›

Who here let (SPOILER) back into the RV? (Episode 3 SPOILERS)

coolmack24coolmack24
edited August 2012 in The Walking Dead
During the scene where Lily kills Doug/Carley,who here decided to let her back in the RV and NOT leave her behind. I did, hopefully so I could some info out of her.

Comments

  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited August 2012
    I let her back in and she tells you come with her when she decides to escape
  • Fiddle DiddleFiddle Diddle
    edited August 2012
    Should be a survey no?
  • Harry CallahanHarry Callahan
    edited August 2012
    I didn't. I'd been empathizing with her up to that point...I felt bad about the strain she was under, even though her hole-up-where-we-are plan was pretty terrible. But shooting Carley like that was just beyond the pale, especially when she just decided that she was guilty on the basis of no proof at all. Hit the road, Lilly, and don't let the walkers bite you in the ass on the way out.
  • ComixFanComixFan
    edited August 2012
    Of course I left her. The pointlessness of her actions aside, she was the most unstable element in the party, perhaps more so then Kenny despite the later's actions in "Starved for Help." Also, for those who know Lily's future from the Kirkman series, well, let's just say leaving her was for the best, regardless of her being used as a narrative scapegoat to kill off Carly/Doug.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited August 2012
    I had Doug and i let her back in because it was just to much going on. But later on Lilly tells you to leave everyone and go with her!!!!
  • GamingDragon316GamingDragon316
    edited August 2012
    two words: FUCK NO
  • PuhChewyChompPuhChewyChomp
    edited August 2012
    Left her when it was Carly, took her when it was Doug.
  • the_Sean712the_Sean712
    edited August 2012
    I let her back on, just because I thought leaving her there was too good for her...what a mistake...wish I'd have left her ass now :\ lol. I was hoping I'd get to throw her to walkers and watch her die if I let her back on or something. Fuck Lilly...I hope we see her dead somewhere in a later episode now XD lol
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2012
    I left her. Me and Carley had a thing going on at the start and she was one of my favourite characters. I did side with Kenny in Episode 2 but I sided with Lilly at the start of this episode and then she killed an innocent person. I was happy to throw her out, I really like how they included Lilly in this game though and her backstory and how it leads into the comics. It's pretty cool.
  • NeonBladeNeonBlade
    edited August 2012
    There was no way I was letting that lunatic back on the RV. I already had my hands full with the ass Kenny.
  • WalkingDead23WalkingDead23
    edited August 2012
    i let her back on but im more curious of what happens if you say yes to going with her
  • TrickyDTrickyD
    edited August 2012
    No way was I letting her back in. I felt bad but it had to be done. She killed Carley in cold blood with no evidence. She was unhinged.
  • Red PandaRed Panda
    edited August 2012
    I let her back on. I said yes. She drives off without you.
  • rcs1537rcs1537
    edited August 2012
    What happens if you choose to let Lilly back on the RV? Does she stay long?
  • jangjangchangjangjangchang
    edited August 2012
    rcs1537 wrote: »
    What happens if you choose to let Lilly back on the RV? Does she stay long?

    She kills Duck.
  • Don'tLickTheSaltLickDon'tLickTheSaltLick
    edited August 2012
    She steals the damn RV.
  • kirby18kirby18
    edited August 2012
    I let her back on. You handcuff her and when the group gets stuck they leave her in the RV by herself. When lee comes back on to get the pencil, she asks him to come with her but (atleast I said, no) he doesnt and she drives off with the RV.
  • CapnJayCapnJay Banned
    edited August 2012
    yeah i have the feeling if you let her back on and say yes to her Lee goes to get clementine and Lily abandons him. But i didnt try it first time. Also i knew Ben was the traitor
  • Master of AeonsMaster of Aeons
    edited August 2012
    I kicked her out. That was crazy shit.
  • magodeskymagodesky
    edited August 2012
    Not a chance. Lilly totally crossed the line. My only regret is that the game didn't give me the option to have Lee kill her himself. But I suppose leaving her to the walkers is the next best thing.
  • Master of AeonsMaster of Aeons
    edited August 2012
    Yeah, there weren't enough suspects.
  • Joe NewberryJoe Newberry
    edited August 2012
    I let her back on because I understood that she was coming unhinged and that she hadn't meant to kill Doug. She was trying to protect the group from a traitor, in her own paranoid delusional way. After the zombie apocalypse, you can't afford to abandon anyone, even murderers. I thought there might be a chance to get Lilly rational again and keep her in the group. I was wrong, but it didn't result in any additional loss of life, so I don't regret it. I couldn't have "punished" her for killing Doug by leaving her behind, anyway, because we know she lives to be a Woodbury citizen. One way or another, she was going to survive her time with us.
  • WowMuttWowMutt
    edited August 2012
    I left her behind.. even when I was talking to the other characters, i never used the option to talk about her.. just let it go!
  • pdlbeanpdlbean
    edited August 2012
    I let her back on. In retrospect I probably shouldn't have. But the whole point is doing things in the moment and that's what my instinct was for whatever reason.
  • magodeskymagodesky
    edited August 2012
    Joe Newberry wrote: »
    I couldn't have "punished" her for killing Doug by leaving her behind, anyway, because we know she lives to be a Woodbury citizen. One way or another, she was going to survive her time with us.

    I haven't gotten that far in the comics yet (only read the first two volumes), but I've seen people saying this. At this point, though, I'm choosing to believe that Lilly from the game is a different Lilly who just happens to have the same name as and look a lot like the Lilly from the comics. And our Lilly was torn apart by walkers on the side of the road. Justice for Carley!
This discussion has been closed.