Hardest/Easiest decision
Out of all of the episodes, which decision have you found the easiest, and which have you found the hardest.
My easiest decision was leaving Lilly behind - once she'd shot Doug I didn't feel she deserved to be in the group any longer and knew I couldn't forgive her.
My hardest decision was probably the Ben one. I dropped him. Often I've felt torn when having to choose between people, but this is the first time I let someone die when there wasn't anyone else who needed saving. Mega regret!
My easiest decision was leaving Lilly behind - once she'd shot Doug I didn't feel she deserved to be in the group any longer and knew I couldn't forgive her.
My hardest decision was probably the Ben one. I dropped him. Often I've felt torn when having to choose between people, but this is the first time I let someone die when there wasn't anyone else who needed saving. Mega regret!
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
easiest: conversations
Easiest: Dealing with Duck. I shot him.
Easiest: Saving Ben (I didn't mistreat him, threaten him, or oppose him any time at all. Why should I drop him?)
Hardest: Telling Clementine that I think her parents are dead. I decided to kill Larry as soon as Kenny started freaking out because I agreed with him, but actually doing the quick time event felt really crappy.
Hardest: Dropping Ben. It kills me inside but I think I did the right thing.
The easiest was pulling Ben up. I got emotional at that scene, and as soon as the option appeared I picked it
Yeah, shooting Duck was surprisingly easy, I just couldn't let Kenny or Catcha do it.
who's Catcha?
is it that idiot that can't catch a ball during baseball?
Attachment not found.
Katja?
Katcha?
Catja?
Ya know, Kenny's dead wife
If you didn't hate him how come you dropped him?
next time play the game in subtitles
her name is spelled Katjaa, not Catcha, Catcha is that idiot that can't catch a ball during baseball
Jeez, it's not like I spelt YOUR name wrong.
I thought you meant Catcha sorry
well now you know who he is
Just because I didn't hate him doesn't mean I didn't think he was a liability to the group. He was in a tough position and I wanted to end it. I probably would've saved him if I knew it meant he would help me save Clem, though.
Yeah, I thought if you opted to save him, you'd try to and he'd slip anyway. That said, he'd probably be more of a danger to Clem than a saviour if his past behaviour is anything to go by.
I was thinking if I would've saved him he'd mess up everything in Episode 5, but end up saving Clem or something like that.
Yeah that's possible. We've probably killed Clem by dropping Ben. Whoops!
Easiest choice, when compared to the gravity of the issue, was killing Duck. Couldn't think of a single good reason not to do it myself. And plenty of reasons why it would be the better course to take.
Hardest: saving Larry, saving Ben and bringing Clem to Crawford
Larry might have been an a-hole but Lilly begging made me help him, I like Ben but he still is a liability, Clem would be in danger no matter what I did but I am glad I brought cause she saved Molly
Easiest was shooting Duck.
There was a lot of easy choices though.
Saving Larry
Leaving the Girl
Leaving Lilly
etc
I don't know the easiest. Letting that girl get eaten by walkers in ep 3 was easy for me. Guilt is not something I've felt.
easiest by far high fiving duck cos i'm that awesome
But the hardest,would probably be helping Kenny kill Larry...I did it.But Lee is still wondering if he did the right thing.
Really? I was pretty torn between Shawn and Duck, maybe because it was the first choice like that I was faced with in the game.
Easiest: Choosing Carley (I already knew I would save the girl when I saw it in one of the trailers. Sorry Doug!)
Hardest: Trying to save Larry, shooting the girl (woulda left her if not for Kenny making it sound more monstrous than it was), and the hardest of all, saving Ben
On the Ben decision I think I need to elaborate some. All throughout episode 4 I hated him more and more every time he did...well...ANYTHING, but I tried to be fair to him still. The straw that broke the camels back was the axe. I was ready to get him killed FIRST chance I got! *rawr roor* But, When Clem intervened I had to rethink the entire thing, and I wasn't done thinking when the bell tower happened. When I realized I had to choose his fate right then and there, cue BSOD in my brain.
I ultimately saved him and don't regret it a bit. *applauds Telltale for being able to do that to me*
I dropped him and feel eternally guilty. From reading stuff on this forum about people's decision RE Ben, I think taking Clem played a big part in whether you saved him or not. Quite a few people have said they would've dropped him had it not been for Clem defending him. I didn't take Clem and sort of forgot she even liked Ben until I got back to the house. I think if she'd been there it would have swayed me in to saving him.
Yeah, while my ultimate reasoning for saving him has nothing to do with Clem, I probably wouldn't have had that train of thought in the first place if she wasn't there. So if I had left her, I would probably be in the same boat as you. It's interesting.
Oh yeah,my timer almost run out on that one.
Lol you can just save Ben xDDDD you really didn't have to drop him lol
I did. I really did. Not surprisingly though if queen clem had been allowed to come to crawford I would had most likely saved him.
But with the new addition of molly and only 5 on the boat. There was only 1 step forward. Christa and kenny back me up.
People always say how him asking to be dropped changed their mind. Thats dumb. Lets take a suicidal and detrimental character with us. YAY
exacta mondo
not to mention he's killed 3-4 people and is naive and his logic is totally fubar
Hardest - Showing the bite to the group and saving/killing Larry in the freezer. (these two are toss ups for me, I can't decide)
Easiest: Shooting the girl in the beginning of episode 3
Hardest: Saving ben. i hated ben since i found out he is responcable to killing Duck, Katjaa, Carley, and acually chuck for not helping out then. But at the moment i didnt think he deserved to die like that. I saved ben but im still not crazy about him. if i had to choose between him and someone else i wouldnt choose ben. But if i dropped him i would be no better than lilly, in which i left.
Whether or not to kill Danny - I spared him.
Easiest:
Whether to leave Clem's house during the day or at night - I left during the day.