›

The saddest Scene of TWD

owner070owner070
edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
I have 2 saddest Scene's of twd that is: In the office of the drugstore and with that little kid in episode 4 that starved to death. And that sad music that they put in when they were in the office dude come on do they want to make us cry?

Comments

  • ChomposaurChomposaur
    edited October 2012
    Hard to choose, but off the top of my head it would have be Lee seeing his dead brother and saying sorry to him, reminds me of someone I know and how I would feel in that situation.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited October 2012
    Wait...shouldn't this thread be in the spoilers sub-forum?

    EDIT: So it's definitely Duck's death. Poor guy didn't deserve to go out like this.
  • puzzleboxpuzzlebox Telltale Alumni
    edited October 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Wait...shouldn't this thread be in the spoilers sub-forum?

    Yup, moved.
  • 2-_-DEAD2-_-DEAD
    edited October 2012
    Duck's death was by far the worst for me.
  • DreamjbkDreamjbk
    edited October 2012
    Carley
  • Web HeadWeb Head
    edited October 2012
    Duck, though..It was depressing..
  • Phoenix VIIPhoenix VII
    edited October 2012
    Lee's bite and Carley's death were both sad and unexpected for me. Duck's death was sad but expected, I couldn't stand him for the first 2 episodes but he grew on me in the 3rd, poor kid.
  • pdlbeanpdlbean
    edited October 2012
    yeah, definitely Duck. That always sticks out in my mind.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited October 2012
    Duck's death by far. The kid may have been annoying, but Batman can't go on without Robin!
  • KingOfTheDeadKingOfTheDead
    edited October 2012
    The little kid in the attic im saying this because i choose the boot kill and just squished his head. However this made me feel better when i seen the face i kind of laughed.
  • DemonseedDemonseed
    edited October 2012
    I think Lee's brother was #1 for me, followed by the poor kid in the attic and having to take care of Duck after Kenny's wife shoots herself.
  • SalamiSmugglerSalamiSmuggler
    edited October 2012
    Duck's demise was the saddest part. He was brave and was willing to help as much as Clementine. They were both young kids who were friends. Then he gets bit, gets sick and you or Kenny has to shoot him before he turns into a walker. While this builds up the story and emotion for the player, it goes against what Telltale games states; "A tailored game experience – Live with the profound and lasting consequences of the decisions that you make in each episode. Your actions and choices will affect how your story plays out across the entire series." :rolleyes:
  • QuarterPounderVladQuarterPounderVlad
    edited October 2012
    Le quack.
    Duccccck... Y u leave so soon?!
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited October 2012
    duck, starved kid walker, clems haircut,

    the moment the dead dogs head fell off (no more chance for resi style zombie dog)
  • KabutoGodTier420KabutoGodTier420
    edited October 2012
    Saddest scene would be Lee getting bit. Fuck Duck. He was like a Ben Jr. And I saved him the misery of growing up into a slightly more intelligent zombified version of Ben.
  • AraronAraron
    edited October 2012
    I would actually say Ben's final scene (if you choose to let him go).Ofc,Duck is right next to him,but the way the camera moves and the way he falls was really tragic. :)
  • Alchera7Alchera7
    edited October 2012
    Saddest part for me was the boy in the attic, and having to bury him. It was haunting because I had already lost Duck, and Clementine is the only kid I have left in my group to save. Just another reminder of the possibility of losing Clemy. :(

    Most disturbing and emotionally wrecking part for me was watching poor Clementine eat HUMAN MEAT... I felt so sick the rest of that episode, (being vegetarian, didn't help much either...) I was trying so hard the entire game to keep her safe and pure, but after watching that I almost lost it.

    EDIT: Actually the saddest part, was watching Carley get shot in the face. Totally unexpected, and I was in total denial figuring out she dies regardless of what I said to Lilly. I was hoping to get romantic dialogue with Carley, and she would of made for a good mother for Clementine. She really had her head together, and reminded me a lot of a female version of Lee.
  • Perfect_CellPerfect_Cell
    edited October 2012
    Saddest part for me has to be either axing lee's brother.. man why did you have to click so many times :( or attic boy, yes duck was said but to hit kenny with that straight after was just torture(ps kenny is my bro)
  • TheShooterTheShooter
    edited November 2012
    The scene that i find it as the saddest is when Lee and Andy fight while the whole group see the fight, the music (Its over) made it soooo sad which also makes me feel sorry for the group that they didn't expect that from St Jones.
  • fusedmassfusedmass Banned
    edited November 2012
    They're was a ton of sad ones. I say the meat freezer one. Because you can hear her screaming for him. It just provokes emotion while other ones are dead and zombies. This game is very well made for moral choices.
  • Sweater SnakeSweater Snake
    edited November 2012
    To this thread I only have one thing to say.

