›

EVIL Carley or Doug (spoilers)

AceStarrAceStarr
edited September 2012 in The Walking Dead
(If you have not played episode 3 yet do not read this)

Ok by now we all know there dead

but what if they our not?


What if in the second season they live and this time they not good but evil. We assume they dead but people have survived gunshots to the head(Carley) and have even been known to walk around because the bullet did not damage no vital areas. The same can be said for a bullet to the stomach like Doug.


So could you see them in second season as evil characters? seeking revenge because you left them?

Comments

  • TrickyDTrickyD
    edited August 2012
    I can't see it personally.

    Why would the seek revenge on Lee and the group when it was Lilly who shot them and they're gone anyway?
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited August 2012
    Well in


    Carleys case: She would wake up like wtf because she got side blinded. I could see a brain injury victim only remember that argument and then nobody is around. She would be like wtf!!!!


    Dougs case: He would know they left if he woke up and he a tech guy he might even be smart enough to patch himself up. Remember how he talked about chalk???
  • ZacTBZacTB
    edited August 2012
    Ugh this would be awful, sorry. They should stay dead. It was a shocking and bleak death that seems fitting considering what has been happening to the survivors.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited August 2012
    ^^^Hey it happens in comic books all the time lol
  • ArthurVArthurV Telltale Alumni
    edited August 2012
    Do they come back with goatees?

    evil-spock.jpg
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited August 2012
    ^^^^OMG i remember that Evil Spock

    that would be cool as hell for Doug to have a beard of Evil LOL
  • Fiddle DiddleFiddle Diddle
    edited August 2012
    SO people keep saying that Doug was shot in the stomach... Why was my Doug shot in the back of the head?
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited August 2012
    anyone else wish lilly shot the nub ben instead...
  • Dead_Man_WalkingDead_Man_Walking
    edited August 2012
    All I have to say is if Carley comes back, after catching a lead round in the face, I may have to switch sides. D:< I mean, come on, that ain't natural. :P As for Doug, I don't know. I had a skip in the scene on mine, and it looked like he caught it in the back/upper torso area. >_> Oh well, too lazy to replay to see. :D
  • MalachXavielMalachXaviel
    edited August 2012
    I predict Doug will come back from the dead, he'll turn evil because he's motivated by revenge and he'll form a group of survivors that he found at a hospital and he'll lead them as they commit atrocities together. During a decisive battle with a group of religious fanatic (but peaceful) survivors, Doug's face is heavily burned and so he covers his entire head in bandages as he continues to hunt down Lee. Doug finally corner's Lee at a derelict room in the hospital and almost kills Lee, but Lee wins because Clem is able to sneak up on Doug from behind and deal a crippling blow so that Lee can finish him off.

    Clem later takes Lee back to where they met and Lee dies from his injuries, the end.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Either way i love the idea of evil doug or carley lol:eek:
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    AceStarr wrote: »
    Either way i love the idea of evil doug or carley lol:eek:

    when you say evil...evil and dead or still human and REALLY pissed off?
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Xarne wrote: »
    when you say evil...evil and dead or still human and REALLY pissed off?

    Alive and pissed off
  • donmike84donmike84
    edited September 2012
    wait a minute you have to choose to take lilly or leave her lilly could check to see if doug/carley are alive
  • SteveTheBlocksSteveTheBlocks
    edited September 2012
    Doug was shot in the stomach?
    What kind of playthrough did you do, mine was shot in the back of the neck on the left side, they say it's the head but i watched it multiple times he was shot in the left neck side.
  • CyreenCyreen
    edited September 2012
    This is a zombie apocalypse. If either of them come back, it won't be as survivors.

    zombie.gif
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Cyreen wrote: »
    This is a zombie apocalypse. If either of them come back, it won't be as survivors.

    zombie.gif

    Chained up female Carley seems like the peedo who calling Clem Clem would have fun with that LOL
  • CyreenCyreen
    edited September 2012
    Sorry, changed the graphic while you were typing, oops! They were too big and, yeah, the chained up chick zombie was just a little weird.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Cyreen wrote: »
    Sorry, changed the graphic while you were typing, oops! They were too big and, yeah, the chained up chick zombie was just a little weird.

    I see now folks going to be like why he say that lol...
  • Gman5852Gman5852
    edited September 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    anyone else wish lilly shot the nub ben instead...

    A lot more people than those that wanted Doug/Carley, dead, which is exactly way Telltale opted not to ;)
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited September 2012
    I'd be ok with Doug/Carley coming back as a villain next season... though... Doug doesn't seem the type. I could image Carley being pissed though.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    I'd be ok with Doug/Carley coming back as a villain next season... though... Doug doesn't seem the type. I could image Carley being pissed though.


    EVIL Carley patch lol
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited September 2012
    As long as she gets an eyepatch and a goatee, I'll be fine with bringing Carley back.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    As long as she gets an eyepatch and a goatee, I'll be fine with bringing Carley back.

    can it be a paint on goatee lol
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited September 2012
    Guys, Nicole Vigil confirmed on her Facebook fan page that Carley is dead in episode 3. Which probably means she won't be coming back.
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Guys, Nicole Vigil confirmed on her Facebook fan page that Carley is dead in episode 3. Which probably means she won't be coming back.

    clarify dead please
  • TreigerTreiger
    edited September 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Guys, Nicole Vigil confirmed on her Facebook fan page that Carley is dead in episode 3. Which probably means she won't be coming back.

