›

Most Suprising Events From EP3?

SouthWardRBSouthWardRB
edited August 2012 in The Walking Dead
This episode was amazing if you don't care about the characters, but the worst one yet if you do. For me:

1. Katjaa and Duck dying, I wasn't expecting duck to be bit, I expected if he were to die he would be eaten. Katjaa committing scuicide.:eek:

2. Carley dying. I knew she was going die eventually, since it was eitherDoug or Carley, it would require to much effort by TTG to develope both characters. But the way she died so abruptly, and after I thought a Lee+Carley thin would happen, especially after carley kissed lee.

So many people fought Kenny. Wtf

Comments

  • geomon19geomon19
    edited August 2012
    So wait, is there no way to save Carly? Cause, yeah that needs to happen.
  • skepticalguy90skepticalguy90
    edited August 2012
    Have to admit I didn't see Lilly killing Carley, I would have bet money that it was Kenny if anyone (that was killed by Lilly). That is sort of the huge turn off for me with the walking dead. You really can't get attached to any character that isn't named Rick.
  • Lin001Lin001
    edited August 2012
    Oh, dude! Daaamn, I knew I shouldn't have clicked in this topic, but I did it. Damn curiosity!
    But, since I am here anyways, Doug dies too?
  • SouthWardRBSouthWardRB
    edited August 2012
    Well since they are "this or that" characters I'm sure Doug dies.
  • SouthWardRBSouthWardRB
    edited August 2012
    As characters come, some must go. A hobo, white guy and black woman came into the group. You have to chpose between the two, who to sae, save the dude, both will live.
  • Lin001Lin001
    edited August 2012
    Uhm. Not cool. I mean, sure, they indeed are " This or that" characters, but would be cool if there were a difference between they importance.

    What I really want to know is who's the traitor. But I guess I have to control myself. I am gettin' out of here boys, g'luck!
  • GoldrockGoldrock
    edited August 2012
    yeah gotta get use too characters dien even kirkman will tell you that in one of his episodes its what sells his books people get too attached and he up and kills a character kinda what makes walking dead so damn good a thrilling there is no superhero or character with a big hero complex loke most storys he will kill them off hell he hasnt killed rick off but ricks moral compass is out of wack.
  • j.em26j.em26
    edited August 2012
    Can we accuse Ben and have Lilly kill him instead ?
  • skepticalguy90skepticalguy90
    edited August 2012
    Goldrock wrote: »
    yeah gotta get use too characters dien even kirkman will tell you that in one of his episodes its what sells his books people get too attached and he up and kills a character kinda what makes walking dead so damn good a thrilling there is no superhero or character with a big hero complex loke most storys he will kill them off hell he hasnt killed rick off but ricks moral compass is out of wack.

    Eh, while you see a thrilling story, I see a strong reason not to invest a ton of interest in any characters (i.e. Tyreese, Glenn, Dale (on TV).)
  • SadClownSadClown
    edited August 2012
    At least now we have some sort of idea of how Lilly ended up in the comics.
  • ComixFanComixFan
    edited August 2012
    SouthWardRB wrote: »
    This episode was amazing if you don't care about the characters, but the worst one yet if you do. For me:

    1. Katjaa and Duck dying, I wasn't expecting duck to be bit, I expected if he were to die he would be eaten. Katjaa committing scuicide.:eek:

    2. Carley dying. I knew she was going die eventually, since it was eitherDoug or Carley, it would require to much effort by TTG to develope both characters. But the way she died so abruptly, and after I thought a Lee+Carley thin would happen, especially after carley kissed lee.

    So many people fought Kenny. Wtf

    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.
  • skepticalguy90skepticalguy90
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.

    I felt incredibly sorry for Kenny by the time the episode was over. Honestly, I'll give TT credit for that. I hated Kenny after the end of E2, but having to shoot Duck turned it around.
  • KylesanKylesan
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.

    Would you mind spoiling 1.? I'm interested to know what i'd have to do differently.
  • mkane24mkane24
    edited August 2012
    SadClown wrote: »
    At least now we have some sort of idea of how Lilly ended up in the comics.

    this is not the same lilly
  • ExzanderExzander
    edited August 2012
    I literally signed up just now so I could ask if we could save Katjaa/duck. Can someone please PM me or just explain it in here how I can save them?

    I would be extremely appreciative.
  • canadianzombiecanadianzombie
    edited August 2012
    Exzander wrote: »
    I literally signed up just now so I could ask if we could save Katjaa/duck. Can someone please PM me or just explain it in here how I can save them?

    I would be extremely appreciative.

    I would also like to know how too! Please inform :confused:
  • Viner16Viner16
    edited August 2012
    canadianzombie wrote: »
    I would also like to know how too! Please inform :confused:

    Wait wait wait... you can save them?
    HOW?:confused::confused::confused:
  • PuhChewyChompPuhChewyChomp
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made.
    Proof or I call BS.
  • Ja1862Ja1862
    edited August 2012
    PuhChewyChomp wrote: »
    Proof or I call BS.

    It is BS his even asking in another thread if its possible lol

    Maybe a fanboy giving telltale more credit then they deserve>???
  • AraronAraron
    edited August 2012
    Damn it...that damn,damn curiosity... its over now.I just...had to read...curiosity... :(
  • itwasmoiitwasmoi
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.
    Would like to know how to
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2012
    Mine are the two obvious ones: when Lilly killed Carley (my jaw literally dropped) and when Katjaa killed herself. I was kind of expecting Katjaa to die in this episode though, but for some reason I wasn't expecting Carley to die. Or at least not like that.
  • JessabethJessabeth
    edited August 2012
    mkane24 wrote: »
    this is not the same lilly

    Could have sworn that they (telltale) said it was...
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2012
    Jessabeth wrote: »
    Could have sworn that they (telltale) said it was...

    I'd be pretty annoyed if it wasn't. I find her character much more interesting because she was in the comics and the thing she did. She got very little character development in the comics so having her in this game was really clever.
  • ChristoasterChristoaster
    edited August 2012
    skepticalguy90 wrote: »
    Have to admit I didn't see Lilly killing Carley, I would have bet money that it was Kenny if anyone (that was killed by Lilly). That is sort of the huge turn off for me with the walking dead. You really can't get attached to any character that isn't named Rick.

    How is it a huge turn off? People fucking die. It's a zombie apocalypse. Telltale isn't going to let someone live all the episode just because you are bonding with them.
  • CaliforniaBearCaliforniaBear
    edited August 2012
    Carley getting shot shocked the shit out of me, I also didn't mean to fight Kenny, but I just let him beat me up, I can't imagine how hard it was for him to go through that
  • ChristoasterChristoaster
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    Are you serious right now? Like legit? Have you experienced and made the right choices to avoid Katjaa's suicide and Dick being put down? Don't spoil it, just tell me if you did.
  • NorskattNorskatt
    edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.


    With what choices can it be avoided? Specifics please, if you've tested it out and she didn't die for you.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited August 2012
    if ttg are going to kill of characters to allow new ones to show up why let you get out of it makes no sense..

    and i got spoiled on carly due to 3 fuck tarts on the fb carley page..
This discussion has been closed.