Trixie... but I think its because she is not secretly evil... I liked young Edna just fine until she let her true colors show... I have not completed episode four yet though.... I think I may be half way through it.
I'll go with Trixie. She may be everything that Edna is against - but she seems to have a heart of gold, unlike Edna. On the surface, Edna seems to be the more morally pure of the two - but, inwardly, Trixie is nicer and less judgemental.
The scene with her 'fight' with Emmett was incredibly entertaining. When she requested the photo album, I had no idea what she could possibly use it for. When she whipped out his baby photo during the fight and asked 'What about Little Emmett?', I lost it right then and there.
I actually do kinda like Edna, and am even thinking of incorporating her into my ficverse. Granted, I don't much care for the Citizen Brown version of her - but I think she is an interesting character. I probably wouldn't be friends with her, though.
Like? As in which character is better? Then id say Edna, yes she's evil and all, but she is important to the plot and a interesting character.
If you mean like as in, who would you rather know and get along with, obviously Trixie, she may seam a bit naive but she is nice.
I gotta give the vote to Trixie, at first I liked Edna, but then there's something about Trixie when she appeared in the second episode that made me instantly like her. Edna isn't that bad until she gets older but Trixie seems like the type of person who is just overall nice without even trying, it's just in her nature.
Trixie. Let's face it, Edna is a very sweet girl, but she is just too controling; she has to have thing her way. Trixie my not be the sharpest knife, but she doesn't have an evil bone in her body.
I actually don't mind Edna in 1931. Sure she has her problems, but she isn't a horrible person. She's trying to contribute to society. It's sad seeing her in the original 1986 as a bitter old woman all by herself. In 1986B she's just a madwoman with the help of Citizen Brown. I don't think of her as evil evil. Biff was a complete jerk who murdered George in BTTF2 in 1985B, but in BTTF3 we see he's back to normal guy cause Marty made sure Biff didn't get the Almanac.
So I think if given the chance she could live a normal life.
I actually don't mind Edna in 1931. Sure she has her problems, but she isn't a horrible person. She's trying to contribute to society. It's sad seeing her in the original 1986 as a bitter old woman all by herself. In 1986B she's just a madwoman with the help of Citizen Brown. I don't think of her as evil evil. Biff was a complete jerk who murdered George in BTTF2 in 1985B, but in BTTF3 we see he's back to normal guy cause Marty made sure Biff didn't get the Almanac.
So I think if given the chance she could live a normal life.
i dont think biff is 'normal' in the 'good timelines' i think he is just afraid of George and puts on an act; remember he does yell at marty for a second at the end of part III.
If I had to chose, it'd be Jennifer, I think her new look is hotter than Trixie's look.
Plus, you can't compare Edna with Trixie, this is just ridiculous, they have nothing in common.
They do have some common points: both are women making their way in the society, polar opposites in some aspects, and yet somehow similar. Their mutual dislike may come from them being resourceful and determined to get what they want.
My take on girls:
Trixie goes by her inner code of morality: she made many mistakes, but remained a sweet, caring person that essentially knows right from wrong and goes on hoping the society can accept her now that she's dating Artie. She knows her worth and loathes Edna for judging her for appearances.
Edna relies on external morality codes and is concerned about the opinions and externals. She's capable of kindness, but her main aim is to enforce order and discipline as she sees them. Trixie is a thorn in her side, because she doesn't care about what people think about her, something Edna considers shocking and can't accept.
I'd choose Trixie all over. I feel deeply concerned for Edna, but the problem she's got in the future timelines we've seen usually is her own fault. However, I'd like to see her happy somehow.
Okay, so I'd choose Trixie, she's sweeter, and she doesn't deserve what happened to her in the last chapter.(And she's hot too )
I hated Edna at the beginning of the episode, but when I finished it, I felt a little guilty and sad for her, and I think a new time-line is gonna be created in OUTATIME, where she's gonna have a better life than in the first ep.
I'm french, so if I make mistakes sometimes, I'm sorry, I'm 17.
i dont think biff is 'normal' in the 'good timelines' i think he is just afraid of George and puts on an act; remember he does yell at marty for a second at the end of part III.
Oh yeah I know Biff is still not a Nice Guy, but I do like him better than his 1985B counterpart (as I'm sure practical everybody does). I'd like to see Edna become better than her original 1986 persona
It would be interesting, if Edna and Trixie actually decided to team up against Marty - after realizing that they were both being manipulated by him. They probably dislike each other too much for that to ever happen, though.
Comments
She's got my vote.
If you mean like as in, who would you rather know and get along with, obviously Trixie, she may seam a bit naive but she is nice.
She is definitely hot!
(And, might I add...Yow! What a knockout.
So I think if given the chance she could live a normal life.
i dont think biff is 'normal' in the 'good timelines' i think he is just afraid of George and puts on an act; remember he does yell at marty for a second at the end of part III.
In that case, Trixie is the person that Marty got his singing voice from.
Plus, you can't compare Edna with Trixie, this is just ridiculous, they have nothing in common.
They do have some common points: both are women making their way in the society, polar opposites in some aspects, and yet somehow similar. Their mutual dislike may come from them being resourceful and determined to get what they want.
My take on girls:
Trixie goes by her inner code of morality: she made many mistakes, but remained a sweet, caring person that essentially knows right from wrong and goes on hoping the society can accept her now that she's dating Artie. She knows her worth and loathes Edna for judging her for appearances.
Edna relies on external morality codes and is concerned about the opinions and externals. She's capable of kindness, but her main aim is to enforce order and discipline as she sees them. Trixie is a thorn in her side, because she doesn't care about what people think about her, something Edna considers shocking and can't accept.
I'd choose Trixie all over. I feel deeply concerned for Edna, but the problem she's got in the future timelines we've seen usually is her own fault. However, I'd like to see her happy somehow.
I hated Edna at the beginning of the episode, but when I finished it, I felt a little guilty and sad for her, and I think a new time-line is gonna be created in OUTATIME, where she's gonna have a better life than in the first ep.
I'm french, so if I make mistakes sometimes, I'm sorry, I'm 17.
Oh yeah I know Biff is still not a Nice Guy, but I do like him better than his 1985B counterpart (as I'm sure practical everybody does). I'd like to see Edna become better than her original 1986 persona
Did you forget that she wanted to turn all the city into zombies in Chapter 3?
And in Chapter 4, she wanted to eraze her husband mem'ries. ^^
but she's not doing that just to be evil. She genuinely thinks that its the right thing to do. Yes she is wrong but not from her perspective
That's just a point of view. ^^