›

spoilers witch choice was harder

donmike84donmike84
edited July 2012 in The Walking Dead
stealing the food from the car at the end of episode 2 starved for hel

or

giveing the girl the gun at the motel when rescuing glenn

Comments

  • SisterofshaneSisterofshane
    edited July 2012
    The car - mostly because I don't want Clementine to be confused when I have to disregard my morals in order to make the right decision for the group.
  • CapnJayCapnJay Banned
    edited July 2012
    an interesting comparison if you give her the gun she blows her brains out if you dont she blows her brains out if you dont steal from the car kenny and the others do anyway if you do steal from the car you steal from it. so it's a fake choice
  • PuhChewyChompPuhChewyChomp
    edited July 2012
    Car. No question. That girl was dead anyway.
  • ZombiesSLAYERZombiesSLAYER
    edited July 2012
    The woman, givin' her the gun to take her own life is no question the hardest choice to make. The car is simple. Nobody around the car. It's easy to take good items. A thief can steal a car is simple. A human takes it own life is lost- rather they're brave or scare
  • marcu5marcu5
    edited July 2012
    the car

    i kind of feel like there's going to be some serious fallout from that
  • darkdominodarkdomino
    edited July 2012
    First off, I'd never give a crazy person a gun (in the apocalypse or otherwise) - you simply don't know what they are gonna do with it. How do I know she's not gonna turn it on me the first second she gets it? Nah, not gonna happen.

    Secondly, I'm gonna quote Shane from the AMC Walking Dead TV series and say "The right choice is the one that keeps us alive." ... I agree that stealing, zombie apocalypse or not, isn't exactly moral or just - but at some point you have to make a choice.

    If it's a choice between me and my crew dying of starvation and looting some abandoned vehicle in the woods....That's no choice at all, for me. I'm gonna stay alive no matter what.
  • The_Cheshire_CatThe_Cheshire_Cat
    edited July 2012
    marcu5 wrote: »
    the car

    i kind of feel like there's going to be some serious fallout from that

    The fact that we don't get to see the repercussions from it immediately tells me the same thing.

    I noticed there was a sweater in there for Clem. I am thinking the owner of that car is going to show up in the next episode and when they see Clem wearing their stolen clothes they will freak out and either refuse to help or become hostile.
  • CornsonCornson
    edited July 2012
    ZombiesSLAYER wrote: »
    The woman, givin' her the gun to take her own life is no question the hardest choice to make. The car is simple. Nobody around the car. It's easy to take good items. A thief can steal a car is simple. A human takes it own life is lost- rather they're brave or scare

    I feel that's its the exact opposite....

    The group is starving and are almost out of food, so stealing food to survive.

    VS.

    Helping a infected person commit suicide so she won't turn.

    In my book the helping the infected survivor was the second easiest choice they have given me so far! (Making sure that Larry didn't reanimate was the easiest)
  • franapbsilvafranapbsilva
    edited July 2012
    Could you turn it into a poll please???
  • JazzyJazzy
    edited July 2012
    Stealing the food. I was like "Can we at least wait a bit and see if the owners turn back up?" Giving the girl the gun was never an option, even if I didn't think she was too crazy to have it there was still the fact that neither me nor Lee had seen anyone die and transform from the bite yet, and wasn't (and still not) convinced that every one who is bitten turns 100%. Eventually someone turns up whose immune or is just a carrier and never develops the condition themselves.
  • pdlbeanpdlbean
    edited July 2012
    the decision to give Irene the gun was the easiest decision so far as far as I'm concerned. She was going to die anyway, and this way she doesn't come back as a walker to kill anyone else. It's not like I shot her in the head against her own will. She wanted it. It was a no-brainer (pardon the pun) to hand over the gun.

    The car was definitely harder, but I ended up not stealing the food because Clementine already saw me kill Danny and I didn't want her to lose any trust in me.
  • GennadiosGennadios
    edited July 2012
    Motel girl didn't stand a chance in hell, and there's no way of knowing who the car belonged to.

    The choice with missing information is always harder.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited July 2012
    I'd say refusing the gun to Irene in episode 1. I just didn't take the food from the car because the car's owners might retaliate. Besides, I'd do what Clem wants.
  • PsychofreakPsychofreak
    edited July 2012
    Neither, I felt whether or not to kill Larry was a heck of a ton harder than either of those decisions.

    If those are the only two options then I would have to say stealing food from the car.
  • NessaTNessaT
    edited July 2012
    Psychofreak wrote: »
    Neither, I felt whether or not to kill Larry was a heck of a ton harder than either of those decisions.

    If those are the only two options then I would have to say stealing food from the car.

    Agreed. The Larry and even Doug / Carly decision was tough as hell. Whenever a person's life is in question, it's tough.

    The gun issue is more of an emotional response. She was going to die anyway, but I let her choose her way out because she has a right to die with dignity.

    I took the goods from the car. It will probably cause problems in future, but Lee needs to be in charge and seen taking care of the group. Lilly and Kenny are too busy with their power struggle. The group needs a Rick, and Lee seems to be closest to that.
This discussion has been closed.