›

Even though choices aren't showing, what did everyone do?

MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules
edited September 2018 in The Walking Dead

It feels odd not having a thread dedicated to what choices we made in the episode. Understandable, considering the servers have been shut down, but I still don't see why we can't discuss the choices we did make in this episode. Plus, it will help us get out minds off of everything that's happening.

Leave whatever choices you made that you think would be the biggest from the episode. Here, I'll start:

  1. I accepted Lilly's hand when she helped me stand up.
  2. I told Violet to shoot Lilly.
  3. I listened to James and decided to distract the walker.
  4. I buried the former nurse.
  5. I went with Louis after the card game (and kissed him).
  6. I saved Louis over Violet.

These are just some examples, leave the choices you think were most important here. And if you want, you can also post the character relations as well, since those worked fine.

EDIT: Pipas made a poll for each choice:

https://strawpoll.me/16531017
https://strawpoll.me/16531025
https://strawpoll.me/16531040
https://strawpoll.me/16531047
https://strawpoll.me/16531077
https://strawpoll.me/16531072

«1

Comments

  • SaltyliquoriceSaltyliquorice
    1. Accepted Lilly's hand
    2. Told them to run
    3. Distracted the walker
    4. Buried the nurse
    5. Went with Violet after card game
    6. Saved Louis

    (Bonus: Told Violet that we are really good friends)

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    (Bonus: Told Violet that we are really good friends)

    Ouch, that's harsh.

    Saltyliquorice posted: »

    * Accepted Lilly's hand * Told them to run * Distracted the walker * Buried the nurse * Went with Violet after card game * Saved Louis (Bonus: Told Violet that we are really good friends)

  • CarverDidNothingWrongCarverDidNothingWrong
    1. Told AJ that he was justified
    2. Didn't take Lilly's hand
    3. Told Violet to shoot
    4. Distracted the walker
    5. Burned the nurse
    6. Went with Violet
    7. Kissed Violet
    8. Saved Violet
  • MosesARoseMosesARose
    edited September 2018

    This is everything I did as well. Besides burning the nurse lol.

    CarverDidNothingWrong posted: »

    * Told AJ that he was justified * Didn't take Lilly's hand * Told Violet to shoot * Distracted the walker * Burned the nurse * Went with Violet * Kissed Violet * Saved Violet

  • CarverDidNothingWrongCarverDidNothingWrong

    Respect

    MosesARose posted: »

    This is everything I did as well. Besides burning the nurse lol.

  • Dat1Wizard246Dat1Wizard246

    What happens when you tell violet to shoot? I told her to run.

    CarverDidNothingWrong posted: »

    * Told AJ that he was justified * Didn't take Lilly's hand * Told Violet to shoot * Distracted the walker * Burned the nurse * Went with Violet * Kissed Violet * Saved Violet

  • CarverDidNothingWrongCarverDidNothingWrong

    I can't remember if she misses but Louis gets shot lol

    Dat1Wizard246 posted: »

    What happens when you tell violet to shoot? I told her to run.

  • Dat1Wizard246Dat1Wizard246

    Oh shit. Glad I told them to run.

    CarverDidNothingWrong posted: »

    I can't remember if she misses but Louis gets shot lol

  • NexusFireNexusFire

    I have the exact same choices as you.

  • Explodingkittens971Explodingkittens971
    edited August 2019

    ...

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    She hits Lilly with a bow, but Abel shoots Louis in the arm.

    Dat1Wizard246 posted: »

    What happens when you tell violet to shoot? I told her to run.

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    Nice.

    NexusFire posted: »

    I have the exact same choices as you.

  • Dat1Wizard246Dat1Wizard246
    1. I told AJ he was justified.
    2. I accepted Lily’s hand.
    3. I told Violet and Louis to run
    4. I distracted the walker (and overall completely trusted James)
    5. Buried the nurse
    6. Went with Louis after card game.
    7. Saved Louis over Violet.
  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules
    edited September 2018

    Went with Louis after card game.
    Saved Louis over Violet.

    Really, now that surprises me, nothing could have possibly given that away.

    Dat1Wizard246 posted: »

    * I told AJ he was justified. * I accepted Lily’s hand. * I told Violet and Louis to run * I distracted the walker (and overall completely trusted James) * Buried the nurse * Went with Louis after card game. * Saved Louis over Violet.

  • bobshawbobshaw
    edited September 2018

    1) I accepted Lilys hand.

    2) Told Violet to shoot.

    3) I distracted the walker.

    4) I burried the nurse (because i felt bad for calling her fertiliser even though it was funny).

    5) Went with Violet and friendzoned the shit out of her. I regretted it though and might break my first play through code of conduct to change this decision, im undecided.

