›

[SPOILERS] Mission: Reproduce Lily Leaving in Ep. 2

SacredlessSacredless
edited September 2012 in The Walking Dead
This statement is pretty simple. People are pushing to have Carley be saved and I'm trying to find out ways how to avoid her being killed in Episode 3. Unfortunately, I understand that there is no way of saving Carley unless you get rid of Lilly beforehand somehow.
Luckily, I found this on IGN somewhere, but I've found counterevidence to their claims. Here is their claim;
Talk to Andy. Choose to kill him or go with the group. Walkers will eat him regardless of your decision. Lily will stay at the dairy if you kill Andy.
However, if you watch this video, it shows quite clearly that she chooses to stay with the group regardless of Andy dying. In fact, it looks like in the video her father was murdered by Lee.

Now, I would like to ask anyone to reproduce IGN's find of Lily staying behind. Effectively, this will keep her from bashing the group apart and we will be able to save Carley and a whole heap of trouble.
Try to keep the format of your post simple; give a short summary of the choices you made that either lead or didn't lead to Lily staying behind or otherwise dropping out in Episode 2 at the end of the mission.
I'm happily waiting for your reports! Remember, reports about what choices did -not- lead to Lily leaving the group are just as welcome. I'll compile the answers in my OP until the right or best answer is found.

Current findings:
Killing Andy + Killing Larry + Killing Danny doesn't make Lily leave.

Comments

  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited September 2012
    what a load of bollocks..

    lilly walks with them anyway..
  • dubesordubesor
    edited September 2012
    None of your choices alter the story. You can not make Lilly leave the group. You can not save Carley. None of your choices have any influence in the result. There isn't more to say.

    Plus IGN isn't exactly known for being reliable.
  • SacredlessSacredless
    edited September 2012
    While I understand your frustration, the game does claim it is possible that you end up with an entirely different team of survivors in the end. I have found no proof that there is no way to influence the result, so I see no reason to be discouraged at the moment. Thank you for your posts, however.

    EDIT: Oh and Milosuperspesh, I've added the link afterwards when I noticed your post. Thanks for reminding me. :)
  • SacredlessSacredless
    edited September 2012
    On another forum, I've read a report that killing both Andy and Dan doesn't make Lily leave, but it didn't say she killed Larry as well. Can anyone confirm for me if the combination of killing Larry, Andy and Dan has any effects...?
  • Ja1862Ja1862
    edited September 2012
    Carley was a rubbish character with a bad voice actor, is the only reason people like her is so the can have a computer game sex scene with her and Lee? (shudders)
  • SacredlessSacredless
    edited September 2012
    Ja1862 wrote: »
    Carley was a rubbish character with a bad voice actor, is the only reason people like her is so the can have a computer game sex scene with her and Lee? (shudders)
    That is not the subject of this topic, I'm not interested in what you are saying here. Though I welcome your B.U.M.P. otherwise. :)
  • QuarterPounderVladQuarterPounderVlad
    edited September 2012
    Um. That's complete bullshit, A good thing you checked with The community.
    And Lay off, ja1862, She's the fucking best character after clem and kenny.
  • TeleporterFINTeleporterFIN
    edited September 2012
    Ja1862 wrote: »
    Carley was a rubbish character with a bad voice actor, is the only reason people like her is so the can have a computer game sex scene with her and Lee? (shudders)
    You're an asshat.
  • SacredlessSacredless
    edited September 2012
    Thank you, Vlad, I feel welcome already. :) On another forum, I've checked out if the murder of Dan has any influence and according to a high-rating member there, it did not influence her decision to stay. Therefore, it is not the murder that Lee commits that would trigger Lily staying. A few final possibilities could be that you need to disagree with Lily openly several times and make clear you are on Kenny's side of the argument and that you will leave with his family in the RV. I don't see many other options right now. If I can get (un)confirmation that being anti-Lily from some point in the episodes would make her turn her back on the group earlier, it would be appreciated.
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    this thread kinda pointless; and by kinda I mean completely
  • WeiliWeili
    edited September 2012
    Xarne wrote: »
    this thread kinda pointless; and by kinda I mean completely
    The same goes for your comment.
  • XarneXarne
    edited September 2012
    Weili wrote: »
    The same goes for your comment.

    Clown you are fighting everyone on these forums, on like every thread
    You're already fighting like 5 people in the choices thread and you're fighting with me in here. Thing is you're not saying anything other than 'dont buy it' or 'dont play it'. Sorry that doesnt fly. Get you fanboi ass in check and learn to communicate with others. Bye bye
  • FreezeFreeze
    edited September 2012
    Kinda think that the least Telltale can do is give us a dream sequence and proper goodbye for Carley. Everyone that wants her "back" just wants a little closure. So I'm hoping Telltale does that and we can all move on. Next episode better be beast.
This discussion has been closed.