more human characters in my o… morepinion and probably my favorite character in Season 2. For the people talking about Topics like this being Kenny VS Jane Topics... the OP literally did not mention Kenny at all, what the heck? It's mostly the people who comment in these Threads that talk about what they like/dislike about Jane or Kenny that are starting these arguments by saying one is better/worse than the other even if one of the characters isn't mentioned in the original comment, it's sad seeing people who express their opinion on just one of the characters get pinned down for starting an argument they didn't start. If people dislike any topics about Jane, Kenny or both, then feel free to keep scrolling, yes these Topics can get tedious but it's peoples' own choice to read through these Threads.
I've seen Discussions about a single character that were fine until someone else began an argument over the topic character and another character, I feel like some people purposefully like to instigate arguments and flame wars, scratch that, some people do.
Thank you. Not once did the OP bring up Kenny. This discussion is about everyone's opinion of Jane. Sadly, you can't talk about one of the characters without the other being brought up.
Not true, she was useful at spotting walkers nearby. She was the first one to notice before the whole group does. Also no, she survived the herd on her own. She did a better job than Luke.
Jane didnt have to convince me, I decided if given the chance I would leave Sarah. So that's not on Jane.
That's why you had the option. She did tell you to leave her, Clem wasn't thinking she would be about to leave her. I don't care, nobody tells my Clem to leave her friends die. Jane's heartless
She left the baby in a car. Yes she did. Out of the wind, wrapped in a blanket. AJ was fine when Clem found him in the car and it was for how long? 10-15 mins? I'll guarentee you AJ was warmer in the car than out in the snow storm and safe from walkers.
I said AJ only survived because he has a plot armor. AJ should have been dead ages ago.
You say she was chosen for big roles over other characters. Okay but now your blaming Jane for Telltale decisions.
Yes, I blame J.T Petty for the writing, he wasn't even a Telltale employee, who the hell asked him to do this job or who accepted him to?
You liked the other characters more than jane
I would choose ANYONE over Jane.
So, to the point of this thread, because YOU didnt like certain aspect's of season 2, does not reflect on the character Jane. It's not her fault.
So you mean it's not the writers' fault Jane was created? I wish Nick Breckon wrote Episode 3 and 4.
The whole reason, for me, is Clem's survival.
Same as me. I would do anything to protect Clem from abusers, traitors, manipulaters, liars etc.
* Sarah was useless and going to die eventually. Jane didnt have to convince me, I decided if given the chance I would leave Sarah. So that'… mores not on Jane.
* She made Luke an offer. Okay, but Luke was an adult and fully capable of accepting or refusing that offer. That can't only be held against jane.
* She left the baby in a car. Yes she did. Out of the wind, wrapped in a blanket. AJ was fine when Clem found him in the car and it was for how long? 10-15 mins? I'll guarentee you AJ was warmer in the car than out in the snow storm and safe from walkers.
* You say she was chosen for big roles over other characters. Okay but now your blaming Jane for Telltale decisions. You liked the other characters more than jane, but now can you really blame Jane for that?
* A Molly Spin-Off, okay I can see that, and you didnt like many things about season 2. That's fine. But I did and I liked Jane and I liked Molly. I was hoping for the chance for one of … [view original content]
I never really trusted Jane, I began to like her more towards the end, but she went back to being loner Jane and tried to trick Clem. Also i'm always choosing Kenny. Especially after finding AJ.
The trailer for Michonne hasn't really given much away other than Michonne looking for her daughters. I think once we know a bit more on what happens and the other characters that might stir up some discussions.
I'm fine with Jane. Capable young woman who's relationship with Clem helps her to overcome her self-imposed solitude. Her pragmatism often conflicts with her conscience, which leads her to withdraw from other people. It is easier to live alone, not having to make those hard calls than to face the guilt and grief of outlasting those you care about.
I'm also fine that Molly returned as Jane. They kind of represent the same thing anyway.
you do realize this post was supposed to be opinions on jane as a character
and the jane vs kenny thing started in the comments...
i just stated my opinion on jane but the main objective was the opinions on the characters
i have to admit i liked her in the beggining of episode 4
when she tried to leave sarah i was a bit angry but not much
but in episode 5 ... the baby moment just ticked me off alot .
I like Jane. She's a lone survivor and I can relate to that. I didn't always agree with her, but I don't want to agree with someone 100% of … morethe time. I didn't agree with tricking Clem though. She likes Clem so much, so trust her enough to at least be honest with her.
Do I trust her? Ehhh... She walked away from Clem once, but she did come back for her. I trust her more than I distrust her. Jane's just scared deep down of loss, and fear can cause people to do uncharacteristic things. That's just my opinion though.
