›

There should've been a part where you choose if Kenny or Clementine lives,

KennysBestBudKennysBestBud
edited December 2012 in The Walking Dead
Of course it'd be sad if someone chose Kenny not Clementine,
but I feel it would be a choice players would have trouble with.

Comments

  • PridePride
    edited November 2012
    I don't think there would have been such a choice because Kenny would definitely sacrifice himself for Clem if it ever came to the point where we had to choose between the two of them
  • KennysBestBudKennysBestBud
    edited November 2012
    But if it was like the Carley/Doug situation where both were trapped, Kenny couldn't do anything.
  • Luigi01080Luigi01080
    edited November 2012
    I think that kenny would have died either way like in episode 1 with shawn or duck. Or he would have a sacrifice for her. Not sure it would have mattered with lee still bitten and gonna die either way.
  • hoffa989hoffa989
    edited November 2012
    I think it would be pretty pointless to decide between a full grown man capable to defend himself and a samll girl. Yeah, that could have been done, but seeing most people love Kenny and Clem, you'd want them both to live, so pretty much everyone would help Clem and hope Kenny makes it. However, if someone chose to save Kenny instead of Clem, I think that would also be the end of Kenny - being saved over a child, after he had to shoot his own. Nah, pretty pointless.
  • george1120george1120
    edited November 2012
    KennysBestBud wrote: »
    Of course it'd be sad if someone chose Kenny not Clementine,
    but I feel it would be a choice players would have trouble with.

    I would pick the third option; not choosing either and Lee shoots himself to not bear the thought of it.
  • AwkwardlyNERDAwkwardlyNERD
    edited December 2012
    Nobody would have a problem with this decision.

    Pretty much everyone would choose Clementine without hesitation.

    Apart from me. I'd choose Kenny.

    Bad idea? Yes.
    Selfish idea? Yes.
    Am I still going to choose it? Yes.

    Kenny was my friend. I liked Kenny. He was in my top five favourite characters.

    Clementine just barely scraped into my top fifteen.

    Sure, I liked Clementine, I thought she was cute. But I held no real affection for her. She was just a kid I had to run and save.
  • Willzy123Willzy123
    edited December 2012
    KennysBestBud wrote: »
    Of course it'd be sad if someone chose Kenny not Clementine,
    but I feel it would be a choice players would have trouble with.

    This just wouldn't work, because then there would be 2 COMPLETELY DIFFERENT Season 2s.
  • ScaevaScaeva
    edited December 2012
    That sort of decision wouldn't have made sense. Choosing to save Clem would have just netted you "You and 98.5% of other players chose to save Clem" after the episode had concluded.

    Clem is practically Lee's daughter. Very few people were going to put another character first, other than perhaps to see what happens before reloading.
  • Gman5852Gman5852
    edited December 2012
    Willzy123 wrote: »
    This just wouldn't work, because then there would be 2 COMPLETELY DIFFERENT Season 2s.

    How do we know that without ever playing Season 2? We don't know if Clem will be a main character of it or even if she will be in the game.
  • Willzy123Willzy123
    edited December 2012
    Gman5852 wrote: »
    How do we know that without ever playing Season 2? We don't know if Clem will be a main character of it or even if she will be in the game.

    They wouldn't have made the after credits scene, if Clementine wasn't in Season 2.
  • dukeletodukeleto
    edited December 2012
    I have news for you. Not just because Clem is a little kid and she is the family but because Kenny is such a....
    Never mind :)

    This would be the way most EASIEST choice of the whole game. Thanks for making me laugh.
    Happy Holidays!
    :D
  • Gman5852Gman5852
    edited December 2012
    Willzy123 wrote: »
    They wouldn't have made the after credits scene, if Clementine wasn't in Season 2.

    They could've made that sequence just to show that Clementime doesn't die the moment she exists the building. Odds are Telltale won't just let Clementime's fate be unknown, but that really wasn't the point. The point is that we don't know that season 2 involves Clementime and we shouldn't expect her to yet.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited December 2012
    I'd choose Clem. Kenny is a good man, and wouldn't stand for me choosing his now-broken shell of a life over Clem. He's my bro, and I know he'd want me to make the smart choice of saving a child over him.
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited December 2012
    ... Every single person would chose Clementine, it wouldn't have even been a choice. The choice should have been between Lilly and Kenny, ultimately choosing who you want to be the leader. Or possibly strengthen Lee's relationship with Carley (or Doug) and then make you get to chose between them and Kenny.
  • watertommyzwatertommyz
    edited December 2012
    Willzy123 wrote: »
    They wouldn't have made the after credits scene, if Clementine wasn't in Season 2.

    I interpreted that scene as a means of connecting the player with feelings of uncertainty and to reflect on all of Lee's advise to reinforce what I believe to be the message of the game; did I really make the right choices? Will Clementine be ok with what I taught her?

    But I do believe she'll be in Season Two, but I don't know to what extent or what her purpose will be. She might even just have a cameo, or she may cause trouble for the new group. Who knows?
  • DildorDildor
    edited December 2012
    No, lol. 99% of people would easily choose Clem in that choice. Hell, Kenny would too.
  • montesinos7montesinos7
    edited December 2012
    fuck you guys i would choose Kenny
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited December 2012
    This game wasn't about Kenny and Lee - so no.
This discussion has been closed.