I originally thought it was Lily as well, and even after a few listens, I still thought it was. However, I found out that her VA is Cherami … moreLeigh, the VA of Gaige from Borderlands 2. After I learned that and watched the trailer again, there's no doubt that it was Minnie who said that, not Lily. It sounds way too much like a more level headed, less insane Gaige. If you want to check for yourself, listen to this video, and then rewatch the trailer when the line comes up, you can definitely hear it.
I originally thought it was Lily as well, and even after a few listens, I still thought it was. However, I found out that her VA is Cherami … moreLeigh, the VA of Gaige from Borderlands 2. After I learned that and watched the trailer again, there's no doubt that it was Minnie who said that, not Lily. It sounds way too much like a more level headed, less insane Gaige. If you want to check for yourself, listen to this video, and then rewatch the trailer when the line comes up, you can definitely hear it.
Like I said, I thought it was Lily too, but subsequent listens have me almost 100% confident that it's Minerva. After playing as Gaige countless times in Borderlands 2, I can definitely tell that's her. If I'm wrong, I'll eat my words, but I really don't think I'm wrong here to say that that is Minerva in the trailer.
I thought you were just throwing it back in my face to be rude, not asking a legitimate question. Obviously because Clem considers the school her home now and it's residents her friends aka 'people'
I thought you were just throwing it back in my face to be rude, not asking a legitimate question. Obviously because Clem considers the school her home now and it's residents her friends aka 'people'
There was supposed to be a winking face at the end there, but I forgot to put it.
Anyway, I was legitimately asking a question since I couldn't think of an answer at the immediate time. I could've sworn I did eventually answer it though.
I'll have to keep listening when I have the time, cause believe me when I say I'm really trying to hear it. The whisper makes it difficult to decipher it being anyone else's but Lilly's. But with this being an idea now, yeah, my trust meter for Minnie is steadily declining. Why does the 15th feel so far away?
Like I said, I thought it was Lily too, but subsequent listens have me almost 100% confident that it's Minerva. After playing as Gaige count… moreless times in Borderlands 2, I can definitely tell that's her. If I'm wrong, I'll eat my words, but I really don't think I'm wrong here to say that that is Minerva in the trailer.
Pretty sure Lilly said that one. Minerva wouldn’t want to send her own friends, and ?past? Girlfriend into a war, when she could just tell them to move someplace else. Plus the camera cuts to Lilly when that line is said, with her just looking at something and not doing anything else, therefore it’s definitely Lilly, there’d be no point in that shot, as well as playing a voice as soon as it shows up that happens to sound like her, otherwise.
Before today, I'd say I would trust her, mainly because we haven't been given a reason not to. She was traded by Marlon against her will to … moreLily and Abel, and she was Violet's girlfriend and Tenn's sister, I'd figured she'd want to get out of there more than anyone.
After watching the trailer, no, I don't think we can trust her. Her line, "The only way you're going to save your people is to let us take them" does not sound very friendly or trustworthy, almost sounds like she's siding with the Delta. Maybe I'm wrong, maybe it's a ruse, I don't know, but right now, I'm not sure we can trust her if we're going off of what she said in the trailer.
I watched it again right now,and you're right,i totally hear Lilly there,and the camera cuts to Lilly when she says that,she's just whispering it's totally her.
Pretty sure Lilly said that one. Minerva wouldn’t want to send her own friends, and ?past? Girlfriend into a war, when she could just tell t… morehem to move someplace else. Plus the camera cuts to Lilly when that line is said, with her just looking at something and not doing anything else, therefore it’s definitely Lilly, there’d be no point in that shot, as well as playing a voice as soon as it shows up that happens to sound like her, otherwise.
Pretty sure Lilly said that one. Minerva wouldn’t want to send her own friends, and ?past? Girlfriend into a war, when she could just tell t… morehem to move someplace else. Plus the camera cuts to Lilly when that line is said, with her just looking at something and not doing anything else, therefore it’s definitely Lilly, there’d be no point in that shot, as well as playing a voice as soon as it shows up that happens to sound like her, otherwise.
