What's the hardest choice you've ever made in a Telltale game? (Spoilers for modern Telltale games)
For me, it was leaving Rodrik behind to save Asher in A Nest of Vipers.
Because, you can't help but love both of them, and then eventually...you have to sacrifice one to save the other. Very hard choice.
Anyway, what do you think is the hardest choice?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Off the top of my head, some of the hardest choices included...
Kill or Spare the Crooked Man at the Foundry (Wolf Among Us Episode 5) - Coming into the episode, I was originally one of the people wanting Bigby to kill the Crooked Man if it came down to necessity. However, when I was presented with the choice to do so at the Sheppard Metalworks, I saw he made a good point about never getting answers and only having a town full of people mad at Bigby. Judging by how people act towards Bigby later in the episode if you bring his corpse to the trial, I was super relieved I made the call to give him a trial instead.
How to respond at Highpoint (Game of Thrones Episode 104) - That scene at the dinner with the Whitehills where you are presented with a super quick timer and have to choose how to respond to Ludd threatening Ryon was intense. Thankfully, I called his bluff, but I cannot say I'd have been so brave if I was in Rodrik's shoes in real life.
Walking Dead-Letting Kenny stab Jane or Shoot Kenny
Weirdly it was whether or not to destroy Ivor's house in MC:SM, I just feel a lot more pressure when a whole town is watching (like dealing with the thief in GOT), because it'll affect the mood of the whole place towards you.
Which outfit to pick in Tales from the Borderlands and the powerful urge to blow all your money away on the tuxedo/tiger skin for Loaderbot.
If I had found that machine in episode 3 my money wouldn't have survived.
Shooting Lee from Walking Dead: This choice was super hard, in the end I decided to have Clem leave Lee because I felt like Clem shouldn't have to kill what became her father figure, even though it meant to leave Lee to become a walker
Cutting off your arm from Walking Dead: Just gross and messed up in general, and the fact that you wont even be sure if it will work in the end.
Shooting Kenny in Walking Dead: Some people obviously found the choice to be super easy, but as a big Kenny fan, I was stuck with either killing a character that I loved or sticking with my gut and hoping he was right.
Where to go first in episode 3 of Wolf Among Us: Probably one of the coolest choices Telltale has made, being presented with three different locations to find information to track down Crane with a time limit. Honestly that whole choice of where to go and feeling timed is probably why episode 3 was one of the best Telltale episodes made.
Saving Rodrik or Asher from GoT: Both were such great characters and knowing only one could live and watching them die was definitely hard.
Trust Fiona or Jack from Tales from the Borderlands: This choice wasn't actually that hard for me because I felt that trusting Fiona was definitely the better choice, but the music playing and the tension growing, and wondering if you really could trust Jack, it really did add alot of difficulty to the choice.
Choosing between Doug and Carley, I got attached to them quickly.
Sitting with Kenny or sitting with Luke in A House Divided. Weird, right?
Choosing for Mira to refuse or agree Morgryn's marriage proposal.
That's easy.
Ya let Kenny get his murderboner out one more time. One more time to grant him his only means of release, then as his lustful eyes slowly turn to shame and regret much like many people who can't satisfy their own thirst for violence and bloodshed...
BOOM! Put the old sack out of his misery.
It's a win/win.
I remember pausing the game to think this decision through when I played Season Two xD
Leaving Rodrik or Asher behind. That was toughest decision I've ever done. I paused the game and I was thinking 10 minutes, I chose to save Rodrik cause I liked him more than Asher. I cried at Asher's death harder than Lee's death TBH.
Doud/Carley and whether or not I drop the salt block onto Larry.
First time playing through, I had to pause the game for both decisions.
Cutting Lee's arm off in TWD S1. I wanted him to have a chance to survive so fucking bad.
Yeah, it's easy for you.
But not for @FanofClementine.
Nope because I actually like both of them. So when it comes down to it, when you have 2 characters you like and relate to, it makes the decision much harder.
Yeah, that's what I meant
If it was easy for you great. But for some it was not. I am just giving my side.
And I mine.
That's fine if you found the choice to be difficult, I am merely saying I thought it was farcical at best.
Jane or Kenny in The Walking Dead Season 2.
Trust Fiona or Trust Jack: In the situation, it was quite tough. Fiona's plan was unclear at the time, but she could be trusted, while Jack was pretty determined but you couldn't really trust him. Still, I don't regret trusting Jack, because of the effects it had on the rest of the series and the opening of Episode 3.
Kill or spare Andy St. John: After everything that had happened, with everyone watching, it wasn't easy to make a choice. It really is a powerful scene, to let him suffer or not. With Clementine watching, it really made the choice tough, and I do love when you spare him he goes all crazy.
Mercy kill Georgie Porgie or let him suffer: This choice too. Considering all of the trauma that just occurred before it, it make it really hard to decided. Give the murderer mercy by killing him, let him suffer for his action, or not want to kill him because of qualms about killing.
But don't you ship Rhysha? Jack ruins that
I worked it out.
Delete a Save File to start a new game or not play a new game at all :c
Whether to Trust Jack or Fiona in episode 2.
How to end Lee, let her leave or make her kill him
I would have to say choosing to save either Ashur or Rodrick. I still get sick at my stomach concerning my decision but I stuck by it. I chose Ashur because Ashur is just awesome and I couldn't let him die. I hated I had to kill Rodrick though.....
Trusting Jack or Fiona. I replayed the episode three times before settling on Jack.
Sitting with Luke or Kenny was definitely the hardest choice for me xD
Jane/kenny