›

how to deal with the brothers

Apache00Apache00
edited December 2012 in The Walking Dead
http://youtu.be/akgcch6735Q

when watching this video i saw 55% killed danny but only 20% killed andy. i wondered why there is such a big difference. what reason is there for killing danny but not andy?

Comments

  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    a lot of people say it's because of Clementine's reaction to Lee killing danny that they don't kill andy
  • CharmingBirchCharmingBirch
    edited December 2012
    I didn't kill either one. Brenda being killed by reanimated Mark was enough for me.
  • DildorDildor
    edited December 2012
    Danny was a real creep. Plus those that did kill him see that it effects how Clem sees you and don't kill the other brother. Andy seemed like the least creepy of the bunch too, and his life is now completely fucked so why not leave him.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited December 2012
    Yeah, Andy pretty much wanted Lee to kill him. Many people did the opposite.
  • SutinenSutinen
    edited December 2012
    Danny was fucking crazy, I think that's the best point to kill him. I didn't though.
    Well, I did kill him on the second playtrough and Clementine got shocked.
    After that I didn't feel like killing Andy, but I did anyways since I wanted to see what happens. I think I frightened Clementine after that. I don't remember what the indicator said.
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited December 2012
    It has been discussed a lot; most of the players didn't kill Andy because Clementine saw them kill Danny. I didn't kill neither of them, though. I would have killed Danny if he hadn't told me to eat him and all of that psycho crap, you know? The guy was going to die one way or another (Zombies, blood loss, infection..), and killing him would save him from a really painful while; but since Lee was mad at that point of the game, it would have been a revenge-kill, rather than a mercy-kill.
  • plaqueconspiracyplaqueconspiracy
    edited December 2012
    Danny was a psycho and was also pretty much doomed with his foot stuck in a bear trap.

    It was just sad to see Andy begging on his knees. I think his death if you let him live is way more... justified. He gets torn up by his own zombie mother. Now, that's fucked up. But so was he. Very emotional scene.



    In the first playthrough I killed neither but when I played it again I just felt like fuck it, these guys have done so much harm they deserve to not be able to do any more.
  • trd84trd84
    edited December 2012
    It's a mix between clem seeing you kill the 1st one. And the whole group watching you beat up the 2nd one.
  • TyrantTyrant
    edited December 2012
    TBH, if you look at the Andy scene. Your entire group is watching you, especially Clementine, some of them know that you're a convicted murderer.

    It's a simple detail, and it's well done

    I killed Danny on my first play through, on my second I didn't kill either of them. What would be the point? Other than to prove that I can become a monster just like them.

    I killed Ben on both playthroughs though. When I think about how he left an eight year old by herself repeatedly and gave me attitude about it, I just found it annoying.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited December 2012
    Tyrant wrote: »
    TBH, if you look at the Andy scene. Your entire group is watching you, especially Clementine, some of them know that you're a convicted murderer.

    It's a simple detail, and it's well done

    I killed Danny on my first play through, on my second I didn't kill either of them. What would be the point? Other than to prove that I can become a monster just like them.

    I killed Ben on both playthroughs though. When I think about how he left an eight year old by herself repeatedly and gave me attitude about it, I just found it annoying.

    well i guess you are called Tyrant for a reason :D
  • DemopanDemopan
    edited December 2012
    I thought the worst I could do to Danny in that moment was kill hi, so I stabbed him. But Andy, oh ho, andy. I killed his family, destroyed his home and mashed his face into an unrecognizable pulp. Killing him would have been too quick a death, so I left him to the walkers.
  • Kiel555Kiel555
    edited December 2012
    Huh, I killed both of them without hesitation. Are you saying that leaving them alive would be worse? Because I actually wanted what was worse for them.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited December 2012
    Kiel555 wrote: »
    Huh, I killed both of them without hesitation. Are you saying that leaving them alive would be worse? Because I actually wanted what was worse for them.

    It's definately worse for Andy, especially if you tell him that his family is dead. Danny is debateable, but since I didn't know walkers were going to overrun the farm, I killed him so he wouldn't be able to come after us if he got out of the bear trap. Getting pitchforked can't be a good way to go, but it might be better than walkers. There's also the possibility of him bleeding out before the walkers even get there, which won't be pleasant either.
  • KaserkinKaserkin
    edited December 2012
    I left Danny to die in the trap. I already "tasered" him, Lilly stabbed him with a hook and I was sure he couldn't make it. Andy wasn't in such bad shape, but when I saw the zombies I knew he wouldn't make it, so I decided to not put his blood on my hands.
  • dustpuffsdustpuffs
    edited December 2012
    I killed them both. I wasn't taking any chances with people that killed my friends. If I'm teaching Clementine to kill or be killed, so be it.
  • notoriousmercynotoriousmercy
    edited December 2012
    I killed Danny because I had no idea I could just walk away. Left Andy alive cause I saw how he was suffering after hearing that both Danny and momma were dead. That was a better punishment than to finish him off.
  • HudomonkeyHudomonkey
    edited December 2012
    I couldn't kill them

    Danny was already dead because of the bear trap and Andy lost everyone ad everything was doomed to death by walker

    I'm not a murderer...
    ...
    Well I suppose Lee is but not in front of Clem
    I agree with the Stranger on some points
    You're A MONSTER
This discussion has been closed.