›

Which episode you liked more and which episode you hated more in TWD?

walking dead loverwalking dead lover
edited April 2013 in The Walking Dead
1.I liked episode 2 more than the other episodes because It had a great story and there was many hard choices in it.

2.I hated episode 5 because your choices (like cutting Lee,s arm) did not affect.

This is my idea:

1.episode 2 (the best)
2.episode 4
3.episode 3
4.episode 1
5.episode 5 (the worst)

Please VOTE!
Thanks.

Comments

  • gimmeseason2gimmeseason2
    edited March 2013
    1.Episode 2
    2.Episode 1
    3.Episode 3
    4.Episode 5
    5.Episode 4
  • The FallenThe Fallen
    edited March 2013
    I loved episode 2. The choices were all great, i enjoyed the pacing of the episode. The atmosphere was perfect throughout and i personally preferred the group composition as it was then. I wish that had lasted a little longer.

    I cant say i hated any of the episodes though. All of them clearly very well made with some great moment. If i had to choose though i'd go for 3, simply because as i said i really liked the group dynamic that got destroyed that episode. Not to say it wasn't a fantastic work of art, it produced some of the seasons most shocking moments, but i hold a personal grudge against it. :p
  • ZeroShootZeroShoot
    edited March 2013
    1. Episode 5 - Epic (no, epic is no over overstatement here) ending, for an epic game, first game ever to make me cry, even after watching the ending for the 10th time.
    2. Episode 3 - Because of the great, melancholic atmosphere, and due to the great moments with Clem (teaching to shoot, cutting hair etc.).
    3. Episode 2 - Because, except for the Episode 2 finale, world seemed normal, and it was great seeing everybody relaxed, especially when knowing what is to come yet.
    4. Episode 4 - Some of the toughest choices I had to make, took place here, and I regret so many of them....
    5. Episode 1 - It's not "bad" it is just... not as epic as the Episodes above, in my opinion.

    But if I had to rate each one of them it'd be like this: E1 9.3 E2 9.5 E3 9.7 E4 9.6 and E5 9.8 - I consider them as a whole game.

    I decided to give reasons, so people could see, why I chose what I chose, I hope, that's not a problem.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited March 2013
    Episode 3 was the best. It was the episode which ended character arcs, and started other ones. The score for the overall episode was awesome too.

    I didn't like episode 4. To me, it had a shortage of human drama. The entire episode just screamed zombie action to me.
  • That1GuyThat1Guy
    edited March 2013
    1. Episode 3-Represented the lack of hope and how you can't change someone's fate no matter what you do REALLY well and Episode 5-The only time I actually almost cried because of a game.
    2. Episode 4-Unlike a lot of people I really liked this one, the Ben choice was one of tthe most intersting moments of the game and Imloved Molly.
    3. Episode 2-I don't like this one as much as other people because it's kinda predictable IMO. The best thing about it is the Larry choice.
    4. Episode 1-It was just kind of boring and the choices were kind of lackluster.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited March 2013
    Episode 2
    Episode 4
    Episode 1
    Episode 5
    Episode 3

    In that order :P
  • BritishBurgerBritishBurger
    edited March 2013
    in order:

    Episode 5- the ending made me cry. so yeah.
    Episode 3
    Episode 2
    Episode 4
    Episode 1

    none were bad.
  • MornaiMornai
    edited March 2013
    5->3->4->2->1

    Loved five because it was epic, three because i liked the scenery and it was heartbreaking, and the rest, well...i don't know, just enjoyed them at about the same levels.
  • anderswhkanderswhk
    edited March 2013
    Definetly episode 2. None of the episodes were bad, 2 just stands out.
  • RiadonRiadon
    edited March 2013
    5>2>3>4>>>>>>>>>>1
  • MikejamesMikejames
    edited March 2013
    I think every episode had their highlights, but it's probably a tie between 2 and 5 for me.

    Episode 2 was the best for successfully meshing calm and tense interactions. Moving from panicking over the bear trap, to slowly trying to deal with rations and group conflict, from peacefully pushing Clementine on the swing to escaping from the locker, the tone of the pacing had a wide and successful range. I thought the St. John twist was a bit obvious going in, but the overall execution was good enough for me to look past it.

    Episode 5 was the emotional culmination of your relationships with Clem and the remaining survivors, and had to be the most hard hitting for me. A race against time with Lee finally moving alone against the horde juxtaposed with the calm back-and-forth with the stranger, and a final exchange with Clementine that brought genuine tears.
  • HudomonkeyHudomonkey
    edited March 2013
    Episode 2 was the best episode if it were the choice of pick one episode to play and no other but Episode 5 was a great conclusion and was the best if you played all the others.
    Episode 2 was really well done and stands up on its own but episode 5 was the conclusion where your decisions truly begin to mean something making it also the best
  • staticflstaticfl
    edited March 2013
    Mikejames wrote: »
    I think every episode had their highlights, but it's probably a tie between 2 and 5 for me.

    Episode 2 was the best for successfully meshing calm and tense interactions. Moving from panicking over the bear trap, to slowly trying to deal with rations and group conflict, from peacefully pushing Clementine on the swing to escaping from the locker, the tone of the pacing had a wide and successful range. I thought the St. John twist was a bit obvious going in, but the overall execution was good enough for me to look past it.

    Episode 5 was the emotional culmination of your relationships with Clem and the remaining survivors, and had to be the most hard hitting for me. A race against time with Lee finally moving alone against the horde juxtaposed with the calm back-and-forth with the stranger, and a final exchange with Clementine that brought genuine tears.

    I agree...perfect descriptions.
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited March 2013
    1. Episode 5
    2. Episode 3
    3. Episode 2
    4. Episode 1
    5. Episode 4
  • walking dead loverwalking dead lover
    edited March 2013
    I wish there could be a happier ending in the episode 5.
  • amigosolitarioamigosolitario
    edited March 2013
    1 win and 5 bad
  • DildorDildor
    edited March 2013
    2, 3, 5, 4, 1

    Everything about 2 was so perfect, great characters, and awesome twists.
    Episode 3 was the most heartbreaking and emotional, it's only topped by 5 for sad-factor.
  • The Girl From AusThe Girl From Aus
    edited March 2013
    Episode 2 was the best
    Episode 3 really screwed me over
    Episode 4 was the less eventful one but that was just cause of the build up for episode 5..

    *TEARS*
  • Cthulhu42Cthulhu42
    edited March 2013
    2 > 5 > 1 > 4 > 3
  • JakeSt123JakeSt123
    edited April 2013
    5 -really well scripted, even if barely anyone lived.
    2 -the story was very good
    4 -seemingly had the greatest amount of locations.
    1 -where everything started
    3 -kinda... bores me whenever I play it.
  • RabidMonkeyRabidMonkey
    edited April 2013
    1 - I love this one as it sets up your relationship with Clem and its where you meet most of the original characters.
    2 - Just loved the story overall, everything fitted perfectly plot wise.
    5 - the feels at the end, 'nuff said
    3 - I'm on the fence with this one. The first half of this episode was really good and felt really nice especially all the heartwarming scenes at the motor inn and had tonnes of emotion due to deaths. But the second half I felt nothing for. Mainly because all the characters I cared about died previously and in this episode. I couldn't get into this episode after Carley died as it felt like a needless death. Though Kat and Ducks deaths were brilliantly done.
    4 - Cared about no-one in this episode except Lee and Clem. Was decent but when there are only 2 characters you care about and your favorite died previously you kinda feel down afterwards and can't get into the rest.

    Biased opinion due to character deaths in episode 3. Yes I am talking about Carley.
This discussion has been closed.