Everyone on first. Everyone bar Lilly which lead to the great scene at the RV when Lilly tries to use Lee's past against him by telling Kenny(thinking that he doesn't know), and him simply replying that he "doesn't give a shit".
I told all on first playthrough but in my second I did the following.
Lily: Her dad apparently told her anyways since she uses it against you even if you don't tell her so I saw no point in confirming it for her.
Katjaa: She seemed so dissapointed and sad after telling her I went to prison and about the meat locker so I figured with everything that would soon happened she didn't need the extra burden.
Clem: She already kinda knew from episode 1 but I felt I should really have a conversation with her about it.
Kenny: He deserved to know since we were bros and all.
Ben: Told him because I actually was hoping to scare him out of the group. xD
Comments
You can never tell Doug, since you need Carley to be able to tell anyone at all.
A "no one" option would be good, though.
I meant an option for those who were unable to
I would have if I could have but I chose Doug so I was unable
I think telling No one and not being able to tell anyone are different enough to result in different options
Lily: Her dad apparently told her anyways since she uses it against you even if you don't tell her so I saw no point in confirming it for her.
Katjaa: She seemed so dissapointed and sad after telling her I went to prison and about the meat locker so I figured with everything that would soon happened she didn't need the extra burden.
Clem: She already kinda knew from episode 1 but I felt I should really have a conversation with her about it.
Kenny: He deserved to know since we were bros and all.
Ben: Told him because I actually was hoping to scare him out of the group. xD
I wonder why we can't tell Duck...
*You chose to shoot Duck yourself*
xD Why not? It'd be another Carley situation. --> *She will remember you stuck up for her* then dies lol.