If You Could... Who Would You Choose?
Who would you choose to pardon from death? So far in this game, if you had the power to change only one characters fate, only one, which of the main characters would you save from their ultimate demise? Who gets to live? and why?
Duck
Katjaa
Carley
Doug
Lary
Mark
Shawn
Other
did i get everyone?
Duck
Katjaa
Carley
Doug
Lary
Mark
Shawn
Other
did i get everyone?
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Future episodes Clem
Currently Duck b because that way i could save TWO characters {kaatja suicided because of Duck}
(There's a guy called CinnamonToastKen on YouTube if you are wondering what the hell I am talking about.)
Spell her name right.... Sniff
Hopefully, by the time Episode 4 is about to come out, that dumbtard AJ Locasio whose been ignoring important questions FROM THE FANS and handpicking questions that SEEMS IMPORTANT TO HIM will have the balls to start asking Telltale Game staffs questions like
1. So, Episode 3 was a bit late. You guys promised that it'd get released by mid August. What happened along the way ? Was there some sort of trouble ?
2. I was a bit shocked about your decisions to kill off Carley. I thought she'd hang around for a little bit more. I know she had to go eventually, but it didn't hit me that she'd go this way because the Episode 3 prediction gave me a feeling that she'd be doing as fine as she did in Episode 2. In fact, players were teased with a bit Carley-Lee romance at the start of the game before her demise. What's your take on this ?
3. I know this is THE Walking Dead, but if there was a huge request from fans, will you guys ever consider bringing Carley/Doug back ? You know, maybe at the end of the game, it might have been revealed that they survived the gunshot to the face. And by coming back, I mean in person, not as a walking dead.
OH GOD PLEASE BRING HER BACK!
Let there be an option to make Ben the traitor, and let Lily kill him. That way, its a mere death switch, which makes it VERY viable.
Unfortunately at this rate, I don't think Telltale would go all out on bringing Carley back as how she looked like in the game.
Imagine maybe Carley coming back with an eye patch or something. I think that's as far as Telltale's willing to go.
Telltale is not Robert Kirkman, Robert Kirkman is not Telltale. How they direct the story doesn't have to be in conjunction with that fatman's story. I get it that TWD is a sad story about human nature, but it doesn't mean any game based on it have to follow that fatass' lead, especially the kind that screws up fan's expectation.
really? wow! lol, i totally picked this name in a hurry last night because i needed to make a name quickly as i joined in the midst of me playing... i couldn't think of anything clever right then so i picked my breakfast. lol it was this or Coffee! i think i will change my name if i can to avoid confusion as i am totally not a guy, not ken and am not on youtube! lol
i'll give it a whirl sometime, but right now i'm on a downer from ep3: carley 3 fuckers spoiled me on facebook), duck (holy shit i actually shot him), katjaa (knew she'd die but why not take duck with her), lilly taking her first steps to going bat guano crazy..
Wasted Potential...yes i agree with that. That and other than Clem, Carley was the only one who REALLY knew who you were at first, and your love interest.
And also the person who saved you....
goddamn it
Damn... should of thought about that, lol. I picked Kaatja.
Even in the end, he was a big ol' lovable hero.
But well, having Larry around bossing us around created the illusion of safety.
Fixed that for you.
In the beginning, we all simply saw her as just an idiot who didn't know how to put in batteries. In the beginning, I just saw her as one of those snooty news anchors who was trying to move on up. But then I saw how much her and Lee were pretty much the only ones who were ACTUALLY friends. It could have blossomed in to something more.
Seeing how much she cared about Clem and Lee, how she always joked about the battery situation, how she kissed Lee on the cheek, how she wasted those two bandits with her pistol... only for her to be on the other end just five minutes afterwards.
That is why I didn't think twice before leaving Lilly on the road... that is why I would have killed her, would I be given the choice... that is why I would have made it to where that coward died and not Carley.
theres no way to bring back Mark without severely changing the storyline
These are some solid questions. Unfortunately, if they do answer the questions, they'd probably give us some BS answers.
I miss Carley and Duck.
Not sure why, but I felt more of a bond with Kenny/Katjaa than any other characters in the game. It really sucked when she offed herself.
Three-fer. You get Robin.
Duck and Katjaa had no real place. Altho if I had to choose one to die, it would be Kat.
Cause Clem needs another kid and maybe Kenny wouldn't be such a wreck.
I think Kenny gathered himself remarkably well, all things considered.
I would save primarily Carley and secondarily Mark. Carley because her death was just so stupid and Mark because he seemed all-round likable.
I really, really wish you could've chosen whether Lilly shoots Carley or Ben based on your conversation choices just before it happened, since she was blaming both of them after all.
I can't help but feel TTG knew this would be the sort of reaction they would get. Can't help but feel it's sadistic of them to kill her off, but would you expect anything less considering the nature of the series?
That's EXACTLY the kind of person I'd want to have in my own survivor group - people I can depend on. Who cares if she's got a problem with batteries?
Lilly got increasingly angry, hostile and downright insane, Kenny would blindly do anything to protect himself and his family, Larry was just a giant ass to everybody and Ben is ... well ... just nobody you could depend on to save your life in a sticky situation.
Mark was likable, if maybe rather naive, but I just didn't know him enough to prefer him over Carley. Same situation as with Shawn, really (minus the naivety).
I also liked Katjaa quite a bit, but in the end she's still Kenny's wife and during the episodes I didn't really get to talk or interact with her all that much. The whole situation was also just too much for her to handle, so I have my doubts if it'd do her any good to bring her back into this cruel world.
Duck was plain annoying in the first two episodes, but I did feel very sad for him in episode 3. Still I think he's better off this way. If not on that day, something would have gotten to him rather sooner than later, anyway.
Doug... well, I didn't play with him, so I can't say much about him. Liked him in episode 1, at least, but I'll always prefer Carly over his TV remote skills.