Oh yeah, she most certainly cares about them alright. She let her friends she'd known for 7 years get mutilated and killed. It took her ex-friends getting abducted and brought on board for her to see them again, not her trying to escape to go back to Ericson's. She didn't aid her friends in escaping when Clementine and Louis came to for them, but stopped their attempt because it was "better this way".
There's nothing she really could've done to prevent any of that. She did try to escape, we all saw what ended up happening. I'm not fully convinced she killed her sister, but I'm probably wrong about that, and if I am she's obviously a piece of shit. But even after that I still think Jane's worse. Maybe I'm being biased, because all the bad things Jane done were directly done to Clemetine, and not her group, so it affects me more.
I replied to your other comment btw, I forgot to click on reply lol.
Minerva still cares about everyone
Oh yeah, she most certainly cares about them alright. She let her friends she'd known for 7 years… more get mutilated and killed. It took her ex-friends getting abducted and brought on board for her to see them again, not her trying to escape to go back to Ericson's. She didn't aid her friends in escaping when Clementine and Louis came to for them, but stopped their attempt because it was "better this way".
Carver's camp was too fucking big for just 2 people, there is no way they had every SINGLE entrance secured in that place. Also, how do you know they had food? I thought Jane said the family stole a lot of their supplies, leaving them low on food management.
What does it matter if Howe's was too big for them and wasn't completely covered? She knew it existed, knew exactly where it was, and knew they could survive there so long as it was stocked and fortified. It was the much better option than travelling endlessly in a snow storm looking for a place that wasn't guaranteed to be there.
Yeah and all they used is Oxy for Rebecca and that's it. Who knows what they did with the rest of the stuff?
Again, what does it matter if they only used oxy for Rebecca? Jane was being selfless when she stole from Arvo and came back to right the wrong that resulted from stealing.
Except she provoked a man, who lost his family, into killing her
Yeah, a man who provoked her from the moment Mike and Bonnie tried stealing their truck, long before she started with him. And everyone lost family, Kenny just doesn't know how to handle it. That doesn't mean everyone should kiss his ass because he's overly sensitive. He needed to learn how to control himself
She made sure Clementine had 4 walls and food before she killed herself
Sucka please. Carver's camp was too fucking big for just 2 p… moreeople, there is no way they had every SINGLE entrance secured in that place. Also, how do you know they had food? I thought Jane said the family stole a lot of their supplies, leaving them low on food management.
Jane was willing to rob Arvo for his medicine
Yeah and all they used is Oxy for Rebecca and that's it. Who knows what they did with the rest of the stuff? You don't even see anyone carrying those supplies on the way to the church (The place nobody ever mentioned again after Episode 4)
Jane never killed anyone who wasn't looking for trouble.
Except she provoked a man, who lost his family, into killing her by leaving a defenseless baby in a frozen wrecked car with a window open which could have got him killed. All Kenny wanted is to bring Clem and AJ to a safe place.
… [view original content]
Jane robbing Arvo was for her own selfish reasons of her trying to prove herself to the group. And it backfired horribly
Its funny you think she was trying to prove herself when she’d previously gotten everyone past Troy, out of Howe’s alive through the herd, and got the gate open so everyone would have a place to rest, as well as a place for Rebecca to give birth.
She did save everyone, yet she then says she shouldn't have, because it was the first person she murdered that didn't do anything to HER.
You say she shot him first and THEN regretted it. How can someone, whose first response to a dangerous situation was to shoot first, only care about themselves when their life wasn’t in any danger?? She put her beliefs aside to save everyone else. Yeah she didn’t like that she did it, but she did it despite knowing it went against how she felt. She did it because it was the right thing to do.
* Jane robbing Arvo was for her own selfish reasons of her trying to prove herself to the group. And it backfired horribly, so I don't even … moreknow why you brought that up. It was one of her biggest fuck ups.
* She did save everyone, yet she then says she shouldn't have, because it was the first person she murdered that didn't do anything to HER. Yet again bringing it back to being about herself. I'm pretty sure I don't need to explain what she did after this to Clementine.
* I don't care what she made sure Clementine had before killing herself AND her unborn child. She still left her alone, in a zombie apocalypse.
I'm not going to jump on this bandwagon hate for a character that has like 4 scenes and a couple lines of dialogue. It's stupid. If Minerva does some fucked up shit still after Lilly is dead, then yes I'll admit she'll be at least close to being as bad as Jane. But as it goes, she's nowhere near her.
Comments
Oh yeah, she most certainly cares about them alright. She let her friends she'd known for 7 years get mutilated and killed. It took her ex-friends getting abducted and brought on board for her to see them again, not her trying to escape to go back to Ericson's. She didn't aid her friends in escaping when Clementine and Louis came to for them, but stopped their attempt because it was "better this way".
There's nothing she really could've done to prevent any of that. She did try to escape, we all saw what ended up happening. I'm not fully convinced she killed her sister, but I'm probably wrong about that, and if I am she's obviously a piece of shit. But even after that I still think Jane's worse. Maybe I'm being biased, because all the bad things Jane done were directly done to Clemetine, and not her group, so it affects me more.
I replied to your other comment btw, I forgot to click on reply lol.
What does it matter if Howe's was too big for them and wasn't completely covered? She knew it existed, knew exactly where it was, and knew they could survive there so long as it was stocked and fortified. It was the much better option than travelling endlessly in a snow storm looking for a place that wasn't guaranteed to be there.
Again, what does it matter if they only used oxy for Rebecca? Jane was being selfless when she stole from Arvo and came back to right the wrong that resulted from stealing.
Yeah, a man who provoked her from the moment Mike and Bonnie tried stealing their truck, long before she started with him. And everyone lost family, Kenny just doesn't know how to handle it. That doesn't mean everyone should kiss his ass because he's overly sensitive. He needed to learn how to control himself
0h
sorry
.
.
.
It's fine, in this case. I think.
Not going back to read it again just in case.
Its funny you think she was trying to prove herself when she’d previously gotten everyone past Troy, out of Howe’s alive through the herd, and got the gate open so everyone would have a place to rest, as well as a place for Rebecca to give birth.
You say she shot him first and THEN regretted it. How can someone, whose first response to a dangerous situation was to shoot first, only care about themselves when their life wasn’t in any danger?? She put her beliefs aside to save everyone else. Yeah she didn’t like that she did it, but she did it despite knowing it went against how she felt. She did it because it was the right thing to do.