Kill Kenny or Pregnant Christa (hypothetical)

edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
In ep 4 you find out Christa is pregnant and Omid's leg is infected. He's sick and getting weaker.

Kenny does what he does and is about to kill Omid because he thinks he's going to die and turn.

Christa is pissed and aims a gun at Kenny with the intent to kill and Kenny doesn't see her.

If you try to warn Kenny he'll look at Christa and get shot. Killing Christa is the only way to prevent his death.

You have to take out Christa or let Kenny die. What do you do?
«1

Comments

  • edited September 2012
    Christa. I can't kill my boy :D
  • edited September 2012
    Christa. I can't kill my boy :D

    You would kill a pregnant woman? haha. You need some Theraflu.
  • edited September 2012
    Wait is this hypothetical or a spoiler
  • edited September 2012
    Red Panda wrote: »
    You would kill a pregnant woman? haha. You need some Theraflu.

    i would rather save somebody who has had my back this whole time, then some stranger who has been a bitch :p
  • edited September 2012
    L e x wrote: »
    Wait is this hypothetical or a spoiler

    hypothetical.
  • edited September 2012
    Is there a way to push Ben in the line of fire and thus save Kenny with Ben's heroic sacrifice? If not, then I'll go with "...".
  • edited September 2012
    Couldn't you tell Kenny to stop and talk it through quickly? But if Christa is stupid enough to try and stop Kenny if Omid dies, I would have to kill her. Why would I let her kill Kenny and endanger everyone else? Her being pregnant doesn't change too much for me, it would be a hard decision but I would end up having to kill Christa.
  • edited September 2012
    Kill my boy who although we had differences; has my back; and just recently lost his family
    or
    Some bitch who's been critiquing my child raising skills the second she made eye contact with Clem and is ready to bail the second everything isnt up to her satisfaction...
    tough decision
  • edited September 2012
    ZacTB wrote: »
    Couldn't you tell Kenny to stop and talk it through quickly? But if Christa is stupid enough to try and stop Kenny if Omid dies, I would have to kill her. Why would I let her kill Kenny and endanger everyone else? Her being pregnant doesn't change too much for me, it would be a hard decision but I would end up having to kill Christa.

    glad to see someone agrees with me :)
  • edited September 2012
    L e x wrote: »
    Wait is this hypothetical or a spoiler

    Don't you know? I have access to the scripts months in advance b/c me and TTG is cool like that.

    :spoil-o:(In the end, Lee is killed by aliens.):spoil-o:
  • edited September 2012
    Red Panda wrote: »
    Don't you know? I have access to the scripts months in advance b/c me and TTG is cool like that.

    :spoil-o:(In the end, Lee is killed by aliens.):spoil-o:

    I thought maybe you had those wikileaks
  • edited September 2012
    Red Panda wrote: »
    Don't you know? I have access to the scripts months in advance b/c me and TTG is cool like that.

    :spoil-o:(In the end, Lee is killed by aliens.):spoil-o:

    Its like talking with the devil...you dont know whats true and whats false
    he speaks in half truths
  • edited September 2012
    Goddammit, I knew dem aliens had something to do with this!

    About the thread though, we've just met Christa and Kenny's been through a lot with us recently, and in that case I think they'd both be wrong. Kenny for wanting to (yet again) kill a living person whose fate could be unknown and Christa for wanting to just shoot the guy instead of trying to talk him out of it or just trying to stop him in a non-lethal way. So I guess I'd have to shoot Christa? Either way I'd feel awful, so I don't know, really =(
  • edited September 2012
    Assuming the zombie apocalypse wouldn't be over in a matter of months, how healthy would raising a new born baby in a environment like that accomplish? I might argue it may be more humane to wait until it's over (if it ends) to have a child, but entering a child into a tortuous world like that would be more horrendous than killing it before it can even think. The sad truth is if the plague never ends then there's no point in trying to create more humans if all it will do will eventually lead to more zombies. (As it will only stop when every zombies head is smashed in, and when humans eventually die they'll turn, creating a never ending cycle)

    So with that all said and done, if she was aiming to kill Kenney I'd probably go after her and stop her not fully realizing that she'd die by my actions. Granted I'd rather kill a attempted murderer than let someone kill another for revenge, as we need trust in this game, and if you're swayed by emotions so much you'd kill another useful living being, then you're a threat to the group. (Cold as it may sound)
  • edited September 2012
    L e x wrote: »
    I thought maybe you had those wikileaks

    Understandable! TTG keeps their scripts in a secret government docs and Jewls (Julian Assange as most people know him) is my peeps, but no.
  • edited September 2012
    I will Kill the woman because I am friends with Kenny in this game. Losing Doug was hard and if I lose Kenny to that would really suck since I built up this nice friendship with him even if he been a dick sometimes.
  • edited September 2012
    You want to show Clementine that there is hope.... Right?

    How do you kill a pregnant woman then? How in the hell do you make that sound like a good thing? Kenny is an able bodied man, and in MY playthrough? He left me to fend for myself under a door crawling with, well, Crawlers.

    Like he said to me, "You took care of yourself, right?" Well Ken, here's your shot to do the same.
  • edited September 2012
    Kenny has had my back since day 1, and Christa is bitching about me and Clem half a minute after she meets me. Not a hard choice. Clem might not like it, but I can't do everything for her.
  • edited September 2012
    You want to show Clementine that there is hope.... Right?

