›

Which Lily?

TheRickGrimesTheRickGrimes
edited December 2012 in The Walking Dead
Comic Lily or Game Lily? ;3

Who's your favorite?

If you like them both, then just post. I can't edit the poll.

Comments

  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    what is the
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited December 2012
    i hate both
    Comic lily:Kills ricks wife and infant daughter
    Game lily:Kills doug/Carley
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited December 2012
    Kinda... vague.

    For what?

    Favorite? President? Target Practice?
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited December 2012
    Comic book Lilly had maybe three lines before she
    probably died
    so, game Lilly I guess? I know there's some inconsistencies but at the end of the day they are the same character so...
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited December 2012
    I don't see why I can't choose both game and comic Lilly. Game Lilly was made with the intent that it would be the same Lilly from the comics.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    seriously, what is the
  • TheRickGrimesTheRickGrimes
    edited December 2012
    I forgot to put both because I'm retarded.
  • marcu5marcu5
    edited December 2012
    comic lilly since she did something useless and killed lori
  • TheRickGrimesTheRickGrimes
    edited December 2012
    marcu5 wrote: »
    comic lilly since she did something useless and killed lori

    useful*
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    game lilly is better but i don't like her
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited December 2012
    marcu5 wrote: »
    comic lilly since she did something useless

    Comic Lilly inadvertently saved Rick's life. She got rid of the worst threat in the prison, which ultimately harmed Rick's group:
    The Governor.
    If Lilly had not done what she did, Rick would likely be dead. I'd like to think it's redemption for killing Doug/Carley.
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited December 2012
    marcu5 wrote: »
    comic lilly since she did something useless and killed lori

    But she also killed a baby
    Alsp didn't kirkman retcon them to be different people
  • TheRickGrimesTheRickGrimes
    edited December 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    Comic Lilly inadvertently saved Rick's life. She got rid of the worst threat in the prison, which ultimately harmed Rick's group:
    The Governor.
    If Lilly had not done what she did, Rick would likely be dead. I'd like to think it's redemption for killing Doug/Carley.

    Yup.
  • o0HeaDShoT0oo0HeaDShoT0o
    edited December 2012
    I was expecting Lilly to make an appearance in the TV series ever since season 3 started. But since Lori died after baby Judith was born, I guess she won't be making an appearance anytime soon.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    o0HeaDShoT0o wrote: »
    I was expecting Lilly to make an appearance in the TV series ever since season 3 started. But since Lori died after baby Judith was born, I guess she won't be making an appearance anytime soon.

    maybe she is that girl on with the bow that was on the wall with Andrea
  • YamiRazielYamiRaziel
    edited December 2012
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    maybe she is that girl on with the bow that was on the wall with Andrea

    Yeah, at first I thought it might be her too, but... nah I don't think so. If she's to appear, it has to happen very soon.

    As for the poll, both versions are awesome.
  • TheRickGrimesTheRickGrimes
    edited December 2012
    Who knows.

    We just know that when Lily appears, TWD will get 100% better.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    YamiRaziel wrote: »
    Yeah, at first I thought it might be her too, but... nah I don't think so. If she's to appear, it has to happen very soon.

    As for the poll, both versions are awesome.

    i think i am just looking for her and she is the only one that could fit, but yeah i wouldn't bet money on it being her or at least her role
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited December 2012
    Do I have to choose between game Lilly and comic Lilly? I mean, they're the same person after all...
  • plaqueconspiracyplaqueconspiracy
    edited December 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Do I have to choose between game Lilly and comic Lilly? I mean, they're the same person after all...

    But are they really, though?

    I have only read a few pages of the comic. Is the Game Lily Comic Lily? Do they have the same story and personality?
  • QuarterPounderVladQuarterPounderVlad
    edited December 2012
    Neither Lilly. DEATH TO LILLY!
  • SutinenSutinen
    edited December 2012
    Well, she was still a pretty good person before Larry died, so game Lily.
  • RobbingrobinRobbingrobin
    edited December 2012
    Uhm, Kirkman never confirmed that, I think.
  • MornaiMornai
    edited December 2012
    Robbingrobin wrote: »
    Uhm, Kirkman never confirmed that, I think.

    He stated that there was going to be a Lilly in the game, but whether or not it was the same as the comic was up to Telltale. Then they released that book...

    Game Lilly, though they are the same person in my eyes.
  • RobbingrobinRobbingrobin
    edited December 2012
    The book was just a crossover from the comic and itself, not a bridge between game and comic, though.

    Okay, its not important anyway. I like Lily, I would have gone with her~ Maybe Lee would still be alive, then?
  • trd84trd84
    edited December 2012
    Robbingrobin wrote: »
    Uhm, Kirkman never confirmed that, I think.

    Telltale removed all references that Lilly was from the comics before the book came out. They even changed the chapter in which Lilly left. It was named Off to Woodbury or something and they changed it.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited December 2012
    trd84 wrote: »
    Telltale removed all references that Lilly was from the comics before the book came out. They even changed the chapter in which Lilly left. It was named Off to Woodbury or something and they changed it.

    I noticed that too. I think it was called "Woodbury Bound" as the Steam achievement.
  • trd84trd84
    edited December 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    I noticed that too. I think it was called "Woodbury Bound" as the Steam achievement.

    Yeah that's what is was.
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited December 2012
    I remember some developer noting in a interview concerning episode 3 (it's a interviewing thing called 'Playing Dead' or something) that "Lilly had to leave to, ya know, go do her thing in Woodbury and meet up with Rick and his crew" (or something along those lines).

    It's just that stupid book that fucks with the continuity. Lilly in the game will always, too me, be the Lilly from the comics.
This discussion has been closed.