should telltale make another monkey island season
they should make it 2 dimensional. 3d just doesn't suit monkey island as well. it could be the same kind of graphics as puzzle agent
anyone else agree that 2d is better?
anyone else agree that 2d is better?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
To answer the question in your thread's heading: Of course they should!
My thoughts precisely. With a sequel hook ending that that? Oh hell yes.
I for one am quite fond of the 3D graphics, but that's not to say they couldn't use some work. I'd like to see something like the difference between Sam & Max seasons 1 and 2 (or even 2 to 3): One was very good, but two was even better. Graphically, and gameplay/story wise. And I'm confident Telltale can do that!
If Telltale were to make a Season Two, then it would have to be a direct follow-on to Season One - it would need to be related to the first season as though it was the second half of the story arc that began in Season One. So, with this in mind, I would like the graphics to be exactly the same as they were in Season One, except maybe with some better lighting effects (ooh, and the coin interface from CoMI!).
This. Tales totally exceeded all of my expectations, and that was down to the story, dialogue and characterizations. If they can keep that up, I don't care what engine or interface they use.
Me too.
In terms of graphics, i'm not a great fan of the visuals in ToMI as a whole but I think this was because of too much open-landscape and thus lack of detail. The screen is pretty busy in ep 3 onwards without a big change in graphics and the game looks infinitely better for it. ToMI didn't sell itself to me 100% last time, but if TTG knew where they were going and had their experiences of series 1 to help them along I think they could hit the ground running quite easily. It'd make a buck or two as well (even if it's nothing compared to Universal franchises).
Would LA grant the license? I'd guess they're more likely to now that they're unlikely to use it themselves for the next few years.
Right after the next installment of Wallace & Gromit, please.
-The Gneech :cool:
I was in the last year of my degree when they brought TOMI out, I played the first 2 parts when it was released, but I only just found the time to play the rest. I'm glad it took me so long to get round to it though, it’s given me something to look forward to. Who knows when the next one will be released?
It better not be too far into the future though. I was kind of hoping they would be making a new monkey island game really soon, if it did well enough. In fact, I thought by now we would at least hear some kind of news of a plan to make another.
I can't wait another 10 years lol! I know the new game doesn’t stand up to the original standards of the first two, but I still love every Monkey Island game regardless.
However, I DON'T want them to develop it for WiiWare. WiiWare caused several scale-backs with the game (though maybe that's the way TT wanted it, so that they'd save time), but I think the more...simplistic approach with Tales in terms of visuals, and maybe even gameplay was done because the WiiWare could not handle the filesize. The soundtrack, fantastic as it was, was also scaled back and was composed in MIDI (for WiiWare), then run through synthesizers (I think) for PC to make it appear to be live. Without WiiWare, Telltale can bring back Michael Land, AND a reggae orchestra, and really make the music something special and more reminiscent of CMI. I'd sacrifice WiiWare development for say...PS3, a platform that Telltale seem to be working closely with these days, plus the first season ran well on PS3, did it not?
Give it a few years, let Telltale produce Back to the Future and Jurassic Park, get more experience in audience, marketing, game designing and visuals (though they're already fantastic as it is, S&M 305 proved that), and bring back Tales in 2011 (or roundabouts), and make it a masterpiece.
-Monkey
I will go with that, since the start of 2011 is only a few months away:D I'm all for a bigger budge verson, as long as it doesn't take too long. It's one of the only game's I play tbh. Most the games these days are either far too easy or combat games. Plus Monkey Island games are the only ones that I even found funny.
This, this, oh god, this. See also SBCG4AP, which was FULL of gltiches because of the Wiiware development.
This is why it wont be soon, imo. As I said above I am like 85% sure there will be a ToMI S2 (unless LA gets stupid like they have in the past) but I think we wont see it untill 2013 or so.
I *think* someone on here said that the first epp of BTTF will be released in Dec (though I might be wrong) with 5 epps, that makes Dec - Jan - Feb - March - april. then, assuming the more-or-less standard 6-month development for their games, JP will be released in Oct (2011) and run Oct - Nov - Dec - Jan - Feb. Assuming another 6 months of development, that means the next series will begin on Aug 2012 and run aug -sept -oct -nov -dec.
People are also screaming for S2 of W+G or SBCGFAP, which, if either would made, would be the "3rd game" mentioned above, bringing ToMI out 6 months later in July 2013. (And I have this sinking suspicion that TTG will be getting more licenses by then)
Really, I thought I was done but...
Tales was awesome on the wii, it sounded and worked amazing, first off, telltale could just easily do the music for PC, then cut it down for the wii, second I found no graphical problems on the wii, while I found tons on my PC which can play games like TF2. I found no problems whatsoever, while people like to complain, seriously the only glitch I ever found besides the whole repeating lines thing with the home menu(which has happened in all of telltales wii titles) was a wierd glitch where guybrush is invisible in one portion of Chapter 5, which I think was just a bad screw up with telltale and not the wii itself. Why do people complain, I have found nothing wrong with it. It shoulden't lose the wiiware port just because people like to complain.Plus I dont have a PS3 if this happens
I love this game and to me it's a masterpiece what Telltale Games made of it: Story, graphic and character design are brilliant.
Hm, well, story, animation and character design for sure. I'm still not too fond of the graphics.
I really hope they do it and I hope its sooner than later...
Same here. Withdrawals will probably begin soon otherwise.
But, in all seriousness, I completely agree. The forums were half of what made the whole experience great - the discussion and speculation in between episodes just made each episode release that much more special because there was an excitement shared within a community, rather just having your own personal excitement.
Same here as I decided to get it on Wii first. I would love to have been part of it though.
I think I agree. Maybe not the player control, because I didn't mind that, but more-so the inventory. It would be nice if item combination could be made a little simpler. I mean, it's no big problem or anything, but it would be a time-saver if you could just click one item onto another item. And a time-saving interface is a good interface. Also, if there was one part of the Escape interface that I really liked, it was how you could jump to the map screen with the 'o', and I'd love to have that in Tales.
Of course... YES !!! They should !
3D's main benefit is flexibility, you can make animations with mesh manipulation and automation where 2D would require set of animation cells for every action. Also in a modern 2D game you'd expect multiplane parallax scrolling, which effectively multiplies the needed work several-folds. 2D for a modern game means a *lot* of work.
For a large monolithic projects like eg. The Whispered World or Blade Runner (even though that's 13 years old already!) , it's a viable and good method, but for episodic games not so much I think.
Just IMO.
Wow, I think that may actually be the first time that I've read those words from a non-troll.
Also, just wondering, by 'original series', are you referring to 1, 2, 3 and 4, or just 1 & 2?
There was the fun one with giving LeCuck 2 golden idols and he fights invislbe pirates. But that glitched rules!