›

The Stranger

saladdayssaladdays
edited May 2013 in The Walking Dead
Does the stranger's attitude toward you change at all depending on the people that you killed, let die, etc. throughout the game? I mean, if I avoided death as much as possible, will his dialogue change (other than not mentioning the event itself)? For example, if I let both St. Johns live, will he care any differently than if I killed them both? Or will he simply just not bring it up and his other dialogue is the same?

Comments

  • FoxxyFoxFoxxyFox
    edited April 2013
    From what I know he will not change much and some dialogues like the one with Lilly or the St. Johns will not be mention when you let them live or take Lilly with you.
  • crispy01crispy01
    edited April 2013
    From what I can tell, he will still hate your guts, but he will hate your guts more if you chose the less moral options more often. You can't dissuade him from his path, but you can make him at least respect you, kinda. I believe he takes Clem for revenge if you play as douche bag Lee, or takes her for protection (and insanity) if you're nice Lee.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited April 2013
    seems like he was more focused on what you did to his car and supplies and how much bad stuff clem as been through/seen/done.
  • Rommel49Rommel49
    edited April 2013
    He's not a fan no matter what you do. There's certain stuff he'll blame you for regardless, e.g. the Doug/Carley choice... if nothing else, he'll hold that against you no matter which one you pick.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited April 2013
    Yeah, you can't win. No matter what you chose he will hate. Leave her at the house when you are at Crawford? He'll be pissed because 1 walker made it inside and could have killed her. Take her to Crawford? Tells you how she would have been alone(exactly what he snaps about otherwise). He gets mad if you try to go to the dairy, as if you knew they were messed up people(I knew ;) ). So what happens if you try not to go to the dairy? He gets pissed that you didn't try to keep her safe and fed;protected.

    I just feel like going "Asshole, I'm a fucking time traveler, and no matter what choice I make you get a temper tantrum over doing the exact opposite. If I could do both to shut you the fuck up, I would. You'd probably get more mad I broke the fourth wall, you damn hypocrite. And at least I have my little girl, and my lover lasted longer. Your wife is in a bag, and you had two kids; where are they? I thought you said you could do better!? What happened bud? Well hurry up Clem, slap him upside the head so I can kill him already..."

    Is that an option? Can I choose that dialogue? Sometimes I have to remember this is a game.
  • Cthulhu42Cthulhu42
    edited April 2013
    I played a mostly ruthless/pragmatic Lee (killed the St. Johns, stole the food, abandoned Lilly, dropped Ben), so the Stranger was pretty furious with me for virtually all my choices.

    I kept my ruthless streak going when I then strangled him to death with my one remaining hand and then shot him in the head.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited April 2013
    ^lol
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited April 2013
    i made clem kill him

    felt she needed to do it, that way she gets over her fear of killing walkers ;)

    i'm evil aren't i ?
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited April 2013
    If he had sneezed, and Lee had forgotten to say "Bless you," he probably would have shot him. Dude's fucked up.
  • Jaded X GamerJaded X Gamer
    edited April 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    If he had sneezed, and Lee had forgotten to say "Bless you," he probably would have shot him. Dude's fucked up.

    I always thought it'd be funny if he held leaving Duck hanging against you. :D
  • saladdayssaladdays
    edited April 2013
    Jaded X Gamer wrote: »
    I always thought it'd be funny if he held leaving Duck hanging against you. :D

    :)

    But yeah, I guess it makes sense that he would find faults with whatever you do. I think he basically is trying to find ways of not liking you even more.
  • The FallenThe Fallen
    edited April 2013
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    i made clem kill him

    felt she needed to do it, that way she gets over her fear of killing walkers ;)

    i'm evil aren't i ?

    I had no idea killing him yourself was even an option until i saw it on the decisions screen post-game :p
  • The FallenThe Fallen
    edited April 2013
    saladdays wrote: »
    :)

    But yeah, I guess it makes sense that he would find faults with whatever you do. I think he basically is trying to find ways of not liking you even more.

    My interpretation is that he's more trying to justify taking Clementine to himself, if he can prove that you're some kind of monster then he can convince himself that he isn't.
  • Cthulhu42Cthulhu42
    edited April 2013
    The Fallen wrote: »
    I had no idea killing him yourself was even an option until i saw it on the decisions screen post-game :p
    I actually had no idea that not killing him was an option until I saw it on the decision screen.
  • Clemmy1Clemmy1
    edited April 2013
    Cthulhu42 wrote: »
    I played a mostly ruthless/pragmatic Lee (killed the St. Johns, stole the food, abandoned Lilly, dropped Ben), so the Stranger was pretty furious with me for virtually all my choices.

    I kept my ruthless streak going when I then strangled him to death with my one remaining hand and then shot him in the head.

    hahaha 'me too' ;)
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited April 2013
    Jaded X Gamer wrote: »
    I always thought it'd be funny if he held leaving Duck hanging against you. :D

    I can see it now.

    Stranger: "A little boy wanted a high-five from you, but you you just walked away!"

    Lee:
    1) "I fucked up."
    2) "You weren't there!"
    3) "I'd do it again!"
    4) "..."
  • Shrewsbury SurvivorShrewsbury Survivor
    edited April 2013
    Jaded X Gamer wrote: »
    I always thought it'd be funny if he held leaving Duck hanging against you. :D
    Stranger "You left a inteligent child who helped you out Hanging?"
    Lee: 1) He had it coming
    2) I wouldnt do that again
    3) Ducks inteligent?
    Stranger "Your a monster!"
  • Shrewsbury SurvivorShrewsbury Survivor
    edited April 2013
    1) Strangers: You didnt give that Girl her hat back. Her dad bought her that for christ sake

    Lee: The same dad you said is alive to get her hear (Omid appears out of thin air to bro fist. Then disappears again)

    2) Stranger: You left at night killing Chet

    3) Stranger: You gave her Beef Jerky!
  • MikejamesMikejames
    edited April 2013
    Shrewsbury Survivor wrote: »
    3) Stranger: You gave her Beef Jerky!
    I Bet You Didn't Even Know That Apples Were Her Favorite!!
  • saladdayssaladdays
    edited April 2013
    The Fallen wrote: »
    My interpretation is that he's more trying to justify taking Clementine to himself, if he can prove that you're some kind of monster then he can convince himself that he isn't.

    I agree. Trying to put you down to make himself look better.
  • IsmokeherbIsmokeherb
    edited April 2013
    Cthulhu42 wrote: »
    I played a mostly ruthless/pragmatic Lee (killed the St. Johns, stole the food, abandoned Lilly, dropped Ben), so the Stranger was pretty furious with me for virtually all my choices.

    I kept my ruthless streak going when I then strangled him to death with my one remaining hand and then shot him in the head.

    I did everything the same except for dropping Ben. Did you chop your arm off alone as well?
  • double_udouble_u
    edited April 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    i can see it now.

    Stranger: "a little boy wanted a high-five from you, but you you just walked away!"

    lee:
    1) "i fucked up."
    2) "you weren't there!"
    3) "i'd do it again!"
    4) "..."

    lol :d
  • SLH1222SLH1222
    edited May 2013
    He doesn't say as much about you, mainly because you wouldn't have done anything bad to talk about.
  • Supporter of LillySupporter of Lilly
    edited May 2013
    He mainly accused me for the carley thing other than that really nothing
This discussion has been closed.