›

Saddest Telltale Death? (Please spoiler mark your posts)

fanciesfancies
in General Chat

I'm not sure if this thread has been created before, but I was wondering, in your opinion, what the saddest telltale death scene is?

The saddest, imo, is....

spoilers for walking dead below

...

Carley's death. I was just starting to trust Lilly and gain romantic feelings for Carley. What the frick, Lilly? Then you take off with our RV? Disgusting and heartbreaking. Carley was such a strong woman.

Comments

  • Akimbo_SliceAkimbo_Slice

    For me, it would have to be Kenny's season 2 death. His season 3 death made me bawl my eyes out as well, but it's too quick to really be as heartwrenching as season 2. I still have yet to actually shoot him in any of my playthroughs (and if we're being honest, I probably never will) but I've seen it on YouTube and it has made me cry manly tears.

    I mean, it's no surprise Kenny is my favorite character, and Kenny was one person Clem could always trust. Having Jane manipulate her into thinking Kenny was a monster (think what you will, but I refuse to believe Kenny was turning into a monster) and having to shoot her oldest friend was devastating. When he says "we almost made it" I just lose it.

    Again, his season 3 death hit me pretty hard on my original playthrough, but it was the fact that this was it for Kenny. Subsequent playthroughs won't make me cry because the scene itself is too short to really be emotional. His season 2 death on the other hand, that's just brutal.

  • Creeper1846Creeper1846

    Almost everyone is going to pick lee and I am to but other than him I would say Marina (I think that's her name) the girl in twd ANF who always listened to music through headphones until she got headshot it filled me with anger towards the people and it's more emotional if you choose to fight back afterwards because it shows a burial scene.

  • CooCooColeCooCooCole

    Jane's S3 death had me shook for days. When I put her down, I literally had to pause the game and walk around my house for some time.

    I think it was the fact that she not only killed one, but she killed two.

    In the end, she was just a scared young adult who felt like there was no point in living. So tragic.

    Also because it was Luke's baby. Ugh.

  • BroKennyBroKenny

    Amen, brother.

    Akimbo_Slice posted: » [view original content]
  • SoundwastelandSoundwasteland
    edited December 2016

    Definitely Lee in Walking Dead Season 1. It's self explanatory.

    I would say though that the second one was Oscar in Jurassic Park. I was very upset that he gave his life for everyone else and he went out fighting like a man. Oscar was easily one of my favorite characters in the game and I loved playing as him. That knife fight was incredible.

  • AronDraculaAronDracula
    1. Lee Everett (The Walking Dead Season 1): One of the most memorable moments in video game history
    2. Asher Forrester (Game of Thrones): This got me so hard, I was never expecting this type of situation
    3. Loader Bot and Sasha (Tales from the Borderlands): Even though they didn't actually die, they still got me because I love them so much
    4. Sarah (The Walking Dead Season 2): She could have been saved but fucking assholes didn't do shit to save her, the only character I like in S2
    5. Kenny (The Walking Dead Season 3): Left behind and suffered so Clem and AJ could escape, I'll never forgive Telltale for that shit
  • Flog61Flog61

    Kenny was one person Clem could always trust

    You mean determinantly, right?

    Akimbo_Slice posted: » [view original content]
  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator

    Lee is a obvious one but another death that i found sad was Scooter in Tales from the Borderlands.

  • deleted_knp6v7vc4878350deleted_knp6v7vc4878350
    edited December 2016
    1. TWD Lee (for obvious reasons)
    2. TWD Kenny S3 (I let him kill Jane in S2)
    3. Reuben MCSM not a lot of people will put him but I bawled so much, I actually predicted it
    4. TWD Sarah she was one of my favs (she died while trapped underneath that wood thing)
    5. TWD Luke I kind of predicted it but I stil cried
  • ClemyClooAndBabybooClemyClooAndBabyboo
    edited December 2016

    Omid's death. It was pretty sad how poorly written and badly executed it was. Still brings a tear to my eye. sniffles

    EDIT: No but seriously, my saddest is definitely Asher from Game of Thrones Episode 5, or Rodrik (if you're stupid kek). It was a pretty amazing choice, especially for one of Telltale's newer games. And it lead to a grim fate.

  • HarpadarpaHarpadarpa

    Duck. Easily Duck. I didn't cry at any other point in any other TTG game, but with Duck and Katjaa, God...

    Watching this goofy fucker

    enter image description here

    Turn into this:

    enter image description here

    Was tragic, regardless of whether he was annoying or not. and then Katjaa killing herself... Jesus. That was the first time I really felt for Kenny in the series. From then on, I always at least tried to make him more comfortable if nothing else. He didn't deserve that. Nobody did.