    6) I saved Violet.

  • Dat1Wizard246Dat1Wizard246

    Tbh I was kinda pissed at him when he told me to take away Aj’s gun. I was like “man you mess around with my boi AJ u gonna get it” But when I came back to the school he acted like a nice guy again. It’s actually crazy to think he still went back to liking/caring for AJ and Clem when AJ literally shot his best friend days ago.

    MetallicaRules posted: »

    Went with Louis after card game. Saved Louis over Violet. Really, now that surprises me, nothing could have possibly given that away.

  • Kenny_The_AlmightyKenny_The_Almighty

    1) Refused Lilly's hand
    2) Told Violet to shoot
    3) Distracted the walker
    4) Burried the nurse
    5) Went with Louis and frienzoned him

    6) Still saved him over Violet and I feel a bit bad about it given she was one of the few who wanted us to stay

  • EleanorBigbyEleanorBigby

    I had the exact same choices as you. I'm curious whether you told AJ he was justified in killing Marlon or if he was a murderer? They were really trying to push Marlon as a monster this episode, weren't they? Even though I kept saying it was AJ's fault.

    "Spit on Marlon's grave"

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    Good options to add.

    1. As much as I love AJ, I told him that he murdered AJ. He needs to know the difference between justified and unjustified killing, even if it hurts him a bit.
    2. I did not spit on Marlon's grave.
    EleanorBigby posted: »

    I had the exact same choices as you. I'm curious whether you told AJ he was justified in killing Marlon or if he was a murderer? They were r

  • EleanorBigbyEleanorBigby

    It's like we're the same person lmao. Yeah that whole spit on Marlon's grave choice was a bit too far...I really wonder what % of fans chose to do that.

    MetallicaRules posted: »

    Good options to add. * As much as I love AJ, I told him that he murdered AJ. He needs to know the difference between justified and unjustified killing, even if it hurts him a bit. * I did not spit on Marlon's grave.

  • CheddarheadCheddarhead
    edited September 2018
    1. Told AJ he was in the wrong
    2. Accepted Lilly's hand
    3. Told Violet to run
    4. Distracted the walker
    5. Buried Ms. Martin
    6. Went with Violet but stayed platonic
    7. Saved Violet
  • PipasPipas
    1. Accepted Lilly's help
    2. Told Louis and Violet to run
    3. Distracted the walker
    4. Buried the nurse
    5. Went with Violet and kissed her
    6. Saved Violet

    Also I made some polls of the choices, maybe @MetallicaRules could put it in the OP? Not everyone likes to comment on the forums and I'd really like to at least see the percentages of the choices people on the forums made. (also feel free to create polls of the choices I missed)

    https://strawpoll.me/16531017
    https://strawpoll.me/16531025
    https://strawpoll.me/16531040
    https://strawpoll.me/16531047
    https://strawpoll.me/16531077
    https://strawpoll.me/16531072

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules
    edited September 2018

    That's a great idea, thanks for this.

    Pipas posted: »

    * Accepted Lilly's help * Told Louis and Violet to run * Distracted the walker * Buried the nurse * Went with Violet and kissed her * S

  • Poogers555Poogers555

    tfw choices arnt showing cuz telltale is so fucked atm

    I accepted Lilly's hand when she helped me stand up.

    I told Violet and Louis to run

    I listened to James and decided to distract the walker.

    I didnt say anything about the nurse, but it leads to us burning her.

    I went with Louis after the card game (and kissed him) cuz the music was nice yo, and cuz possibly no future episodes so fuck it I guess.

    I saved Louis over Violet.

  • Poogers555Poogers555

    yo real talk tho it be funny as fuck to flirt with Louis during that scene, draw the heart around the C + L and then going "you're a good friend."

    oof.

    Kenny_The_Almighty posted: »

    1) Refused Lilly's hand 2) Told Violet to shoot 3) Distracted the walker 4) Burried the nurse 5) Went with Louis and frienzoned him

  • prink34320prink34320

    Told AJ he was a murderer.
    Accepted Lilly's help.
    Told Louis and Violet to run.
    Distracted the walker.
    Buried Ms. Martin.
    Went with Violet and became her girlfriend.
    Saved Violet.

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    My God, everything is backwards now.

    My once trusted ally in Pipas supports Violet x Clem, while my mortal enemy Poogs supports Louis x Clem like I do.

