Through the entirety of Telltales games which were the saddest and which were the most deserving?
In ALL of the games that you have played, which were the saddest deaths and which were the most deserving deaths. Despite how satisfying or heartbreaking those deaths were...
Make your Top 5s MEANINGFUL!
My Top 5 Saddest Deaths:
5 - Ethan (Kid had the balls to stand up to Ramsay)
4 - Scooter (See ya, Space Cowboy...)
3 - Asher ( While being a stray, he died valiantly)
2 - Vivian (Although it was because of her the girls died for protection, she had a VERY dark secret on her, plus her death is heartbreaking)
1 - Lee or Kenny (I can't really choose which one is sadder, since it's SO difficult to decide 
)
My Top 5 Most Deserving Deaths:
5 - The Stranger (Ok, so he MAY not be around much time but he's one of the reasons Lee and Clem got seperated)
4 - Lord Whitehill (Couldn't forgive myself for letting Asher die, this bastard had it coming)
3 - Jane (Ok sure, what was shown in S3 showed more reason to 'forgive' her of what happened in S2 but I still believe she would've left AJ to die IF Clem hadn't survived S2)
2 - Handsome Jack (Ok sure, he's somewhat dead but still, he was using you since Ep.2)
1 - Bloody Mary (This ***** was pretty much unbeatable, even when she just appeared, she just gave away an aura of creepiness and the scariest of dialogue)
What about you guys 
?
Comments
I cannot pick too many, because I don't want to feel too sad thinking and remembering all those sadness.
But Lee's death is undoubtedly the saddest. Although he succeeded with saving Clementine, he is doomed to die regardless of his action of his noble and heroic deed. Also the fact that he know that he acknowledge that he'll never see Clementine again, which make "I'll miss you" a insanely tearjerking final good bye.
Handsome Jack's death is the most deserving death in my opinion. But it was also an emotional death for me. I played and finished Borderlands 2 before Tales from the Borderlands got released. Over the course of Borderlands 2, I felt an odd worthy-adversary relationship with Handsome Jack. He is like the Joker who stays around to give you challenge and fun. His death in Borderlands 2 wasn't satisfying and conclusive, it felt like my battle with him wasn't over yet. I was relieved and happy to see his return in Tales from the Borderlands and the final confrontation with him in Episode 5, was the best way to give this villain a conclusive and satisfying death. I have finally defeated him, but I am also sad to see my nemesis/frenemy disappear forever. Which is why I apologized before killing him.
Saddest death? Aww man...it's either Lee or Asher/Rodrik.
Most deserving death would be Carver or The Crooked Man if you decide to strangle him at the Sheppard Factory.
Saddest was Rodrik/Asher. It just wasn't fair after everything they had been through just to get to that point.
Most deserving was Carver, at least it felt that way. Fucker shot Walter, beat and tortured everyone, and abducted them to be forced labor at his prison community. Beating Kenny awoke the beast though and he didn't survive it.
Saddest:
5 Georgie (Don't get me wrong he was an asshole but he was a dumb one, a pawn controlled by someone far worse.)
4. Katjaa and Duck (Truly saddening)
3. Lawrence (Poor guy... Lost his wife and didn't know how to cope)
2. Kenny (Season 1)
1. Lee
Most Deserved
5. Luke (Just because he was dumb enough to get himself shot and walk on ice with a rifle at his back)
4. Carver (Died to soon but somewhat satisfying)
3. The Stranger (What a creep)
2. The Crooked Man ( It was so satisfying to see this interesting, charismatic piece of shit die)
1. Danny St. John (Dude fuck this guy. He's the most evil character Telltale has yet to conceive)
Saddest was Lee for me, really gets me whenever I play it again, I was really worried at the end of Tales From The Borderlands too.
The ending of Tales From The Borderlands was something UNEXPECTED. I was confused at first but after awhile I understood that both Fiona & Rhys went somewhere else but damn what a cliffhanger
Top 5 saddest deaths:
Honorable mentions: Sarah (Her 1st death. Her 2nd death is nothing but shock value.), Ethan, Georgie, Katjaa and Duck.
Top 5 most deserving deaths:
Honorable mentions: Troy and Carver
Okay, I guess I'll list those that made me cry/teary eyed (I love crying at sad stuff):
(5 being saddest. I couldn't figure out how to make the number list flip around)
Saddest
Asher/Rodrik
Scooter
Katjaa/Duck
Reuben
Lee
Most Deserved
Felix
Carver
The Crooked Man
The St. Johns
Handsome Jack
Fionas hat in Tales from the Borderlands
cries