    "Hey, bud."
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited November 2012
    It's quoted in my signature, it's an achievement from episode three, I also used the achievement as my forum avatar. I don't think Beatrice's death wasn't the saddest, but it was the one which I can't (and probably won't) forget. I can't say I "liked" the death scene, I mean, I did like it, but not that "LOL she died omfg lol yes" kind of like. Remembering how Kenny actually wants to let her alive (to buy himself some time) always makes me think about how sick it would be to live during a ZA.
  • MalphaxisMalphaxis
    edited November 2012
    duck dieing, the attic kid, seeing that Katcha had killed herself, even finding Chuck in the sewer was pretty rough.
    But for me, I think it was when Ben told me why I needed to let him go and I realized he was right.
  • FollowLillyFollowLilly
    edited November 2012
    had to be when you find the train
    you can only watch as Duck slowly falls apart and you try to do anything to help
    bring him animal crackers, like thatll do anything, but its all you can do

    and then, Lilly left with the RV, once Lilly was gone I just felt entirely hopeless
  • gameaddictwngameaddictwn
    edited November 2012
    The saddest part for me: In ep 3 when I found out I couldn't throw Ben off the train.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    gameaddictwn wrote: »
    The saddest part for me: In ep 3 when I found out I couldn't throw Ben off the train.

    lol yeah

    and for me words are not enough but this pic is

    pardon the size...
    2012-10-10_00037.jpg

    i didn't want to lie but ttg gave me no choice...it sucked.....
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited November 2012
    How could I even forget about that scene?? Clementine crying is by far the saddest thing of the whole game :(
  • DevlonirDevlonir
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    lol yeah

    and for me words are not enough but this pic is

    pardon the size...
    2012-10-10_00037.jpg

    i didn't want to lie but ttg gave me no choice...it sucked.....

    This scene was the second time in my 20+ years of gaming that a video game made me cry.
  • gameaddictwngameaddictwn
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    lol yeah

    and for me words are not enough but this pic is

    pardon the size...
    2012-10-10_00037.jpg

    i didn't want to lie but ttg gave me no choice...it sucked.....

    What happens when you lie and say yes?
  • SikorySikory
    edited November 2012
    gameaddictwn wrote: »
    What happens when you lie and say yes?

    She doesnt believe you.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    Sikory wrote: »
    She doesnt believe you.

    thats what i did. same result but feels worse.

    i choked up and almost screamed 'noooo not clem, lee you frickin idiot!! ' i then offered a hand to her and she turns away and walks to the window seat..

    ttg owned it. (even though i hated the feeling)
  • GrimfangoGrimfango
    edited November 2012
    I think Hershel's son getting killed because of you is pretty bad. Hershel was pretty torn up. Yeah, we didn't know him like we knew Duck, but once Duck had been bitten you knew his end was coming, but I didn't know there would be choices like the one with Duck and Hershel's son that I'd have to make so it was quite shocking and sad. Same with the Carley and Doug decision. Carrying that kind of guilt is sad! There's been a whole ton of sad moments though. The boy in the attic was pretty sad, but to be honest, by this point, with all the frequent deaths, I'm just glad he's too weak to lunge at me and Kenny!
  • TypicaljacobTypicaljacob
    edited November 2012
    the scene when lee is beating the shit out of andy st.john and everyone watches ( i agree this music "its over" intensifies the scene's mood), clem and lee holding hands when the others are taking supplies from the abandoned car, dropping ben ( this wasnt actually the choice i made, i went on youtube and saw what happens when you do drop ben. TTG made you feel so guilty by only snapping his legs and getting him eaten alive! again with "its over" playing in the back...) and clem crying towards the end of episode 4. poor clem :/ didnt mean to make her cry
  • lilTomTomlilTomTom
    edited November 2012
    It was hard to chose. Too many good people died. Though episode 4 with the zombie boy who starved to death really did make me tear up. You don't know his story or anything. Just that he was probably waiting it out or waiting for his parents to return.
  • MRH__98MRH__98
    edited November 2012
    Duck's death or Clementine crying.
  • SalamiSmugglerSalamiSmuggler
    edited November 2012
    Duck's death got to me emotionally. Here is this young active kid always wanting to lend a hand then gets bit and slowly suffers to the last breath. Watching him laying against a tree struggling to live and then passes away was just tragic.
  • HiggsBoson2142HiggsBoson2142
    edited November 2012
    3. Shooting Andy St. John. Even more than leaving him. I just take a shot and he limply falls onto the ground to be no more.

    2. Kenny's Breakdown. When Ben finally reveals the beginning of Duck's and Katjaa's fate to Kenny, it just made me lose all hope. My two favorite characters turned against eachother.

    1. In the Meat Locker. If you turn off the music, and just listen to Lilly's cries for her dad before you decide who to help, it's just so sad and pitiful. And I helped Kenny...
  • ZozmaZozma
    edited November 2012
    No love for Mark? That really tore me up. I knew what I was going to find when I pushed that bookcase aside and opened that door but it still didn't prepare me for what I saw. Even worse when the poor guy drags himself to the doorway! I felt bad for him because he was so optimistic about the farm and it was the worst place for him. Even more so because it was just an arrow to the shoulder. He could have survived that, barring infection.

    I also thought burying the little boy was disturbing. I kept screaming "WHY ARE THEY MAKING ME DO THIS? GAH! THIS GAME IS MEAN!"

    I was also upset by a number of the other scenes brought up here. Duck saddened me because I was fond of the derpy kid. He reminds me of my nephew (and yep, he's dumber than a bag of hammers!) and he was Clem's friend.

    And Carley's death upset me in a different way because I was so angry with Lilly! Quite honestly, I didn't hesitate to leave her behind. She was unhinged.
  • PatPlaysTWDPatPlaysTWD
    edited November 2012
    1. Duck's death. I don't see how he's annoying at all. He just has a stupid voice.

    2. Ben's death. Oh god, that scene. Definitely saving him when I get EP4.

    3. Chuck's death. Clem would have died if he didn't tell you to teach her to use a gun!

    4. Kenny's Breakdown. Ben, y u do that? He's already depressed enough.

    5. Doug's death. Carley just... died. Doug died saving Ben. What a hero.

    99999999999. Larry's death. Piece of shit deserved it :)
This discussion has been closed.