    Maybe the bullet didn't hit her brain...so now she's UNDEAD! DUN DUN DUNNNNN...idk. That could work. :P
  • QuarterPounderVladQuarterPounderVlad
    edited September 2012
    ...FUCKING REALLY? SHE WAS SHOT IN DA DAMN FACE.
    Get fucking over it, I'm raging because there are so many people with ideas that suck. An evil carley? I mean, Do you want her to climb a building and yell "EAT THEM MY SLAVES! EAT THEIR ORGANS!"
    She's dead. Now fucking DEAL With it!!!

    Sorry for the rage, It's just how I feel about dumb ideas.
  • CrazyGamerzPCCrazyGamerzPC
    edited September 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Guys, Nicole Vigil confirmed on her Facebook fan page that Carley is dead in episode 3. Which probably means she won't be coming back.

    Dammit....

    This is it guys, she truly is dead. The VOICE ACTOR confirmed it!

    Damn you TTG >.<
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    QuarterPounderVlad wrote: »
    ...FUCKING REALLY? SHE WAS SHOT IN DA DAMN FACE.
    Get fucking over it, I'm raging because there are so many people with ideas that suck. An evil carley? I mean, Do you want her to climb a building and yell "EAT THEM MY SLAVES! EAT THEIR ORGANS!"
    She's dead. Now fucking DEAL With it!!!

    Sorry for the rage, It's just how I feel about dumb ideas.

    Hold up buddy and im assumeing your a guy

    In comic books it happens all the time bringing back the dead..... GOOD OR BAD!!!!

    Jason Todd was beat to death and blown up by the Joker bam he alive again as the Red Hood!!!

    They killed Superman!!!!

    They recently killed Ulitimate Spider-man!!!

    Im thinking you forgeting Walking Dead is a comic book and anything is possible in the comic book world!!!
  • Master of AeonsMaster of Aeons
    edited September 2012
    AceStarr wrote: »
    Hold up buddy and im assumeing your a guy

    In comic books it happens all the time bringing back the dead..... GOOD OR BAD!!!!

    Jason Todd was beat to death and blown up by the Joker bam he alive again as the Red Hood!!!

    They killed Superman!!!!

    They recently killed Ulitimate Spider-man!!!

    Im thinking you forgeting Walking Dead is a comic book and anything is possible in the comic book world!!!

    Whoa, whoa, whoa. Now I'm mad. Comics are comics, sure. But you're citing superhero comics in a Walking Dead argument. Nothing supernatural (save for the zombies themselves) has ever happened in Walking Dead. No one has ever returned from death here. Kirkman pulls that in Invincible, but he knows to keep the genres separate.
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited September 2012
    No kidding, the walking dead isn't the super-heroic genre.

    It's the, you're screwed during a ZA genre.

    You might survive a horrid injury..... with parts missing at that... but there's only one way to come back from the dead...
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Master of Aeons wrote: »
    Whoa, whoa, whoa. Now I'm mad. Comics are comics, sure. But you're citing superhero comics in a Walking Dead argument. Nothing supernatural (save for the zombies themselves) has ever happened in Walking Dead. No one has ever returned from death here. Kirkman pulls that in Invincible, but he knows to keep the genres separate.

    Sorry Master its still a comic book lol

    Yes Kirkman so far has not pulled the they alive card yet.... but to say it wont ever happen?

    Ok like for example when Tyrese was trap in a room with 25 zombies the group locking the door behind him. Ending that comic issue with the idea he is definatly dead until next issue they open the door and he laying on a pile of 25 dead zombies Now is that Realistic???? No its not
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    But ill do you one better which is real life there is a story i read about a African American soilder during world war 2 who watched the nazis shot his comrade. They said he snap out and ran into the Germans with his knife sceaming like an animale and killing two soilders cuting ones head off and holding it out front of them. They called him a screaming demon and ran away. So what im trying to say here is you have Tyrese trap in a room with 25 zombies and this man in real life holding a head who could have been shoot. But instead he scared away the enemy both storys our possible but only one is real :eek:
  • Master of AeonsMaster of Aeons
    edited September 2012
    AceStarr wrote: »
    But ill do you one better which is real life there is a story i read about a African American soilder during world war 2 who watched the nazis shot his comrade. They said he snap out and ran into the Germans with his knife sceaming like an animale and killing two soilders cuting ones head off and holding it out front of them. They called him a screaming demon and ran away. So what im trying to say here is you have Tyrese trap in a room with 25 zombies and this man in real life holding a head who could have been shoot. But instead he scared away the enemy both storys our possible but only one is real :eek:

    I'll give you those as both extreme examples of human perseverance. I find neither example supernatural though. They're within the bounds of our ability, but people don't do them because they're never pushed to. Tyreese was in peak form and a fine human specimen who killed two dozen zombies or more. Rick and Michonne later do the same thing with a horde.

    I don't disagree with your points, they're both excellent examples although one is fake. But neither involves spontaneous healing, ressurection or miracles. Superhero comics are based around magical twists and illogical revelations. I still don't see that ever happening in The Walking Dead.
  • AceStarrAceStarr
    edited September 2012
    Master of Aeons wrote: »
    I'll give you those as both extreme examples of human perseverance. I find neither example supernatural though. They're within the bounds of our ability, but people don't do them because they're never pushed to. Tyreese was in peak form and a fine human specimen who killed two dozen zombies or more. Rick and Michonne later do the same thing with a horde.

    I don't disagree with your points, they're both excellent examples although one is fake. But neither involves spontaneous healing, ressurection or miracles. Superhero comics are based around magical twists and illogical revelations. I still don't see that ever happening in The Walking Dead.

    I dont disagree with you your right Kirkman has not went that route yet. Im just saying its possible in the comic book world.
  • Master of AeonsMaster of Aeons
    edited September 2012
    Sure. I can't imagine he'll keep a realistic tone forever. Especially after the dream sequence where they were all superpowered.
This discussion has been closed.