›

What road would have gone if Carley/Doug hadn't died

TheNNerdGamerTheNNerdGamer
edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
Again I was thinking.
what route could it have gone.
I Lilly hadn't gone out of her mind, what would had happened.

Carley: Carley and Lee would had turned out as a couple.
Doug: I have no idea, maybe best bros 4 life?

Comments

  • Luigi01080Luigi01080
    edited November 2012
    Katjaa and duck would still be dead, and carley would have had our back and stopped lee from getting bit and been a loving couple. Lily and kenny still would fight over who is in charge and my lee would have been in the lily team with carley. although alternatively if lily shot ben i feel everyone would be happier.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited November 2012
    Who knows? Definitely get some romance with Carley, and well as continue Lee's budding friendship with Doug. If either of them had been alive in episode 4, I'm wondering if one of them would have an eye on Clem when she runs out of the house.
  • Viner16Viner16
    edited November 2012
    If Doug was alive, I can see him as watching over Omid (and Clem if you left her) while everyone else goes to Crawford, while Carley comes with you.
  • Shrewsbury SurvivorShrewsbury Survivor
    edited November 2012
    Lilly would of shot Kenny
  • SonnyN18SonnyN18
    edited November 2012
    Episode 4's ending would have been better if Lilly,Doug or Carley would have been in the positions where Christa and Omid were.
  • HiggsBoson2142HiggsBoson2142
    edited November 2012
    Doug saved: After Lee gets you-know-what, Kenny, Doug, and Ben live the rest of their lives as bros.
  • MoggyoxysMoggyoxys
    edited November 2012
    HiggsBoson2142 wrote: »
    Doug saved: After Lee gets you-know-what, Kenny, Doug, and Ben live the rest of their lives as bros.

    Kenny and Ben? After what went down in episode 3 and 4, I'm not too sure about that.:p
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited November 2012
    Duck would still be dead. Katjaa might not have killed herself with so many of the group left, but that's a pretty small maybe in the end. Lilly and Kenny probably would have "worked out" (in the loosest terms possible) their differences now that neither of them had anything left in the world. She probably wouldn't have shot him, as he would know exactly what she went through after the meat locker and Kenny would probably be a lot like he is now, but with more support from the group to pull him and Lilly out of their dark places. Plus, the end of Episode 4 would have been easier as there would have been more people to divide up between staying with the boat and going to save Clem.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    i say lee/carley would of seen lilly raise the gun then we have a stand off and lee has to choose 'who dies' that would of been more epic.

    so can shoot lilly/ben/ or doug/carley.

    of course to kill lilly would result in a miss or non lethal wound as she has plot armor.

    ben could be saved carley since she was standing up for him. but she kills him later when lee tells her he fessed up.

    doug will try to protect lilly. lee doesn't shoot but lilly does and offs doug or doug shoots lilly.

    katjaa and duck are prety much dead either way as they left the motel.

    carley kills molly in a panic.

    christa and carley have a fight over clem.

    omid and lee have words with kenny.
  • notborednotbored
    edited November 2012
    TheNNerdGamer wrote: »
    Carley: for me Carley and Lee would had turned out as a couple.
    Doug: I have no idea, maybe best bros 4 life?

    The disparity between these possible storylines is THE reason why both had to die. I'm not saying it's a good reason, but a romance between Carley and Lee would have been a punishment to those who saved Doug.
  • The_Cheshire_CatThe_Cheshire_Cat
    edited November 2012
    At some point Carley would have run out of bullets so her usefulness is limited.
  • cojemocojemo
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    i say lee/carley would of seen lilly raise the gun then we have a stand off and lee has to choose 'who dies' that would of been more epic.

    so can shoot lilly/ben/ or doug/carley.

    of course to kill lilly would result in a miss or non lethal wound as she has plot armor.

    ben could be saved carley since she was standing up for him. but she kills him later when lee tells her he fessed up.

    doug will try to protect lilly. lee doesn't shoot but lilly does and offs doug or doug shoots lilly.

    katjaa and duck are prety much dead either way as they left the motel.

    carley kills molly in a panic.

    christa and carley have a fight over clem.

    omid and lee have words with kenny.

    Why would Lilly "off" Doug? she was fine with him.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    in the struggle for the gun, lilly shoots doug 'anyway' or cos he was being a total wimp she offs him
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited November 2012
    I see Lilly and Kenny becoming friends... Well, not that "omg lest paint our nails sparkly together" kind of friends, but they would have got to understand each other. Lori said it herself in the comic books; people don't become friends because of common interests anymore, just because they share a common trauma. I can't picture Lilly getting drunk with Kenny (although would have been hilarious), but I do picture her with Kenny in the attic talking about their losses/apologizing, you know, supporting each other. If Kenny wasn't traumatized about his family's death, they could be a potential Snu-Snu material.

