More dangerous? Jane or ANF Clem
Both were violent characters in their season but which was the most dangerous? Jane from Season 2 or the ANF version of Clementine
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Both were violent characters in their season but which was the most dangerous? Jane from Season 2 or the ANF version of Clementine
Comments
How was Jane dangerous?
The woman left a baby out in the freezing cold near a herd of Walkers, just to provoke Kenny and prove a point to Clem
Jane technically got more people killed and doesn't even have youth on her side, so let's go with her.
Meh
She left him in a car where it had more warmth and protection than being kept out in the cold where walkers could come up from anywhere in the blizzard (and there were no walkers near the car)... if she was really that dangerous she could've just left AJ in the snow and played it off as her losing him in the blizzard..
Clementine, for the sheer fact that Jane dies no matter what (from what we know), otherwise still Clem because she's managed to escape many ridiculous situations and has been able to kill more dangerous people since she was 9.
If you do absolutely nothing during the fight in S2. Kenny, an old man with one eye beats Jane. She had skills, but they counted for nothing in a fight against the boat god. So, I'd have to go with Clem.
S3 Clem because she shoots people accurately and doesn’t get emotionally wrecked by it afterwards. Look at Jane when she stabbed the russian guy in the neck. She regretted it and was more shook than Haiti after the earthquake.
So what you're saying is...both are stupid.
I’m saying Jane is.
Oh here we go with this shit.....I pick Jane because even if clem in anf looked similar to her behavior Jane was a ruthless bitch who wouldn't give a fuck about her group and does questionable acts to prove a point....
MiniJane: These bullets don't work!
Eli: Sure they don't. .
MiniJane: You--...ripoff artist!
. * Threatens him with gun loaded with said blanks *
i don't know if this is meant dangerous personality-wise or physically. If its physically then obviously Jane
This is a pretty good question. I think I have to go with Clem here. Sorry Clem.
I can never understand why you call s3 Clem MiniJane. If anything she's a MiniKenny.
If you mean Lilly and Jane, then yes
Not my nickname, believe it or not. Other people were calling her that back then and I decided to occasionally use it myself instead of "ANF!Clementine."
No, I didn't. Did you forget what thread you're in?
...Okay, Lilith kinda is now, but not Lily herself originally.
That's actually a pretty fucking good point. I totally forgot about that since ANF is that forgettable.
You forgot a glaring act that's OOC?
Jane was dangerous, Clementine herself says "so you put AJ in danger and got my friend killed just to prove a point" and anyone who thinks otherwise or defends her are idiots in my opinion. The car would have been just as cold as outside especially given the small crack in the window that was left open. She is dangerous because she has proven she'll use a helpless human being to achieve what she wants. She can't be trusted and that is the main issue. TRUST! She didn't need to do what she did to prove a point. Then there is the stuff with Sarah and virtually forcing Clementine to leave her and not even try to persuade her.
So fuck Jane and fuck any fan who disgustingly supports her.
If you're speaking of dangerous to themselves and their own group, then Jane. Her reckless behavior compromised where Rebecca was giving birth, which in turn lead to the death of Sarah if she hadn't died previously, as well as her own later suicide. Her choice to rob Arvo cost a lot of people their lives, ultimately lead to Clementine being shot and the group splitting up.
If you're speaking of dangerous to others, then Clementine. She's got that main character Kevlar, and powers through everything.
Oh look,"these people don't agree with my opinion so they're idiots and i'm obviously right" lol,pathetic.
I can’t even consider it an opinion when someone actually defends Jane for what she did so the only pathetic ones are those that support her for the psychotic shit she did.
I don't think i've seen a lot of people actually "defending" Jane for what she did,everyone knew that hiding AJ just to prove a point was a bad idea,even Jane knew that plan was stupid and admitted it later,but i've seen people forgiving Jane for what she did,some didn't but some did.
Anyway i've talked about this hundreds of time so i'm not even gonna get into this again,just stop insulting people for having a different opinion than yours because that's not helping.
The whole point was sheltering him from the snow, so he wouldn’t get wet and freeze. Because, you know, blizzard? A car with a window just slightly open so there would be air flowing in was the safest place for the baby. And Jane did care enough to crack that window open.
Actually, I'm sure the window was already cracked when she found it. She was in a hurry after all.
Their point was that the window cracked when more blizzard air was being let in..
What. Rebecca only ever gets out of the herd because of Jane and her skills. The place you say she compromised was only ever available because of Jane and her skills. Luke and Sarah only ever make it back to the group alive because Jane decides to go looking for them, and again, has the skills to rescue them. Arvo’s group didn’t need anyone stealing from them to attack us since they do it regardless and their dialogue actually reveals Vitali and Buricko chose to do it on a whim.
I don’t think having sex with Luke was wise at all and I make no excuses for it - it was reckless, but Jane had her job done, Luke was the one who did not. Also worth noting that their sex didn’t generate that herd, it was coming whether Luke was watching the treeline or not.
The episode writers/directors purposefully put that window there just so slightly cracked open. I don’t believe for a second that wasn’t a deliberate decision to show Jane didn’t just throw the baby in whatever. She also chose a car relatively close to the rest stop, everything points to care.
The temperature was not something you were able to control in this situation. It was going to be cold anywhere really, window cracked open or not. The point was sheltering the baby from the snow, which would turn into freezing water and kill the baby should he not have been put in that car.
It doesn’t matter about her “intentions” for Clem, she put the baby in danger and Clementine herself says so afterwards, it is in the game like it or not.
If Kenny had killed Jane and the baby hadn’t cried, he would have starved or froze to death in that car as Clem or Kenny would not have known where he was due to believing he was already dead. That is the reason Jane is a dangerous bitch who cannot be trusted who also had plenty of opportunity to confess her idiotic and psychotic plan before it got way out of hand or better still if she hadn’t pulled the stunt in the first place. That is why i would always trust Kenny over her. At least he can be trusted and has never lied to anyone about anything.
Seriously fuck Jane!
Jane literally put a infant in a snow bank during a zombie apcolypse with flesh eating monsters lingering around looking for human flesh while she literally brawled Kenny for the sake of proving a false idea that Kenny was unstable.
Jane was a selfish spontaneous bitch and she is way more dangerous.
ANF Clem is really only dangerous if you attempt to kill her or innocent people or do something dumb. She's still a good person. She wasn't just endangering lives and killing for the fuck of it like Jane.
Kenny was unstable, though. That was pretty obvious.
Which just makes what Jane pulled all the more self-righteous.