›

Would your opinion be different if...

noskinoahnoskinoah
edited February 2013 in The Walking Dead
Would your opinion on Telltale's The Walking Dead be different, if telltale actually made a 2.5 hour movie instead of a game? It was animated the same way it did in the game, same actors, same story and performance - but you wouldn't be playing it. You would be watching it on the big screen.

Comments

  • SeriousScarSeriousScar
    edited January 2013
    It practically was a movie, besides the few shooting sections and quick time events. I don't even describe it to friends as a game because its misleading. Its more like an interactive story. However, unlike a movie your actions dictate how the characters act towards you.

    So it wouldn't be as good if it were just a movie, it would still be a good movie though. Thus my opinion of it would be lower.

    (Also I wonder if people would have the same emotional connection to Clem if it were just a movie. That was probably the strongest part of the story for me)
  • distortiondistortion
    edited January 2013
    Yeah, I also usually describe as being an interactive movie where you get to control the actions of one of the characters.


    That's a fantastic question about Clem, though. If we weren't able to control Lee, our opinion of Clem would likely be drastically different. In essence, it was us that she was talking to, something that would not be true if we were simply watching a movie. So we wouldn't care nearly as much about her well-being.
  • BenIsKindaCoolBenIsKindaCool
    edited January 2013
    SeriousScar wrote: »
    It practically was a movie..

    I think it was a game..And like Dave Fennoy said:''it's the gaming world growing up''

    Anywho,I think I would like it.When I like this game,then why not movie.I just hope that in the movie there would be some things diffrent,if you follow me?
  • Snake LiquidSnake Liquid
    edited January 2013
    Certainly, I would still like it and watch it. The story was excellent, in my opinion. I would not have had the emotional attachment that I had to the characters if it was just a movie however, which makes it much better suited as a game.

    Very few movies have ever gotten me attached to the characters. I watch them, and by the end don't really care who lived or died, or where they end up. Sometimes I don't even remember some of the characters names. Good sequel movies that continue building the characters are the exception, like Star Wars.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited January 2013
    playing it is way better than just watching it, people that have only watched the game on you tube don't know what they are missing, being responsible for making the decisions and setting the tone yourself is so much better than just passively just watching something.

    there should be a "yes i would watch it but it would not be as good as the game" option
  • ClemOwnedYouClemOwnedYou
    edited January 2013
    Some of these topics I swear its Telltale logging in and asking questions.
    Just worry about getting season 2 out already!
  • AnnaSanAnnaSan
    edited January 2013
    I prefer playing the game and choosing his dialogues, because I want to know how my word choices would affect my relationship with the other characters. Plus, you'd be able to put yourself in Lee's shoes and see things from his perspective, making it a much better experience.
  • GhositexGhositex
    edited January 2013
    When you play the game, you feel you're Lee, and that you're the one making decisions. If it was a movie, you'd be watching Lee making his own decisions, and wouldn't attach to it that much. I'd probably watch the movie and still enjoy it, though.
  • TornreaperTornreaper
    edited January 2013
    Absolutely. TWDTG strikes me as a movie (Just with interactivity) as it is. As a video game It's missing good gameplay. If it was a movie it would fix all my problems with it.
  • TychoxiTychoxi
    edited February 2013
    I would watch it and probably like it but I don't think a movie format would have conveyed half the emotional weight. And I'm not sure I would have been so forgiving on some stupid things. Even with all the false choices and etc, it wouldn't be the same at all.
  • DAISHIDAISHI
    edited February 2013
    You lose all the consequence of being responsible for your own damn words and actions. It's not a game, its not a movie, its something awesome,
  • MornaiMornai
    edited February 2013
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    there should be a "yes i would watch it but it would not be as good as the game" option

    Completely agreed. There is zero chance that it would have anywhere near as much effect were it a movie. It simply does not work without the player being involved. I'm sure it would still be fantastic, but the emotional connection would never feel the same. The level of that the game achieved is something a game and only a game can reach(in this situation).
  • slimymeteorslimymeteor
    edited February 2013
    It'd have to be a miniseries. We grew to care about these characters more and more over the course of the game, and you could never rival that kind of character development with one movie. That's why I feel the Walking Dead game, comics and show are all better than any zombie movie.
  • HudomonkeyHudomonkey
    edited February 2013
    It was a point and click by Telltale and that is why I played it

    I'm not a walking dead fan or zombie fan but I love Telltale so I'm willing to give their games a shot even if it is a bit different
    I'm not sure a movie would be as appealing
  • AdvancedAdvanced
    edited February 2013
    DAISHI wrote: »
    You lose all the consequence of being responsible for your own damn words and actions. It's not a game, its not a movie, its something awesome,

    This.

    I would give a great example right now to backup my point and show it wouldn't work as a movie, but this is the spoiler-free section.
  • loobylooby
    edited February 2013
    Like most other people, I wouldn't have got as attached to the characters and wouldn't have cared what happens to a lot of them if it was a movie. Taking responsibility for Lee's actions and looking after Clem is what we love about it. As a film it'd just be any old zombie flick, perhaps just slightly more dramatic.
  • JordyLichtJordyLicht
    edited February 2013
    My girlfriend almost ordered me to do another playthrough, so she could watch the story. She's a huge Walking Dead fan, but doesn't like gaming, so for her, it was more a movie than a game.
This discussion has been closed.