Who is more redeemable? Minerva or Marlon
Marlon killed Brody by "accident", Minerva killed her twin while they were on their own. Both of them betrayed the school, but who had more potential for redemption?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Marlon killed Brody by "accident", Minerva killed her twin while they were on their own. Both of them betrayed the school, but who had more potential for redemption?
Comments
Depends on the storytelling, but on bare-assed principal, Minnie.
EDIT: Okay, scratch that a little--in terms of "redemption" in the "make up for past transgressions" sense, it would most likely edge towards Marlon from a narrative perspective.
Marlon obviously. How is this even a question?
Minerva is a brainwashed piece of shirt that killed her own sister without any remorse.
Marlon was just a scared coward that tried to keep everyone safe. (He failed completely, but it's the thought that counts,
I guess)
Well I don't think neither can be redeemable but Marlon can be forgiven by kicking him out of the school for 3 days detention but minerva killed her sister in blood she's absolutely NOT forgiven (but I'd bet socks that ten would forgive her)
If Tenn doesn't forgive her, she'll probably kill herself.
Despite giving away the twins and killing Brody, Marlon never wanted to hurt anyone. He only gave up the twins to save everyone else, and killed Brody to silence her from disturbing the peace at Ericson’s. Although his methods were pretty questionable, he only did what he did to protect everyone else.
When Clem came to save everyone, Minerva locked her in the cell when she was the only one on guard duty. She easily could’ve let everyone out and made a run for it. Yeah that would’ve been a pretty huge gamble to take, but who knows, she could’ve lucked out and got away.
She's probably try to kill herself even if he does.
Indeed.
She wasn't gonna leave.
At least if even that bare basics of the writing stayed consistent.
Tenn was willing to forgive her before they all went on mission, but he wasn't aware about what happened to Sophie.
I know.
I'm saying I still don't see her going home to try and pretend to be happy with everyone.
Neither do I, but that just shows you her character cant be saved(for now at least)
They’re both equally redeemable. Marlon killed someone by accident. Minerva killed someone after being severely tormented by an oppressive establishment. In both cases what they did was terrible, but I think both could have been redeemed. I suppose Minnie still can be.
Marlon, definitely. Marlon, while his actions were reprehensible, showed deep remorse and regret. It does not even begin to excuse him for what he's done, but he at least acknowledged that he was wrong, but felt it was necessary to protect the larger group. Minerva stooped as low as to kill her own sister, and despite being given some chances to turn against Lilly and help Clem and her former friends, chose to betray them. I'm not saying both are capable of redemption, but if I had to pick one, it would certainly be Marlon.