I'm fine with Jane. Capable young woman who's relationship with Clem helps her to overcome her self-imposed solitude. Her pragmatism often c… moreonflicts with her conscience, which leads her to withdraw from other people. It is easier to live alone, not having to make those hard calls than to face the guilt and grief of outlasting those you care about.
I'm also fine that Molly returned as Jane. They kind of represent the same thing anyway.
Is this going to be another topic about Kenny/Jane where it inevitably turns into a fight about who is better than another when this topic is about this one person only?
i liked jane in episode 4
i got a little bit angry with the sarah parts and with some of jane s abortion suggestions
but in episode 5 i just kind of started getting really annoyed with her
My opinion is that she did what a lot of people do. She was so hurt that she closed off to protect herself. For survival, she has taken a su… morervivalist attitude in that people who dont want to help themselves will drag others down with them. Also understandable since she witnessed it first hand. But she has proven to me that she does care about people. She came around a lot in only a few episodes.
I've seen Discussions about a single character that were fine until someone else began an argument over the topic character and another char… moreacter, I feel like some people purposefully like to instigate arguments and flame wars, scratch that, some people do.
I never really trusted Jane, I began to like her more towards the end, but she went back to being loner Jane and tried to trick Clem. Also i'm always choosing Kenny. Especially after finding AJ.
Also Molly was awesome! I liked her.
I liked Jane, I trusted her more or less, and I found the choice at the end of S2 to be difficult. But I'm too much of a sentimental bastard, so Jane died because of it
She doesn't make my top ten list, but she's up there... somewhere
I hear that. When Sarah died at the collapsed deck and Jane said she was sorry, I replied back with, "You didn't even want to save her." I can't remember if it was that exact line, but close to it. I don't really have a strong opinion on Sarah, but my thought was, let's be honest here... You had two opportunities to try to save Sarah and your heart wasn't in it, both times.
Her plan involving AJ was reckless, and she came across as desperate. Anyway, even though I like her, I didn't stay with her in the end.
i have to admit i liked her in the beggining of episode 4
when she tried to leave sarah i was a bit angry but not much
but in episode 5 ... the baby moment just ticked me off alot .
I'm saying that Molly cried when she tells Lee about her story and sister. When Jane tells hers, she didn't seem that she cared a lot about her sister.
Yeah but here's the thing, it get's annoying because nearly thread which is related to Kenny and/or Jane turns into a big argument about who's the real good one, when both are really shitty people.
you do realize this post was supposed to be opinions on jane as a character
and the jane vs kenny thing started in the comments...
i just stated my opinion on jane but the main objective was the opinions on the characters
Molly had lost her sister a month ago, as the day we saw Molly with Dr. Logan on the tapes was day 76 since the apocalypse started, and Lee and Co. made it to Savannah around day 105; Jane could've lost her sister anywhere from two years ago to two weeks ago, as there was no information about that.
I'm saying that Molly cried when she tells Lee about her story and sister. When Jane tells hers, she didn't seem that she cared a lot about her sister.
Not everyone is a crier. It doesnt mean you dont care. People put up walls on their emotions all the time. I can see Jane doing that just to keep from going crazy thinking about her sister.
I'm saying that Molly cried when she tells Lee about her story and sister. When Jane tells hers, she didn't seem that she cared a lot about her sister.
First of all, don't put a space in a tag or it will not work.
Lol I know exactly how to use tags. I didn't tag you because this is a… morelready a reply to your comment, so an extra tag would've been redundant and I didn't want to spam your feed. I just wanted people to see I was replying to you, not to one of the other people directly above me.
I know I shouldn't be making a fuss of this
Yeah, you really shouldn't be. It's not that big of a deal.
And what really surprises me is that there aren't any threads talking about the upcoming Michonne game even though that it's only less than a month away from release, aren't there any theories or speculations that the people here have about it rather than that same, boring, debate of which choice was better even though both of them were complete lacklusters.
Tbh I was hoping more people would be doing that myself (I even posted a mondo huge post analyzing at least part… [view original content]
Comments
oh i dont even use sony vegas i use windows movie maker lol
git gud skrub
I was arguing more against how you make it sound like the TV version was the sole reason this was being made in the first place (which it isn't)
But yeah, maybe the lecture part was overdoing it
Edit: internet problems caused this post to double so... lol removing the odd double post.
I made this video in movie maker about that cringe "minecraft story mode roleplay" thread
enter link description here
People will be excited when the game gets close to coming out. Right now, there's just not much to talk about.
He felt all over the place for me. That's just my opinion though.