  • HersaniHersani

    1) I accepted Lilly hand
    2) I told Louis and Vi to run
    3) I distracted the walkers
    4) buried the nurse
    5) Went with Vi, and friendzoned
    6) Saved Vi

  • bruzdaabruzdaa
    1. Told AJ that what he did was murder.
    2. I Accepted Lily's help
    3. Told Violet to run
    4. Distracted the Walker
    5. Buried the nurse
    6. Told AJ not to swear(again)
    7. Went with Violet and, well, friendzoned her

    8. Saved Louis over Violet(wanted to try something else)

      And the most important one:
      I petted(or pet?) the shit out of Rosie

  • Hillbilly_DaveHillbilly_Dave

    I refused Lilly's hand and stood on my own.
    I told Violet to shoot.
    I listened to James and distracted the walker (I felt like the least I could do after he helped me is honor his request)
    I buried the nurse.
    I went with Violet after the card game (no romance).
    I saved Louis (though I'm gonna replay the episode to save Violet instead. I chose Louis because I was trying to shoot Lilly but it wasn't her).

  • PipasPipas

    It is indeed the end of times.

    To be fair, Louis is still a cool character and I wouldn't mind if Clem ended up with him. But yeah, I prefer Violet.

    MetallicaRules posted: »

    My God, everything is backwards now. My once trusted ally in Pipas supports Violet x Clem, while my mortal enemy Poogs supports Louis x Clem like I do.

  • MaikelRRRMaikelRRR Banned

    Accepted Lilly's hand
    Told them to run
    Distracted the walker
    Buried the nurse
    Went with Louis after card game
    Saved Louis

  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules

    It's fine, I'm just messing around. I also love Violet, I just don't see their relationship that way and I prefer them as friends. Although I can't imagine she'll be too fond of me if we were to rescue her.

    Pipas posted: »

    It is indeed the end of times. To be fair, Louis is still a cool character and I wouldn't mind if Clem ended up with him. But yeah, I prefer Violet.

  • FirewallcanoFirewallcano

    1. Accepted lilly's hand. I really dont see a reason not to bar pure spite

    2. Told violet to shoot

    3. Distracted

    4. Stayed silent as didnt care what happened (please stop trying to make me care about random walkers)

    5. Went with violet (friendzoned her)

    6. Saved Louis, really its because violet can likely handle being kidnapped better than he can

  • ifrahdbifrahdb

    I justified AJ’s action of killing Marlon
    I accepted Lilly's hand when she helped me stand up.
    I told Violet to shoot Lilly.
    I listened to James and decided to distract the walker, even though I wanted to kill it so bad lol
    I buried the former nurse.
    I went with Violet after the card game (and kissed her)
    I saved Violet instead of Louis.

    Sucks that we can’t see eachother choices at the end of the episode though :/

  • enzeruanimefanenzeruanimefan
    1. Told AJ he shouldn't have shot Marlon
    2. Took Lilly's hand
    3. Told them to run
    4. Distracted the walker
    5. Burried the nurse
    6. Went with Violet
    7. Asked her to take it slow
    8. Saved Violet (I'm sorry, Louis)
    9. Picked Willy's trap
    10. Took the apple
    11. Said that even monsters get funerals
    12. Let AJ patrol
    13. Got all collectibles on the first run (not counting Tenn's doll)
    14. Apologized to Louis
    15. Gave AJ the disco broccoli shirt
    16. Married Ruby, flipped Aasim, killed James
    17. Told Vi that Lilly used to be a friend
    18. Didn't spit on Marlon's grave
    19. Pet Rosie
    20. Gave Louis AJ's gun
    21. Dared Aasim to hit on Ruby
    22. Went into the greenhouse without a fight
    23. Asked AJ to not go after Abel, beat him in rock-paper-scissors
  • ArchielanArchielan
    1. I accepted Lilly's hand (I mean, It's not like I had any other choice).
    2. I told Violet and Louis to run.
    3. I did what James asked. I accepted his food and distracted the Walker with the rock (He saved Clem and AJ. I had no reason to not trust him).
    4. I followed Violet to the bell tower but friendzoned her. (I like her but my Clem is straight and I don't think Louis is good enough for her and things between me and him weren't that great anyway).
    5. I saved Violet
  • AnimalBoyAnimalBoy
    1. You did have the option to get up on your own.
    Archielan posted: »

    * I accepted Lilly's hand (I mean, It's not like I had any other choice). * I told Violet and Louis to run. * I did what James asked. I ac

  • ArchielanArchielan

    I know, but I couldn't risk pissing them off when I was at gunpoint.

    AnimalBoy posted: »

    * You did have the option to get up on your own.

  • Dat1Wizard246Dat1Wizard246
    edited September 2018

    Is it possible to not shoot Lily after the explosion? Like the game does the ‘aim to shoot’ deal and I’m wondering if I could’ve chosen to not shoot her.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.