The pitch and tone of the voice just doesn’t match Lily, but does match the voice work of Minnie’s voice actress. Again, if I’m wrong, I’ll eat shit, but I don’t think I’m wrong here and I’m certain that it was Minerva, not Lily, and the shot in the trailer was intentionally meant to throw us off. Who knows what could have happened in the year that she’s been with them. While she might have been taken against her will, they might have done something to her that has caused her to start siding with them, hence why she calls them “your people.” Again, I’ll own up to being wrong, but I’ll be owed an apology when I’m right.
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
Pretty sure Lilly said that one. Minerva wouldn’t want to send her own friends, and ?past? Girlfriend into a war, when she could just tell t… morehem to move someplace else. Plus the camera cuts to Lilly when that line is said, with her just looking at something and not doing anything else, therefore it’s definitely Lilly, there’d be no point in that shot, as well as playing a voice as soon as it shows up that happens to sound like her, otherwise.
The pitch and tone of the voice just doesn’t match Lily, but does match the voice work of Minnie’s voice actress. Again, if I’m wrong, I’ll … moreeat shit, but I don’t think I’m wrong here and I’m certain that it was Minerva, not Lily, and the shot in the trailer was intentionally meant to throw us off. Who knows what could have happened in the year that she’s been with them. While she might have been taken against her will, they might have done something to her that has caused her to start siding with them, hence why she calls them “your people.” Again, I’ll own up to being wrong, but I’ll be owed an apology when I’m right.
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
Yes, yes it is. That's why I didn't choose to use the speech, because it could have been manipulated easier than the visual aspect. A lot of these actors have to say multiple versions of the same line to suit different situations. This could be a line where Minnie is pissed off at Clem so she's subtley mocking what she's saying. It can be hard to say without much context. Though, I also admit they could've just altered her facial expression too for the trailer exclusively. I hope I'm not wrong. Can Clem just have one fucking break?
The pitch and tone of the voice just doesn’t match Lily, but does match the voice work of Minnie’s voice actress. Again, if I’m wrong, I’ll … moreeat shit, but I don’t think I’m wrong here and I’m certain that it was Minerva, not Lily, and the shot in the trailer was intentionally meant to throw us off. Who knows what could have happened in the year that she’s been with them. While she might have been taken against her will, they might have done something to her that has caused her to start siding with them, hence why she calls them “your people.” Again, I’ll own up to being wrong, but I’ll be owed an apology when I’m right.
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
The pitch and tone of the voice just doesn’t match Lily, but does match the voice work of Minnie’s voice actress. Again, if I’m wrong, I’ll … moreeat shit, but I don’t think I’m wrong here and I’m certain that it was Minerva, not Lily, and the shot in the trailer was intentionally meant to throw us off. Who knows what could have happened in the year that she’s been with them. While she might have been taken against her will, they might have done something to her that has caused her to start siding with them, hence why she calls them “your people.” Again, I’ll own up to being wrong, but I’ll be owed an apology when I’m right.
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
Debating on whether I should make a new colour for each letter, but each will have the brightness of the fecken sun, for example lawn green, magenta and yellow so I can give everyone epileptic fits
Well to be fair, I’m really the only one bringing it up, since that’s the work I’m most familiar with. I’ve never played Persona 5, but Gaige is one of my favorite characters to play in Borderlands 2 and because her backstory/dialogue is pretty funny.
Ok, for what I saw in the trailer minerva didn’t look menacing, I know majority of people would say they want to trust her for the simple fact yes she’s been in the Delta for a year we get that what I am saying is that she might Covenants us to stay in a peaceful manner.
Admittedly, no, but then you can also thank Kent Mundle for that.
@MetallicaRules Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
I'm sorry to be late on this, but a who&whatnow from where?
Comments
2:02 reminds how my parents barging in every time when I’m talking too a girl on the phone or just doing one of my hobbies. ?
I know. I was just talking about the initial vibe I got from her. A first impression solely based on the design.
...That's fair.
I still hear Lilly in the trailer. I guess we'll have to wait and see. But I still feel pretty confident in saying it's Lilly saying that.
I just thought Minerva would consider them her own people, since she lived with them so long.
Like I said, I thought it was Lily too, but subsequent listens have me almost 100% confident that it's Minerva. After playing as Gaige countless times in Borderlands 2, I can definitely tell that's her. If I'm wrong, I'll eat my words, but I really don't think I'm wrong here to say that that is Minerva in the trailer.
You didn't answer my question--but anyway, it's a sign that either she doesn't know who she's looking for just yet or that she's a patriot.