    How do you kill a pregnant woman then? How in the hell do you make that sound like a good thing? Kenny is an able bodied man, and in MY playthrough? He left me to fend for myself under a door crawling with, well, Crawlers.

    Like he said to me, "You took care of yourself, right?" Well Ken, here's your shot to do the same.

    pregnancy is hypothesized, you'd kill Kenny after all you been through with him?
    We had our ups and downs, but thats what friends do...
    maybe because he lost his family or maybe because he's the only familiar face I've got left, but I've got his back to the end- at the very least I wouldnt side with a stranger over him. (A rude one at that)
  • edited September 2012
    Christa! Two birds with one stone!
  • edited September 2012
    I'd have to back my bro, Kenny. We've been at odds, but we bonded over me shooting his kid in the head. Good times.
  • edited September 2012
    I'd kill Kenny, it would be the humane thing to do, no person can live after what has happened, Lilly has shown that it's best to put someone out of their misery before they snap like that.
  • edited September 2012
    I'd kill Christa. Kenny and I have had each others' backs since the day we me ton Hershel's farm. We started growing apart at the start of 3, but me and him are Brothers to the End. Christa has done nothing but yell at me, for how I'm teaching Clem to defend herself and SURVIVE in this new world. I saved her at the train, and she said it was the "wrong choice" and I should have saved the other guy. Don't worry Chrissy, i'll make the "right choice" this time around.
  • edited September 2012
    I'm a bit surprised. Kenny potentially almost lets you die twice. Plus, he has an itchy trigger finger. And Christa is freaking pregnant. You're killing her and her unborn child.
  • edited September 2012
    Kenny is one of the people I can trust, he has helped me many times, and we are friends for months.
    I do not think 2 times and shoot Christa.
  • edited September 2012
    I'd have to back my bro, Kenny. We've been at odds, but we bonded over me shooting his kid in the head. Good times.

    Man you killed his son in your first date ??? bold move !!!!
  • edited September 2012
    Xarne wrote: »
    pregnancy is hypothesized, you'd kill Kenny after all you been through with him?
    We had our ups and downs, but thats what friends do...
    maybe because he lost his family or maybe because he's the only familiar face I've got left, but I've got his back to the end- at the very least I wouldnt side with a stranger over him. (A rude one at that)

    Considering the fact that Kenny left me to die at the hands of some walkers, Yeah. I don't feel like I owe him anything after that. He saved me once, and left me to die once. That means we're square in my book.

    I'd rather keep around someone that I don't think is going to have some huge episode because they didn't get their way. I get it, I didn't side with you but you wanna let walkers fucking eat me? That's not cool man.

    I repaid him enough by doing the deed for him with his kid. Christa may be a bit of a bitch but she likes that I'm a straight shooter with Clem. I think we'll get along okay in the 2nd episode with her (because I helped Omid on the train too).
  • edited September 2012
    Better the devil you know, than the devil you dont
  • edited September 2012
    Despite everything, I want Kenny to last till the end.... and beyond!
  • edited September 2012
    Gotta help my boy Kenny!
  • edited September 2012
    Considering the fact that Kenny left me to die at the hands of some walkers, Yeah. I don't feel like I owe him anything after that. He saved me once, and left me to die once. That means we're square in my book.

    I believe he would have to try to kill you to be square. I think you still owe him a rescue.
  • edited September 2012
    As much as I am on team Kenny, I would have to let her shoot him. I couldn't shoot a prego woman.
  • edited September 2012
    This choice was so much easier than I would have imagined lol
  • edited September 2012
    Wait, do we know she's pregnant at the moment we're making the choice to kill her or not? Not that it would affect my desicion at all, just curious.
  • edited September 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Wait, do we know she's pregnant at the moment we're making the choice to kill her or not? Not that it would affect my desicion at all, just curious.

    Yes
  • edited September 2012
    I was off to a bad start with Christa and quite frankly don't see myself getting attached to them but there's no way I'm going to kill a pregnant woman much less murder unless necessary.

    Plus if you think about it, killing Kenny is most humane thing to do. He really seemed to only care about his family and at this point he's lost everything
  • edited September 2012
    The situation could have been better but Id off kenny
  • edited September 2012
    kenny without a doubt
  • edited September 2012
    bazenji wrote: »
    I believe he would have to try to kill you to be square. I think you still owe him a rescue.

    I did save Katjaa as well, and Duck for that matter when he botched that.

    He did leave me to die but Lilly used her sickle of doom to save me.

    I didn't put in all of the details, but really I think that I'm pretty even with everyone at the moment. If not? Then I'm Urban, so I don't need to remember.
  • edited September 2012
    Id let Christa shoot Kenny. Kenny's been pissing me off since episode 2 and to tell you the truth I'm sick of having him around now. After how I saved his son in ep one and sided with him to not throw Duck out to the walkers, and he repays me by almost letting me die twice? Yeah he'll be lucky if I don't actually HELP Christa kill him let alone stop her. Fuck him.
    Xarne wrote: »
    pregnancy is hypothesized, you'd kill Kenny after all you been through with him?
    We had our ups and downs, but thats what friends do...

    Friends don't leave you to die, twice as a matter of fact.
This discussion has been closed.