  • WalkerMage102WalkerMage102

    The Death of the Quality of The Walking Dead Season 1

  • bloopbloop

    enter image description here

  • CooCooColeCooCooCole

    ROASTED ASF

    WalkerMage102 posted: »

    The Death of the Quality of The Walking Dead Season 1

  • AnimalBoyAnimalBoy
    edited December 2016

    Kenny in season 3. He was a character that i wanted to see make it because he had gone through so much sadness. I miss him.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    The death of mattering choices.

  • BetterToSleepBetterToSleep

    She can trust his corpse to this day.

    Flog61 posted: »

    Kenny was one person Clem could always trust You mean determinantly, right?

  • ThreeDaysRiseThreeDaysRise
    edited January 2017

    Gawd, this is hard. Uhhh, well:

    1. Lee (TWD S1) Even though I didn't choose Clem to shoot him, but still. Her crying made my heart break so damn hard ;-;
    2. Asher/Rodrik (GoT) This choice truly killed me. I sat like around 15 minutes in front of my TV, thinking about who I should leave behind. I chose in my first playthrough Rodrik and in my second one Asher, just to see how the game ends then.
    3. Sasha (TFTB) I know, she didn't die actually and what happened when she got healed by that weird clock made me laugh and cry of happiness at the same time, but I remember how I just sat there, crying and talking to myself: THIS CAN'T BE FC*IN TRUE!
    4. Mariana (TWD S3) I wasn't sure if I should choose her as third or not, but well, I was just starring open-mouthed at my TV when she died. Everything just seemed so fine and lucky (which was very suspicious anyway) and then BOOM out of nothing, she got shot in her head ._.
  • Ekelund21Ekelund21
    • Lee: From what I can remember, the first time something fictional made me tear up.
    • Scooter: I was surprised when this made me tear up, I only knew him from TFTB, hadn't played the other Borderlands games at the time, but he was one of my favorite characters in that game, and maybe the funniest.
    • Sasha: If her not-death counts, it's the only one that made me outright cry. Never expected Tales to give me the feels when I bought it.
  • Lee Everett Lee Everett
    1. ) Lee - He was honestly my most favorite character in the entirety of The Walking Dead and probably my most favorite character in all of gaming. All saw something of myself in him.
    2. ) Kenny( A New frontier's death) As shitty as the writing was it is no secret that I was upset that he died as he was my 3rd favorite Character of TWD.
    3. ) Scooter- I really liked this guy, he was funny as hell, he was the main reason why we got a lot of things done, it really hurt me in the feels when he died. I made sure to honor him.
  • AdamiksAdamiks
    edited January 2017

    Only Lee's death made my cry like a baby.

    "I will miss you"

    Second one was Kenny's death, but in my original playthrough i never killed him. So when i did, i rather felt anger, knowing that Jane hid AJ all that time....

    I think it's worth to point out that scene in front of Wellington's gates was really heartbreaking too, even though nobody died.

  • ShatterMe310ShatterMe310

    Lilly's in TWD. She pretty much died, but if we're talking about official deaths, probably Omid's in TWD.

  • Akimbo_SliceAkimbo_Slice
    edited January 2017

    Yeah, the Wellington ending, especially if you leave Kenny, is honestly probably the most heartbreaking scene for me in all of Telltale's games, but I suppose it doesn't count since nobody dies.

    Adamiks posted: » [view original content]
  • SnorkachuSnorkachu
    edited January 2017

    Kenny's death in A New Frontier. (I left Wellington with him) It wasn't the best way for Kenny to go and I was disappointed with his death, but just because one is a strong survivor doesn't mean fatal accidents don't happen to them. And at least it was better than Jane's, who told Clementine that she wouldn't leave her again (Season 2 Episode 5) and then she kills herself because she was pregnant, which was very out of character.

  • UrbanRodrikUrbanRodrik

    1: Asher s death in Game of thrones was really unexpected and i really liked his character.

    2:Lee

  • TheFurryOneTheFurryOne

  • aManWhoLovesTelltaleaManWhoLovesTelltale Banned

    You say that as if they mattered in the first place...

    TheAutisticGamer posted: »

    The death of mattering choices.

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer
    edited January 2017

    They did.

    aManWhoLovesTelltale posted: »

    You say that as if they mattered in the first place...

  • jhti0612jhti0612
    edited January 2017

    Guys, the walking dead season 2, is it better on the ps4 or the Xbox 360?

  • TheAutisticGamerTheAutisticGamer

    PS4. I don't see what this has to do with the saddest death in a Telltale game, though. :D

    jhti0612 posted: » [view original content]
Sign in to comment in this discussion.