›

Everything for her...

zev_zevzev_zev
edited February 2013 in The Walking Dead
If in second season you will have a difficult situation for example: the bandits seized the camp of your group, and set the group to his knees, but you and Clem are near the car, and you can quickly grab Clementine and jump in the car and drive away, leaving their people to certain death, or can not betray your people, and try do something with risk for your and Clem's life.
The situation can be any! Please don't pay much attention to my example. Just the question is: are you ready to betray their own group for the sake of that would ensure the safety of Clementines?
If you watched "Lost" you must remember
guy named Michael, he betrayed his group for saved his son. He led his friends to "others" whom gave him the boat for this, and he swam away from the island, together with his son.
So, you have a similar situation, what do you choose?

Comments

  • RiadonRiadon
    edited February 2013
    Clementine is my daughter, the group can go fuck itself.

    :D:D:D

    Of course, it depends on the situation. If the camp is completely overrun, fuck the group. If there are just a few bandits and I think I can take them, I will choose the group.
  • double_udouble_u
    edited February 2013
    It might depend on the group. If it was a group of Larry's, Ben's, and Lilly's... well ;)

    Otherwise, I won't betray my group, because I have a responsibility to both Clem AND my group. If it's a group of good people I get along with, they'll be part of the extended family so to speak. If Clem and I were in the opposite position, I'd hope my group would save us too.

    And if I look at from a more practical perspective, saving the group now means they owe me a favour for a rainy day in the future.
  • AdvancedAdvanced
    edited February 2013
    I am a very loyal person so that in itself wouldn't let me do it. But knowing Clementine.... she would NOT approve of us leaving everyone behind, as a example: She stood up for Ben in Crawford.... after he left her to die with he zombies.

    I cannot see Clementine living with that decision, nor do I see myself living with that. A traitor is something I will not become and if it was up to me I would raise Clementine the same way.
  • AnnaSanAnnaSan
    edited February 2013
    I love Clementine, but I can't leave the group behind...
    So yeah, I'll take the risk and try to calm the bandits down >.>
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited February 2013
    I'm not betraying my group. Clem says it herself at Crawford. "We don't leave friends behind". I'd make sure that she stays out of the way, but I'm not letting the group die if I can help it.
  • o0HeaDShoT0oo0HeaDShoT0o
    edited February 2013
    Advanced wrote: »
    I am a very loyal person so that in itself wouldn't let me do it. But knowing Clementine.... she would NOT approve of us leaving everyone behind, as a example: She stood up for Ben in Crawford.... after he left her to die with he zombies.

    I cannot see Clementine living with that decision, nor do I see myself living with that. A traitor is something I will not become and if it was up to me I would raise Clementine the same way.

    You and me both, pal.
  • gimmeseason2gimmeseason2
    edited February 2013
    Riadon wrote: »
    Clementine is my daughter, the group can go fuck itself.
    exactly
  • JordyLichtJordyLicht
    edited February 2013
    Clementine all the way.
    Otherwise it feels like game over. Clementine dying isn't an option at this point.
  • MornaiMornai
    edited February 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    I'm not betraying my group. Clem says it herself at Crawford. "We don't leave friends behind". I'd make sure that she stays out of the way, but I'm not letting the group die if I can help it.

    Agreed. I may reconsider if it was a bunch of Larry's who have done nothing but try to kill me ever since the apocalypse began, but otherwise... my life will go before anyone else.

    I'd probably tell Clem to run away(presuming this is when she knows how to shoot and etc.) then confront the bandits. To quote a certain someone: "If we're not back by nightfall, we're not coming back at all."
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited February 2013
    I have not yet replied to my own question. I'm not ready to betray the people who helped me. Im not a rat. But if the group would attacked by The Saviours (Negan's gang)... just imagine what Negan can do with little Clemmy... I need to think more.
    P.S. I repeat that the situation can be any, not necessarily the bandit attack.
  • KaserkinKaserkin
    edited February 2013
    No. I'll rather kill Clem myself so the bandits don't get her, but I'm no turncoat.
  • sQOrPIONsQOrPION
    edited February 2013
    No, wont leave my group.I would probably tell Clementine to hide until bandits gone
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited February 2013
    Fuck over the group to save a kid.... well we saw how well that worked for Rick....

    I'd be sad, but Clem would be a zombie happy meal.