I thought you were just throwing it back in my face to be rude, not asking a legitimate question. Obviously because Clem considers the school her home now and it's residents her friends aka 'people'
Oh, don't worry about--I was.
Eh.
Do you have to be so fucking rude all the damn time?
Seriously
No.
I don't think I was being rude(or rather, a smartass) there in your quote, for example.
.......
There was supposed to be a winking face at the end there, but I forgot to put it.
Anyway, I was legitimately asking a question since I couldn't think of an answer at the immediate time. I could've sworn I did eventually answer it though.
Because Clem is a part of their group, dude. Some will be looking to Clem as their leader in ep.3
I'll have to keep listening when I have the time, cause believe me when I say I'm really trying to hear it. The whisper makes it difficult to decipher it being anyone else's but Lilly's. But with this being an idea now, yeah, my trust meter for Minnie is steadily declining. Why does the 15th feel so far away?
Pretty sure Lilly said that one. Minerva wouldn’t want to send her own friends, and ?past? Girlfriend into a war, when she could just tell them to move someplace else. Plus the camera cuts to Lilly when that line is said, with her just looking at something and not doing anything else, therefore it’s definitely Lilly, there’d be no point in that shot, as well as playing a voice as soon as it shows up that happens to sound like her, otherwise.
I watched it again right now,and you're right,i totally hear Lilly there,and the camera cuts to Lilly when she says that,she's just whispering it's totally her.
I'd say we're missing some key context, buuut....
Ah well, that's some intrigue potentially lost/ruined.
The pitch and tone of the voice just doesn’t match Lily, but does match the voice work of Minnie’s voice actress. Again, if I’m wrong, I’ll eat shit, but I don’t think I’m wrong here and I’m certain that it was Minerva, not Lily, and the shot in the trailer was intentionally meant to throw us off. Who knows what could have happened in the year that she’s been with them. While she might have been taken against her will, they might have done something to her that has caused her to start siding with them, hence why she calls them “your people.” Again, I’ll own up to being wrong, but I’ll be owed an apology when I’m right.
Oh God, this is going to turn into a Yanny/Laurel situation, isn’t it?
I don't think it was meant to throw us off so much as establish a shift in prerogative.
Yes, yes it is. That's why I didn't choose to use the speech, because it could have been manipulated easier than the visual aspect. A lot of these actors have to say multiple versions of the same line to suit different situations. This could be a line where Minnie is pissed off at Clem so she's subtley mocking what she's saying. It can be hard to say without much context. Though, I also admit they could've just altered her facial expression too for the trailer exclusively. I hope I'm not wrong. Can Clem just have one fucking break?
Guess we’ll find out on
TUESDAY 15th!
BE THERE, OR BE SQUARE
Has it crossed anyone’s mind that maybe it was neither one of them?
OW MY EYES!!
That'd be the twist of the century.
Debating on whether I should make a new colour for each letter, but each will have the brightness of the fecken sun, for example lawn green, magenta and yellow so I can give everyone epileptic fits
Admittedly, no, but then you can also thank Kent Mundle for that.
I'm sorry to be late on this, but a who&whatnow from where?
Feels weird to see people reference the voice actress as Gaige’s voice actress when I know her solely as Makoto from Persona 5.
Well to be fair, I’m really the only one bringing it up, since that’s the work I’m most familiar with. I’ve never played Persona 5, but Gaige is one of my favorite characters to play in Borderlands 2 and because her backstory/dialogue is pretty funny.
I trust her as much as I trust myself which isn’t very high
Ok, for what I saw in the trailer minerva didn’t look menacing, I know majority of people would say they want to trust her for the simple fact yes she’s been in the Delta for a year we get that what I am saying is that she might Covenants us to stay in a peaceful manner.
I can relate
A lot of people heard Yanny, and some weirdos heard Laurel... ?
No no no, you got it backwards. Some weirdos heard Yanny, but far superior people, such as myself, heard Laurel.
I’m hearing Yaurel and it’s a focken pain in the ass! Which is it?!
It's Laurel--Yaurel is the "whisper" effect of the audio.
First it was Yaurel, then Laurel, but now I’m hearing them both at the exact same time. I honestly don’t understand
So, exactly what I described in the end?
I lost IQ points for Too this.?