    Carley and Lee's romance would have bloomed in episode 4, that's for sure. Carley would have gone with Lee to find Clementine no matter what (Carley would have gone even if you were an ass to her, I'm guessing). I think she would have been arguing with Kenny if he was as depressed as he was in-game episode four; however, since Lilly would have been supporting Kenny (and making him feel less-depressed), I don't see this happening.

    I can't picture anything related to Doug, I didn't save him in episode 1, so I don't know what he is like, aside from a techy guy. I don't know him very well, and I don't know how he would have been at this point of the game. (I'm not a Doug hater, I just being honest..)

    Christa would have been more friendly to you when you first meet with her, I think she distrusted us because there were just men in our group. She instantly showed an interest in Clementine, I'm guessing she would have talked with Carley and become a more reliable person. Again, can't pcture what'd happen with Doug (sorry..)

    Omid would have been the same guy as before... He is missing in most part of episode four. Same Not-knowing-him-well-enough effect I have with Doug.

    Ben wouldn't have changed at all. He was pretty much destroyed with Katjaa and Duck's death, I don't think the way things worked out would have affected him. He'd have still confessed at Crawford, been grabbed by the walker at the bell tower, etc. He might wouldn't have fessed if Katjaa didn't suicide (it was not just Duck's death the reason she killed herself, Lilly leaving the group and Carley/Doug being shot affected her too, I'm guessing).
      Now, about some of in-game options.
    • Carley might have gone with you to the River front. This would kill one of those (bro or nobro) Kenny-Lee moments, though.
      If you showed the bite:
    • Lilly would have gone with you, and get Kenny to agree with you when going to find Clementine. /if you helped Lilly in the Meat locker.
    • Lilly would have said something similar to Kenny's "you weren't there for Katjaa and Duck" speech; Kenny would have agreed /if you helped Kenny kill Larry in the meat locker and didn't help his family.
    • Lilly would have said something similar to Kenny's "you weren't there for Katjaa and Duck" speech; Kenny would have denied and gone with you /if you showed the bite, helped Kenny kill Larry in the meat locker and helped his family.
    • Carley/Doug would have gone with you
    • Carley/Doug would have reacted the same way most of us did when they or shot in episode Three.
      If you hid the bite:
    • Kenny would have gone with you /pro Kenny walkthrough
    • Lilly would have gone with you /pro Lilly walkthrough
    • Carley/Doug would have gone with you, still /non-asshole-Lee walkthrough
    • Omid-Christa and Ben choices remain the same
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited November 2012
    ...and this is probably the longest reply I've ever written. I'm guessing I should he written a little less, now that I look at it again. Lol.
  • TheNNerdGamerTheNNerdGamer
    edited November 2012
    well that's another reason TTG killed the characters off.
    1. lazy
    2. not enough time
    3. too much story for them to finish off
    4. I have no Idea
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    yo ghositex Y U NO edit the long post to include the rather odd comment about your long post... ??!?!
  • NinnuendoNinnuendo
    edited November 2012
    Hmmm

    Honestly I think that yes, Carley ends up with Lee and that just tips Kenny over the edge. Not only does he lose his family and still have to cope with Lilly, but also Larley's and Chromids couple smugness. And Ben. He'd literally be surrounded by a group of people he either dislikes, hates or would feel are united against him.
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    yo ghositex Y U NO edit the long post to include the rather odd comment about your long post... ??!?!

    yo Milosuperspesh Y U NO edit your sig to include the rather odd comment about the rather odd comment about his long post......

    :p
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    yo Milosuperspesh Y U NO edit your sig to include the rather odd comment about the rather odd comment about his long post......

    :p

    whats my sig got to do with anything relevant to the double posting ?
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    About as much as passenger side modding. :p
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    About as much as passenger side modding. :p

    think your seat belt is too tight...

    and lolWUT....
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    Seriously dude, why so serious? :p
  • CyreenCyreen
    edited November 2012
    Alright kiddies, play nice.
    Shrewsbury Survivor wrote: »
    Lilly would of shot Kenny

    I think it would have been an interesting dynamic if Kenny had died and Katjaa and Duck survived. I think Katjaa would have toughened up nicely.
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    Oh I was just having fun with him. :p

    I think he finally realized that at the end.
  • FoxxyFoxFoxxyFox
    edited November 2012
    I would had love to see a interaction between Lilly, Christa & Carley or Lilly & Vernon to argue with eachother. I would directly agree with Lilly :D
  • kierano87kierano87
    edited November 2012
    To be honest lee wouldn't have time for him and carley to be a couple. It's him and clem all the way !
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    Oh I was just having fun with him. :p

    I think he finally realized that at the end.

    if you call being completely random and making no sense 'fun' to the point of mind numbing confusion

    sure i got it after the first 'odd post'
This discussion has been closed.