    Well, depending on the group....
  • RonedorRonedor
    edited February 2013
    Oh,its wery difficul chose,but I think we should left the group for saving them later.
    If we wouldn't left them behind , it means that everybody can die.
  • ZeroShootZeroShoot
    edited February 2013
    That strongly depends on the situation, since you're speaking of just any situation.
    If i was sure she would die, I would sacrifice the group for her sake, but if the odds were good we could save everybody I would give it a try.
    It's a nasty decision... gamble with the live of your loved one(s) or leave a whole group of people to die for sure.
    Kenny would take Duck and run off.

    It also depends on the people left in the group, like: Are there friends of mine left? Are there other kids?

    One thing I know for sure, I would catch the bullets for Clem, if they noticed us while trying to save the group, and quickly tell her to run away.
  • RonedorRonedor
    edited February 2013
    ZeroShoot wrote: »
    That strongly depends on the situation, since you're speaking of just any situation.
    If i was sure she would die, I would sacrifice the group for her sake, but if the odds were good we could save everybody I would give it a try.
    It's a nasty decision... gamble with the live of your loved one(s) or leave a whole group of people to die for sure.
    Kenny would take Duck and run off.

    It also depends on the people left in the group, like: Are there friends of mine left? Are there other kids?

    One thing I know for sure, I would catch the bullets for Clem, if they noticed us while trying to save the group, and quickly tell her to run away.

    I totally agree with you, but whatever you decide, if you do not know what will happen after your choice?
    In the group are all good people, but there is a risk of losing them in the event of an escape. If not escape you have a risk losing Clem .
    P.S sorry for my english .
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited February 2013
    Ronedor wrote: »
    In the group are all good people

    It isn't fact that everybody in the group are good people. Maybe someone in the group is traitor or he planning something bad... it's "The Walking Dead"
  • RonedorRonedor
    edited February 2013
    zev_zev what about you ? what do you say about this situation ? What chance of survival if you're caught? what the bandits are atacked our group ? ... Precisely describe the situation please, because its very difficult quastion if we dont know all details .
  • ZeroShootZeroShoot
    edited February 2013
    Ronedor wrote: »
    P.S sorry for my english .
    Don't worry, you're doing good. :cool:
  • RonedorRonedor
    edited February 2013
    zev_zev wrote: »
    It isn't fact that everybody in the group are good people. Maybe someone in the group is traitor or he planning something bad... it's "The Walking Dead"

    can you tell us all the details of the situation ?
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited February 2013
    Ronedor wrote: »
    zev_zev what about you ? what do you say about this situation ? What chance of survival if you're caught? what the bandits are atacked our group ? ... Precisely describe the situation please, because its very difficult quastion if we dont know all details .

    No one deserves to be betrayed... Clem would never forgive this decision, she's not stupid, we could lying her that they are sacrificed theirselves (as like we can told her about Ben death), but I'm not sure that she would trust us this time. It's depended of group, and how thay relate to Clem.
  • RonedorRonedor
    edited February 2013
    zev_zev wrote: »
    No one deserves to be betrayed... Clem would never forgive this decision, she's not stupid, we could lying her that they are sacrificed theirselves (as like we can told her about Ben death), but I'm not sure that she would trust us this time. It's depended of group, and how thay relate to Clem.

    I know no one deserves to be betrayed, and i know that Clem did not believe us if we lie... but we need more information about our group and about bandits , for to do our choice .
  • zev_zevzev_zev
    edited February 2013
    Ronedor wrote: »
    I know no one deserves to be betrayed, and i know that Clem did not believe us if we lie... but we need more information about our group and about bandits , for to do our choice .


    Why only a bandits? How about the horde of walkers?

    So, I made a choice and I'll trying to explain my decision. When I played at first time I didn't left Lilly behind. To be honest I like her more then Carley. When she was free of the handcuffs and told me to leaved the group, together with her: "...to walk hand in hand into the sunset" - as Shane told, I said that I'm ready to run away with her and Clem, because I was tired of this group, I'm tired of the whining of Kenny, annoyed me that Kenny constantly throws me in trouble. Well I thought that leaving group with Lilly is the best way for me.

    After
    Lillys betrayal,
    I didn't be anger to her so much, but after this I was very ashamed in front of Kenny. He was a good guy, but I understood it too late.

    Few hours later when I discussed the plan with Clementine, I told her that we must leave the group "You and me, we are stronger togeather". But when I had a choice between saving Ben or killing him, I was saved him. He's a person, he's a Clem's best friend, and by my opinion he didn't deserve this death.

    I ready to leaving a group if they irritate me, or if I thinking that they are dangerous for Clementine.

    But I can't leave in group in critical danger situation.

    I'm not a traitor - this is my vote.
This discussion has been closed.