Probably, just would prefer a side story that branches away from Clem and the crew with a "new" character... or perhaps an expansion or DLC to Season 2 vs Michonne. An entire Carver DLC story arc would be epic for example, all the Cabin group could be part of it all the way up until they leave. xD
Thank you. Not once did the OP bring up Kenny. This discussion is about everyone's opinion of Jane. Sadly, you can't talk about one of the characters without the other being brought up.
I've seen Discussions about a single character that were fine until someone else began an argument over the topic character and another character, I feel like some people purposefully like to instigate arguments and flame wars, scratch that, some people do.
I don't like Jane. Nothing but a botched version of Molly; whom I liked a thousand times better.
Not true, she was useful at spotting walkers nearby. She was the first one to notice before the whole group does. Also no, she survived the herd on her own. She did a better job than Luke.
That's why you had the option. She did tell you to leave her, Clem wasn't thinking she would be about to leave her. I don't care, nobody tells my Clem to leave her friends die. Jane's heartless
I said AJ only survived because he has a plot armor. AJ should have been dead ages ago.
Yes, I blame J.T Petty for the writing, he wasn't even a Telltale employee, who the hell asked him to do this job or who accepted him to?
I would choose ANYONE over Jane.
So you mean it's not the writers' fault Jane was created? I wish Nick Breckon wrote Episode 3 and 4.
Same as me. I would do anything to protect Clem from abusers, traitors, manipulaters, liars etc.
I never really trusted Jane, I began to like her more towards the end, but she went back to being loner Jane and tried to trick Clem. Also i'm always choosing Kenny. Especially after finding AJ.
Also Molly was awesome! I liked her.
Botched? Ehh... I think she was more interesting than Molly, although Molly did have some skills.
Molly was more caring than Jane. She tried very hard to protect her sister, harder than Jane.
The trailer for Michonne hasn't really given much away other than Michonne looking for her daughters. I think once we know a bit more on what happens and the other characters that might stir up some discussions.
I'm fine with Jane. Capable young woman who's relationship with Clem helps her to overcome her self-imposed solitude. Her pragmatism often conflicts with her conscience, which leads her to withdraw from other people. It is easier to live alone, not having to make those hard calls than to face the guilt and grief of outlasting those you care about.
I'm also fine that Molly returned as Jane. They kind of represent the same thing anyway.
M'kay, that's your opinion.
season 1 .
you do realize this post was supposed to be opinions on jane as a character
and the jane vs kenny thing started in the comments...
i just stated my opinion on jane but the main objective was the opinions on the characters
i have to admit i liked her in the beggining of episode 4
when she tried to leave sarah i was a bit angry but not much
but in episode 5 ... the baby moment just ticked me off alot .
they are kind of the same loner trait but with different ideals and morals
i just prefer one instead of the other
i dint even mention Kenny O_o
what mistakes i just stated my opinion? (if its grammar mistakes its probably because im brazilian and make small mistakes from time to time )
hum i dint even mention Kenny...
i was asking for opinions
i liked jane in episode 4
i got a little bit angry with the sarah parts and with some of jane s abortion suggestions
but in episode 5 i just kind of started getting really annoyed with her
pretty much forum arguments in a nutshell
same here
I liked Jane, I trusted her more or less, and I found the choice at the end of S2 to be difficult. But I'm too much of a sentimental bastard, so Jane died because of it
She doesn't make my top ten list, but she's up there... somewhere
I hear that. When Sarah died at the collapsed deck and Jane said she was sorry, I replied back with, "You didn't even want to save her." I can't remember if it was that exact line, but close to it. I don't really have a strong opinion on Sarah, but my thought was, let's be honest here... You had two opportunities to try to save Sarah and your heart wasn't in it, both times.
Her plan involving AJ was reckless, and she came across as desperate. Anyway, even though I like her, I didn't stay with her in the end.
Jane "dragged" her sister (that didn't even want to live) across 4 states.
Molly stood on a community with a capable sister.
Just pointing this out.
Not you, of course. I was referring to the other commentators on this forum.
it was the grammar, friend. no worries.
I'm saying that Molly cried when she tells Lee about her story and sister. When Jane tells hers, she didn't seem that she cared a lot about her sister.
Eye!
Yeah but here's the thing, it get's annoying because nearly thread which is related to Kenny and/or Jane turns into a big argument about who's the real good one, when both are really shitty people.
Molly had lost her sister a month ago, as the day we saw Molly with Dr. Logan on the tapes was day 76 since the apocalypse started, and Lee and Co. made it to Savannah around day 105; Jane could've lost her sister anywhere from two years ago to two weeks ago, as there was no information about that.
Not everyone is a crier. It doesnt mean you dont care. People put up walls on their emotions all the time. I can see Jane doing that just to keep from going crazy thinking about her sister.
enter link description here