Andy, Danny and Brenda
Youl notice that when Lee and Mark go out to fix the fences he turns the fence on to try and kill you. He says he heard mark yell to turn it on but mark only yells after he turns it on.
When you Go out to hunt bandits with danny you find the CamCorder and dannys like Oh crap what have you got there. And when you say its not working hes like Oh Phew. (meaning that hes afraid youl find out they are killers)
The only reason you and danny go out hunting for bandits is to leave INJURED Mark alone with brenda and Andy so they can Start to kill him.
Also When brendas on the porch and you go up to her shes like "dinners ready soon" then her face goes all DEMONIC, it looks just like a graphical glitch but you can tell shes an evil mofo
When you Go out to hunt bandits with danny you find the CamCorder and dannys like Oh crap what have you got there. And when you say its not working hes like Oh Phew. (meaning that hes afraid youl find out they are killers)
The only reason you and danny go out hunting for bandits is to leave INJURED Mark alone with brenda and Andy so they can Start to kill him.
Also When brendas on the porch and you go up to her shes like "dinners ready soon" then her face goes all DEMONIC, it looks just like a graphical glitch but you can tell shes an evil mofo
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Poor Mark, he woulda made a great member of the group
I do wonder what exactly they were going to do after dinner had we not found out. Were they expecting us to forget all about Mark and not notice us disappearing one by one? What kind of meat did the others think they were eating? Chicken?
That's actually a really good question. Why did nobody think "This farm only has one cow, which is very alive, what the hell are we about to eat?"
Also, I think the little hints Andy was dropping were intentional. Cause in the barn he says you weren't ready to know yet, implying that at some point, they wanted you to find out. They just wanted to make sure you wouldn't freak out about it.
Andy seemed more or less normal...you know, with the exception that he was eating people.
Yeah once I learned that the cow was the only animal there and it was sick my cannibal detector became active. When they said that they ran a dairy farm and had loads of food I was expecting them to have lots of dairy-based food products.
I'm not sure they were planning on recruiting us or anything, my impression was that they felt that you were all going to die anyway, and that we would be ready for the 'truth' when they wanted to eat us, but I'm not 100% certain. Maybe they were crazy enough to think they could convince us that eating people was good, or maybe they were playing the part of the 'helpful hosts' in an attempt to delude themselves they were not eating them.
I had all kinds of thoughts about these people, cannibalism being one of them. I also had the unnerving idea that Telltale was actively trying to deceive us and in the end this family turns out to be just some friendly folks ... by which time we would have screwed up everything with our unjustified paranoia, e.g. by sabotaging the fence and destroying this family's "safe" haven.
Danny is the one polishing the gun, not Andy.
I head someone in another thread have the idea of them just being a normal family we destroyed by distrusting, and I still really like that idea.
Also, I've pointed this out before, but wouldn't the lack of electricity mean no refrigerator, which would be big trouble for a dairy farm?
I'm pretty sure they intended to try and convert at least some of you, judging by certain things. When the truth comes out, they don't pull guns on you until after it is clear your group is not okay with this. It's clear from the "wasteful" plan of killing all but one of you afterwards that they didn't plan on having this many prisoners. Why make dinner at all if killing everyone was the plan? Seems more like a way to show them how "good" cannibalism can be. Why fix the swing? Why wait so long? Why not just take the kids hostage as soon as everyone arrives, rather than let them snoop around?
Maybe because of the bandits ?
They might wanted to make some more food for them as a gift of forgiveness ?
Definitely not. We don't know exactly why their deal went south, but the bandits are unlikely to listen to what they have to say, as opposed to shooting first, as shown with what happens to Lee and Mark when trying to clear the fence. And if that were the case, Brenda wouldn't talk them having to kill all but one for that reason, since she could just cook them up and give them to the bandits. If anything, I think it's more likely she was hoping to find allies in the group to help fight off the bandits, who were a big problem for them.